Changelog
How we correct
Corrections to a published claim are logged here, with the date they were made and the pages they affected. We now aim to add a dated note to every corrected page; earlier entries show that was not always done: one entry below records a correction, made in early August 2026, that went unrecorded here until more than a month later. Where the error was ours, an error of fact, attribution, sourcing or reading, we label it a Correction. Where our reporting was accurate when we wrote it and the facts have since moved on, such as a closure being confirmed or a consultation closing, we label it an Update instead. New pages and posts are listed separately, as are changes to the site itself, such as design, navigation or images, that did not change what a page claims. The original wording of this log, before it was reorganised on 26 September 2026, is kept in full at the changelog archive.
At a glance
| Date | Corrections | Updates | New | Site changes | Main change |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 13 November 2026 | 0 | 2 | 0 | 0 | Open questions: a new row for our request to the Environment Agency of 13 November 2026 on the choice of PFAS analytes for the soil and egg sampling, including EEA-NH4 (reply due 14 December 2026, our calculation); Wyre Council’s reference, FOI004176, added to the Jameson Road lease request, which it acknowledged on 12 November; the Environment Agency’s reference, EIR2026/54440, added to the Jameson Road licence request |
| 12 November 2026 (Phase 2 copies) | 0 | 1 | 0 | 0 | The Reports page links our copy of Wyre Council’s republished Phase 2 report alongside the original, for comparison |
| 12 November 2026 (Phase 2 interpretative report) | 0 | 3 | 0 | 0 | The Reports page summarises WSP’s Phase 2 interpretative report (March 2026), which Wyre Council linked on 11 November 2026; eight pages that give the 144 µg/kg Phase 2 maximum now carry WSP’s caveat on that result, in WSP’s words |
| 12 November 2026 (corrections) | 4 | 1 | 0 | 0 | The Bentham post’s note on Dr Megson now quotes the Guardian’s report of October 2025 on his soil results and says that the results are as the Guardian reported them, that we have not seen the data, and that a web search on 12 November 2026 found no published paper reporting them; the 2025 Dalmijn paper’s author order is corrected on four pages; the home page’s 145 tonnes now says 2012 is AGC’s date and quotes the Environment Agency’s report of 12 November 2026 on continuing PFOA emissions; three section headings now attribute the 2012 end of PFOA use to AGC. The HSE consultation post says no outcome had been published when we checked on 12 November 2026 |
| 12 November 2026 (EEA-NH4) | 0 | 2 | 1 | 0 | New post: the council leader’s report to Full Council on 22 October 2026 says AGC’s on-site investigation found EEA-NH4 in soils close to homes bordering the site, and that the Environment Agency has commissioned sampling of a small number of public open spaces for it; set beside what the Agency said about EEA-NH4 in March 2026. Timeline and Open questions updated |
| 12 November 2026 (Phase 2 report) | 1 | 3 | 0 | 0 | The Reports, Open questions, Timeline and Victrex pages now record that Wyre Council republished the Phase 2 factual report on 11 November 2026 with the sample co-ordinates removed and two staff names redacted, and that our copy is the council’s original |
| 12 November 2026 | 0 | 1 | 0 | 0 | National context: a new section on the Environment Agency’s publications of 12 November 2026: what its airborne report says about AGC Chemicals Europe, which runs the Hillhouse plant (the identification is ours), that Defra’s TOMPs air monitoring network does not monitor PFAS and there is no standard UK method for monitoring PFAS in ambient air, the 30% and 29% river figures as national averages for PFOS and PFOA, and that the review says PFOS is the only PFAS with a UK environmental quality standard |
| 11 November 2026 (evening) | 2 | 1 | 0 | 0 | Open questions and The Reports (two corrections that narrow claims): the Defra row now limits Defra’s “not held” answer to records for the meetings in our request that concern emissions or contamination from the site, and the Phase 2 note says the council’s guide gives no reason, in place of “the council has not given a reason”; the Defra row also gives the invite lists in Defra’s Annex C, which name the consultancy Kreab for two meetings, with Kreab’s EU lobbying register entry, and the Lancashire County Council row gains its reference |
| 11 November 2026 (open requests) | 1 | 4 | 0 | 0 | Open questions (one correction: four of our calculated due dates moved by one working day): Defra replied to our request about its meetings with AGC Chemicals Europe on 10 November (partly answered; the row now records our internal review request of 11 November); Wyre Council declined an internal review of the garden-sampling request, and we reported it to the Information Commissioner’s Office on 5 November; the Environment Agency’s two internal reviews and its further requests on the dispersion model, the current PFOA releases request and three Jameson Road landfill requests (Environment Agency, Lancashire County Council, Wyre Council) are listed with their due dates. The FAQ answer on garden sampling, the timeline’s list of later events and the NPL page’s consultation wording are updated too |
| 9 November 2026 | 0 | 0 | 1 | 0 | What is PFAS?: a new section, Can PFAS be destroyed?, on a laboratory study published in October 2026 that broke down six PFAS, including PFOA, in water, with what the study does and does not show. |
| 3 November 2026 (UKHSA announcement) | 0 | 2 | 0 | 0 | UKHSA published its own announcement of its blood and urine study at 10:30 on 3 November 2026, with initial findings from the programme expected in 2027; our post on the study and the national context page say so, with two government written answers of 2 November 2026 on monitoring PFAS in communities and on the conclusions of UKHSA’s rapid review |
| 3 November 2026 | 0 | 1 | 1 | 0 | New post: the UK Health Security Agency’s study of PFAS in people’s blood and urine, as reported by the BBC on 3 November 2026: what it covers, when the PFAS figures are due, and what it could and could not tell residents here; the national context page links it |
| 28 October 2026 (Wyre request) | 0 | 2 | 0 | 0 | Open questions: Wyre Council has not given a substantive reply to our Freedom of Information request of 29 September 2026 (reference FOI003977) by its due date of 27 October; its status now reads “No substantive reply”, with a link to the reminder we sent on 28 October 2026; the FAQ answer on garden sampling says so too |
| 28 October 2026 (networks) | 0 | 2 | 0 | 0 | The About page and footer now say that Andrew Molloy, who runs Hillhouse Watch, also founded and runs PFAS Communities UK, PFAS Communities and the Fenceline Network, in place of “not affiliated with any campaign group”; the answer to “Everyone has PFAS in their blood anyway” gains a third point: widespread exposure is a reason for action nationally and internationally, and does not rule out an additional contribution from a local source |
| 27 October 2026 | 0 | 1 | 0 | 0 | National context: three government written answers of 26 October 2026, on publication plans for background biomonitoring data (PFAS data “at a later stage”, no date given) and on adopting the EU’s new chemical hazard classes in Great Britain |
| 26 October 2026 (evening) | 0 | 2 | 0 | 0 | Wyre Council’s contaminated-land guide again carries its former FAQ questions (change detected at our 16:05 check on 26 October 2026); our council-FAQ page and national-context page are updated to say so |
| 26 October 2026 (blood testing wording; Phase 3 results contact) | 0 | 6 | 0 | 0 | Clarified: who arranged and carried out the blood testing for 49 residents now follows Leigh Day’s press release of 24 September 2026 on every page that described it, including the council FAQ page; Information and resources has a contact for residents whose Phase 3 results have not arrived; four BBC links on Common criticisms now go to the BBC’s own article, and dead links for the Director of Public Health’s words are removed, with Wyre Council’s guide cited where it carries the same words; the “Blood Tests Cannot Predict” post says which version of the Director of Public Health’s words it compares |
| 26 October 2026 | 6 | 6 | 0 | 0 | Wyre Council removed the Phase 2 factual report from its website on 22 October 2026; its former FAQ address has returned “not found” at every check since 16:05 on 23 October, and its FAQ is now 12 questions in a new guide. The Reports, Open questions and council FAQ pages record this, and links to removed council pages go to dated Internet Archive copies. Timeline corrections: Leigh Day’s 27 March update, and AGC statements that the timeline had attributed to the council’s FAQ |
| 26 October 2026 (national context) | 0 | 0 | 1 | 1 | New page: Thornton in national and international context, with the Environment Agency’s national PFAS programme, the national and local references to “Phase 4”, who decides what, UK rules for PFAS, other countries and what is changing; linked from the footer and Start here |
| 25 October 2026 | 0 | 3 | 0 | 0 | Wyre Council’s Hillhouse investigation pages have been replaced by a six-page “Contaminated land” guide; one link each on three of our pages now points to the guide |
| 23 October 2026 | 0 | 10 | 1 | 0 | New post: the two allotments determined as contaminated land on 22 October 2026, with the dates; pages that said no formal determination had been recorded now carry a dated update |
| 22 October 2026 (IARC Group 1 answer) | 0 | 0 | 1 | 1 | New FAQ answer on the response that bacon and sausages are on the same IARC list: it agrees the classification does not say how dangerous something is, and sets out the links to disease, blood results, kidney cancer counts and worker study the concern rests on |
| 22 October 2026 (model sweep) | 12 | 1 | 0 | 2 | Corrections after the Environment Agency’s model report RP03 and our re-check of WSP’s charts: the west-north-west “second peak” is not shown to be a peak of the south-east’s size, the model report lists the south-east, south and west as predicted peak directions, and the pages that repeated it, and both soil maps, are corrected |
| 22 October 2026 (open requests) | 0 | 1 | 0 | 0 | Open questions: the Environment Agency replied to the model and sampling-design request (partly answered); Lancashire County Council extended its deadline to 23 November; a new request to Wyre Council about WSP’s roles |
| 22 October 2026 (EA dispersion model) | 3 | 1 | 1 | 0 | New post on the Environment Agency’s reply to our request for the dispersion model and sampling design: it does not hold RP02, supplied the later RP03 (dated before any soil sampling), and withheld the model-versus-soil plans as personal data. Two posts and the FAQ corrected where they said the model had not been published or had been used to plan the testing; Open questions updated with the internal review request |
| 22 October 2026 (fund questions) | 0 | 1 | 0 | 0 | The CrowdJustice fund page has a new section, Questions about the fund: ten common questions, each answered from the page and the site’s sourced pages, with its own link |
| 22 October 2026 (CrowdJustice fund) | 0 | 1 | 0 | 3 | The CrowdJustice fund is now the first item in the headline ticker and has a block near the top of the home page, with share buttons there, on the fund page and on What You Can Do |
| 21 October 2026 (What You Can Do) | 1 | 1 | 2 | 1 | New What You Can Do page leading with the petition for blood testing and the CrowdJustice fund, each with its own page; the menu item now opens a submenu; the advice and contacts page is now labelled Information and resources |
| 21 October 2026 | 7 | 4 | 1 | 0 | Post on the Phase 3 report’s quality control withdrawn: the figures it said were missing are in the report; Reports page now serves the council’s own downloadable PDFs, with what we found when we checked them; publication-month and page citations corrected |
| 19 October 2026 | 0 | 1 | 0 | 0 | Open questions: the Health and Safety Executive sent a holding reply on the October 2024 fire request, with no date |
| 18 October 2026 | 77 | 1 | 2 | 1 | Source of the 145 tonnes corrected to AGC’s own estimate; new post and map putting the Phase 2 garden soil readings and the Health Cell’s kidney cancer count for one neighbourhood on one map, with what it does not show; a “What counts as PFAS?” section and a Glossary were published, withdrawn the same morning because they cited government agencies for scientific statements, and republished sourced to peer-reviewed research; the same rule applied across the site: 27 passages on 24 pages re-sourced or recast, and the What is PFAS lead corrected; a second whole-site review the same afternoon found remaining instances and other errors, 28 further corrections including the Miteni entry on Sources and evidence and the kidney cancer science post; a legal read of the whole site the same evening produced 20 more, led by the AGC closure post, which no longer implies that the company’s explanation was dishonest |
| 17 October 2026 (Wyre Council reports) | 0 | 3 | 0 | 0 | Wyre Council upheld the accessibility complaint: the three Issuu-only reports are now downloadable, text-searchable PDFs; Open questions, Documents and one Victrex source updated |
| 17 October 2026 (CrowdJustice fund) | 0 | 0 | 1 | 1 | New page: the CrowdJustice fund for expert work, who hosts it, where the money goes and what happens to unused funds; footer link and disclosure wording added across pages |
| 14 October 2026 (Who has been at Hillhouse) | 0 | 0 | 1 | 0 | New page: a sourced profile of every company and public body on record at the Hillhouse site, past and present |
| 14 October 2026 (NPL; EVC, INEOS and Vinnolit) | 0 | 0 | 2 | 0 | New pages: NPL, the estate’s main landowner, and the PVC plant from ICI to closure under EVC, INEOS and Vinnolit |
| 14 October 2026 (ICI) | 0 | 0 | 1 | 0 | New page: ICI at Hillhouse, from the salt works to the 1999 sale, with AGC’s decade table of PFOA releases and where ICI’s companies are now |
| 14 October 2026 (Victrex) | 0 | 0 | 1 | 0 | New page: Victrex at Hillhouse, from its permits, emissions returns, incidents and own statements |
| 14 October 2026 (AGC in its own words) | 0 | 1 | 1 | 0 | New page: what AGC Chemicals Europe and AGC Inc. have said and recorded about the site, quoted exactly; Questions caveat on the site’s COMAH status updated |
| 14 October 2026 (kidney cancer pages) | 11 | 0 | 0 | 0 | Third review of the kidney cancer pages: titles and links name Lancashire County Council; what the Health Cell tested and did not test; the comparisons the report does give; its remit; Leigh Day’s PFOA figures; a retrospective study exists; the Shearer study’s adjustments |
| 14 October 2026 | 48 | 5 | 0 | 1 | First-principles source review of the whole site, with two rounds of fixes after a five-way panel review: 48 corrections; the 2012 date for the end of PFOA use is now attributed to AGC wherever it appears; claims with no primary source removed; timeline overview image removed; six questions put to AGC; Questions page updated |
| 13 October 2026 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 0 | New page: Wyre Council’s FAQ page, answer by answer; corrected and revised the same day |
| 12 October 2026 | 18 | 2 | 0 | 0 | Second-reader review of the whole site: wording the reports do not support removed or replaced with the source’s own words; figures and attributions corrected; what happens to a contact-form message now stated; the tap-water answer |
| 11 October 2026 | 22 | 1 | 0 | 0 | Cross-page corrections to dates, figures and attributions, including allotment conclusions, egg results, Health Cell findings and clinical follow-up thresholds |
| 4 October 2026 | 21 | 3 | 2 | 0 | Hostile-reader review of the FAQ: twenty-one corrections of wording, attribution and citation; who runs the site now stated at the top of the FAQ; two new FAQ answers |
| 1 October 2026 | 5 | 1 | 0 | 0 | Second adversarial review of the live site: fire article, permit-breach table, accounts wording, EEA-NH4 figure and our own self-description corrected; current PFOA generation added |
| 30 September 2026 | 4 | 5 | 1 | 0 | Open requests table; FAQ and criticisms rebuilt on the published science; who runs the site disclosed; EEA-NH4 discharge figure dated to 2019; two articles corrected |
| 29 September 2026 | 0 | 2 | 0 | 0 | Council will not sample on request (new FAQ answer); requests to the EA and Wyre on the model and sampling design |
| 28 September 2026 | 4 | 5 | 1 | 0 | Status: HSE reported to the ICO; FOI to Lancashire County Council; kidney cancer posts; timeline corrections (COMAH tier, Jameson Road dates); Guardian byline; current PFOA generation added |
| 27 September 2026 | 10 | 0 | 9 | 0 | Zones map withdrawn; council and permit wording corrected across pages; new post and seven answers on responses to the blood results |
| 26 September 2026 | 10 | 1 | 7 | 3 | Soil map and timeline redrawn; distance and wording corrections; changelog reorganised |
| 25 September 2026 | 10 | 8 | 1 | 2 | Second accuracy review: own errors fixed; closure and blood results added |
| 17 September 2026 | 6 | 0 | 0 | 0 | Corrections to the toxic-gas post and the March investigation update |
| 11 September 2026 | 10 | 4 | 0 | 0 | Full accuracy sweep: three own errors logged first, then wider updates |
| 3 September 2026 | 1 | 1 | 0 | 0 | Groundwater section expanded; an internal notes error also corrected |
| 14 August 2026 | 2 | 0 | 0 | 2 | Two citation errors corrected; a third link and form fixed |
| 2 August 2026 | 6 | 0 | 0 | 0 | Major correction pass: W1 discharge figure, citations, attribution, several figures |
| 23 July 2026 | 1 | 0 | 0 | 0 | Precision fix to “three-month fire” wording; no claim changed |
| 9 March 2026 | 0 | 0 | 1 | 0 | New post: BBC filming confirmed; Leigh Day town hall announced |
| 8 March 2026 | 0 | 2 | 3 | 1 | New posts on the 1km zone, residential testing and the PFAS plan |
| 6 March 2026 | 0 | 15 | 0 | 3 | Navigation and theme overhaul; Part 2A conclusion for Occupation Road |
| 25 February 2026 | 2 | 0 | 0 | 3 | Cancer-stat headline corrected; dark-theme fixes; more sources added |
| 18 February 2026 | 16 | 0 | 0 | 8 | Foundational rewrite; several more sourcing corrections and citations restored |
13 November 2026
Updates
- Open questions: a new request to the Environment Agency, and a reference. A new row records our request of 13 November 2026 to the Environment Agency, filed through WhatDoTheyKnow, for the recorded information on how the PFAS analytes were chosen for the soil and egg sampling in Phases 1 to 3 of the Part 2A inspection, including whether EEA-NH4 was considered; the reply is due on 14 December 2026 (our calculation, which WhatDoTheyKnow matches). The Wyre Council row on the Jameson Road lease request now gives the council’s reference, FOI004176; the council acknowledged the request on 12 November 2026 and gave no due date, so the row keeps our calculated date of 9 December 2026. The Environment Agency row on the Jameson Road licence request now gives the Agency’s reference, EIR2026/54440, and notes that the Agency’s due date matches ours.
12 November 2026 (Phase 2 copies)
Updates
- The Reports: our copy of the republished Phase 2 report. Next to the council’s original, the Reports page now also links our copy of the version Wyre Council republished on 11 November 2026 (353 pages), so both versions stay available for comparison. Both are the council’s files, unaltered, with their SHA-256 fingerprints in our public document archive.
12 November 2026 (Phase 2 interpretative report)
Updates
- The Reports: WSP’s Phase 2 interpretative report. A new entry summarises the report Wyre Council linked on 11 November 2026 (WSP for the Environment Agency, reference 70100310/12295, March 2026, 46 pages): what it tested and against which screening levels, its findings and conclusions in WSP’s words, its recommendations (Phase 3 fieldwork, 9 October to 19 November 2025, sampled gardens out to 1 km and tested eggs), and what it does not cover: EEA-NH4, children’s exposure as a separate question, testing of produce, background exposure, and any particular household’s total exposure across soil, home-grown produce, eggs and other sources.
- The 144 µg/kg Phase 2 result: WSP’s caveat added. WSP’s Phase 2 interpretative report for the Environment Agency (March 2026, section 3.6.2) adds new information about the Phase 2 maximum of 144 µg/kg PFOA. The report was linked by Wyre Council on 11 November 2026 and was not linked on our earlier captures of the council’s pages, so our pages gave the figure without it. WSP says “There is some uncertainty associated with this result” and that it “noted the presence of a plastic bag within the soil at this sample location”; the laboratory confirmed that there “did not appear to be a plastic bag / rag within the soil remaining” after analysis; and WSP concludes that the result “may be genuine”, citing 15.2 µg/kg in the soil above it at the same point and that PFOS, PFHxS and PFNA were not elevated in the sample. The Numbers, the Timeline, Sources & Evidence, Start here, the Phase 3 soil results post, the two kidney cancer posts (assessment questions and south-east of Hillhouse) and the soil map post now give the caveat in WSP’s words. The figure is unchanged, and the pages that call 144 µg/kg the highest Phase 2 reading still do. The map image in the soil map post still shows 144 without the caveat; the post’s text carries it.
- Timeline. The 11 November 2026 entry now records that the council’s guide also links the interpretative report.
12 November 2026 (corrections)
Corrections
- Bentham post: Dr Megson’s soil results. The note said Dr Megson had, “according to the Guardian (October 2025), confirmed the presence of EEA-NH4 in those soils”, and that “He described what he found as ‘a giant chunk of toxic material.’” The Guardian reported on 19 October 2025 that “New independent sampling has confirmed the presence of EEA-NH4 in soils around the plant”, that Dr Megson carried out the analysis, and quoted him: “Our results showed that in addition to PFOA, the soil surrounding the site consistently contains EEA-NH4 and hydrogen-substituted carboxylic acids (H-PFCAs).” It reported “a giant chunk of toxic material” as his description of something in the environment that regulators were ignoring, not of his results. The note now quotes the Guardian’s report and says that the results are as the Guardian reported them, that we have not seen the data, and that a web search on 12 November 2026 found no published paper reporting them. The 18 February 2026 entry below says EEA-NH4 testing “was described as involving ‘soils’; the source reports water samples”. That was right about the paper then cited (Megson et al., 2024, a study of water samples), but the Guardian’s report does concern soil, so the change went further than the sources supported. No current page carries the changed wording, and that entry is left as it was published.
- The 2025 paper in Environmental Science & Technology: author order. The HSE consultation post, the Bentham post, the March 2026 investigation update and the Timeline cited it as “Cousins, Dalmijn et al.”, “Cousins/Dalmijn et al.” or “Dalmijn, Cousins et al.”. Joost Dalmijn is the first author and Ian Cousins the last of seven. Each now reads “Dalmijn et al.”, and the HSE post gives all seven names in order.
- Home page: the 145 tonnes. The card said the PFOA was released “between the 1950s and 2012”. The 145 tonnes is AGC’s own estimate for 1950 to 2012, and 2012 is the year AGC gives for the end of its PFOA use; the card now says so. It also says that AGC’s later figure of about 103 tonnes runs to October 2023, and quotes the Environment Agency’s report of 12 November 2026: “small quantities of PFOA are still emitted to air from the scrubber” (National context).
- What is PFAS? and the Timeline: section headings. “PFOA Phase-Out and Replacement”, “Change of Ownership: Asahi Glass / AGC (1999-2012)” and “Knowing the Risks: The PFOA Phase-Out (2008-2015)” did not say whose dates they were: the first Timeline heading ended at 2012 without saying that 2012 is AGC’s date, the second gave the phase-out period without AGC’s account of when its own PFOA use ended, and the What is PFAS? heading gave the phase-out as an established event. The text beneath them already attributed the 2012 date to AGC. The two Timeline headings, and the links to them at the top of the Timeline, now carry the attribution on that date only: “Change of Ownership: Asahi Glass / AGC (1999; AGC says PFOA use ended in 2012)” and “Knowing the Risks: The PFOA Phase-Out (2008-2015; AGC says it ended its own PFOA use in 2012)”. The What is PFAS? heading now reads “PFOA Phase-Out (AGC’s Account) and Replacement”. The link addresses are unchanged.
Updates
- HSE consultation post: the outcome, and what “toxic” rests on. The post now says that when we checked on 12 November 2026, HSE had published no outcome of its consultation (GBCLP 009), and where we looked. It also now says that the Environment Agency’s April 2023 evaluation treats EEA-NH4 as “toxic” on the draft PMT criteria “based on the current self-classification” (p.63), an industry self-classification, not a classification set by a regulator or by the Agency. It quotes the evaluation’s attribution of that self-classification to “the UK supplier” (named in the evaluation as AGC Chemicals Europe Ltd), and says that the “by analogy” reasoning applies to persistence only.
12 November 2026 (EEA-NH4)
New
- EEA-NH4 in soil: what the council leader reported on 22 October 2026. Paragraph 2.6 of the council leader’s report to Wyre Council’s Full Council meeting of 22 October 2026 (published 14 October) says AGC’s on-site investigation “found significantly elevated concentrations of a new contaminant of concern (EEA-NH4) in soils close to residential properties that border the site”, and that the Environment Agency has commissioned sampling of “a small number of local public open spaces” for EEA-NH4, with further fruit, vegetable and egg sampling “for PFOA”. The post quotes it in full, sets it beside the Agency’s text of March 2026 (FOI003176), says what the earlier off-site sampling tested for, and what is not confirmed: the results are AGC’s, the report gives no figures, the report does not say whether these soils are inside or outside the site boundary, and the council’s guide says the open-space sampling “has been carried out” but we have seen no details of it (which spaces, how many samples, dates, results) in the guide, the report or the Environment Agency’s published pages, as checked on 12 November 2026.
Updates
- Timeline: the leader’s report of 22 October 2026. A new entry in the summary of events since March 2026.
- Open questions: the Environment Agency’s EEA-NH4 sampling. A new row, status Preparing: the results of the open-space sampling, and whether EEA-NH4 will be tested in the Phase 4 garden sampling.
12 November 2026
Updates
- National context: the Environment Agency’s publications of 12 November 2026. A new section reports what the Agency’s airborne report says about AGC Chemicals Europe, which runs the Hillhouse plant (the report does not use the name Hillhouse; the identification is ours), including that “small quantities of PFOA are still emitted to air from the scrubber”; that the Agency’s companion report says there is no standard UK method for monitoring PFAS in ambient air and that Defra’s TOMPs air monitoring network does not monitor PFAS, with pilot work commissioned; that the Agency’s river figures (about 30% for PFOS and 29% for PFOA, 2016 to 2025) are national averages for those two chemicals and not results for the Wyre; and that its thresholds review says PFOS is the only PFAS with a UK environmental quality standard. The reports say they do not necessarily represent the Agency’s views, so the section reports them as reports published by the Agency.
12 November 2026 (Phase 2 report)
Corrections
- Open questions and the Timeline: the Phase 2 removal. The Wyre Council row said “The council has not given a reason.” for removing the Phase 2 factual report, and the Timeline’s 22 October entry said “the council has given no reason”. What we can show is that the council’s contaminated-land guide gives none; both now say that, and the Open questions row carries a dated correction. (The Reports page note was corrected the same way on 11 November 2026.)
Updates
- The Reports: the Phase 2 factual report republished. On 11 November 2026 Wyre Council linked a Phase 2 factual report again from its contaminated-land guide, which no longer says “currently under review” (recorded by our monitoring at 16:05). The new file is 353 pages; the council’s file dated 14 October 2026 (server record) is 485. The new file has the sample co-ordinates removed and two staff names redacted. We compared the extracted text of the two files and found no other difference in the results text; we have not compared the maps and figures by eye. Neither the council’s guide nor its download page gives a reason for the changes. Our copy is the council’s original and is unchanged. Our note of 26 October 2026, and the posts and pages that repeated it, said the report was under review; that was the position until 11 November. The 26 October entries below are left as they were published.
- Open questions, Timeline and Victrex. Each now records the removal of 22 October and the republished file of 11 November 2026, in place of the “currently under review” position.
11 November 2026 (evening)
Corrections
- Open questions: Defra’s “not held” answer. The Defra row said Defra holds no minutes, notes or briefings “on emissions or contamination from the site”. Part 4 of our request asked for minutes, notes, read-outs and briefing notes for the meetings in our request, only insofar as they concern emissions, discharges or releases from the site or contamination from it. Defra says that, after searching its paper and electronic records, it does not hold that information. The row now says so. The 11 November entry below repeats the earlier wording and is left as it was published.
- The Reports: the Phase 2 note. The note said “The council has not given a reason” for removing the Phase 2 factual report. What we can show is that the council’s contaminated-land guide gives none; the note now says that, with a dated correction. The 26 October entry below repeats the earlier wording and is left as it was published.
Updates
- Open questions. The Defra row links Defra’s reply and its list of meetings (Annex C), and gives Annex C’s invite lists: “AGC, Defra Official and KREAB” for the online meetings of 20 November 2025 and 4 June 2026 on long-chain PFCAs. It adds that Kreab describes itself as a strategic communications and public affairs consultancy, that its entry on the EU Transparency Register lists AGC Chemicals Europe among its clients for 2025, under “REACH”, and that we could not check the UK Register of Consultant Lobbyists. The Lancashire County Council row on the Jameson Road landfill gains the council’s reference, FOI1977, from its acknowledgement of 11 November.
11 November 2026 (open requests)
Corrections
- Open questions: four reply dates that were our calculation. We had counted only bank holidays in England when working out when replies are due. The Freedom of Information Act 2000 (section 10(6)), which the Environmental Information Regulations 2004 apply through regulation 2(1), defines a working day as excluding a bank holiday “in any part of the United Kingdom”. The dates are recalculated to exclude bank holidays in all parts of the UK, as the law requires, which removes Scotland’s St Andrew’s Day (Monday 30 November 2026) and its substitute holiday of 4 January 2027. The Environment Agency request on current PFOA releases (filed 3 November) is due 2 December 2026, not 1 December. The three Jameson Road landfill requests to the Environment Agency, Lancashire County Council and Wyre Council (filed 10 November) are due 9 December 2026, not 8 December. The page carries a dated correction note. Other calculated dates on the page, all before 30 November 2026, are unchanged.
Updates
- Open questions. (1) Defra answered our request about its meetings with AGC Chemicals Europe on 10 November 2026 (reference EIR2026/24312): it listed four contacts, said it held no minutes, notes or briefings on emissions or contamination from the site, and withheld the titles, dates and producers of the related documents under regulation 12(5)(e) and (f); the row says what the reply does and does not give, and that we asked for an internal review of the part 5 withholding on 11 November. (2) Wyre Council declined our request of 4 November for an internal review of the garden-sampling request (FOI003977) on 5 November, on the ground that it does not carry out internal reviews where no response has been provided; we reported the request to the Information Commissioner’s Office the same day. (3) The Health and Safety Executive row records our internal review request of 18 October. (4) New rows for the Environment Agency’s internal review of its fire-request answers (IR2026/50959, the Agency’s date 17 December), its internal review on the dispersion model (IR2026/51684, 21 December), our further requests on that thread (EIR2026/52524, 19 November) and our request of 3 November on current PFOA releases (due 2 December by our calculation), and three requests of 10 November on the Jameson Road landfill, one each to the Environment Agency, Lancashire County Council and Wyre Council, due 9 December by our calculation. Two rows in the “What we are asking next” table that these requests replace are removed.
- Frequently asked questions. The garden-sampling answer records the internal review request and the Information Commissioner’s Office complaint.
- Timeline. The list of later events gains five dated entries (Wyre Council’s accessibility decision of 16 October, the removal of the Phase 2 report and the Environment Agency’s reply on the dispersion model, both 22 October, UKHSA’s study of 3 November, and Defra’s reply of 10 November), and its footer date is updated.
- NPL. The Wyre Council consultation form on the masterplan review is described as having given 6 November 2026 as its closing date.
9 November 2026
New
- What is PFAS?: Can PFAS be destroyed?. A short section on a laboratory study by Long et al. (Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, published online 19 October 2026) that used a palladium-coated membrane and hydrogen to break down six PFAS, including PFOA, in water. It sets out which chemicals were tested (EEA-NH4 was not one of them), the results of the 58-day test, and the study’s limits: a 40-millilitre laboratory reactor, water only, not at full scale.
3 November 2026 (UKHSA announcement)
Updates
- UKHSA’s study of PFAS in people’s blood. An update note at the top: UKHSA’s own announcement, published at 10:30 on 3 November 2026 after the post, with what it confirms (the samples, the chemicals, initial findings from the programme expected in 2027) and what it does not say. The passages it affects, including the closing note, now say so, and one gains a government written answer of 2 November 2026 on monitoring PFAS in communities (37869).
- Thornton in national and international context. UKHSA’s announcement, and two government written answers of 2 November 2026: on plans to monitor PFAS in communities (37869), and that the conclusions of UKHSA’s rapid review of the health impacts of industrial sources of PFAS were not based on UK health or environmental standards (37870).
3 November 2026
New
- UKHSA’s study of PFAS in people’s blood: what it covers, and what it could mean here. The BBC reported on 3 November 2026 that the UK Health Security Agency is launching its first study of PFAS levels in people, using samples from the Health Survey for England. The post sets the report beside the government’s written answer of 26 October 2026 (PFAS data “at a later stage”), UKHSA’s own description of the programme, the Environmental Audit Committee’s recommendation on groups with higher exposure, and UKHSA’s position on individual testing.
Updates
- Thornton in national and international context. One sentence on the BBC’s report of 3 November 2026, with a link to the new post.
28 October 2026 (Wyre request)
Updates
- Open questions. Wyre Council’s reply to our request of 29 September 2026 (reference FOI003977: the law relied on for not sampling gardens on request, the sampling design, properties that declined or were substituted) was due by 27 October 2026, by our count of 20 working days. Apart from its acknowledgement of 29 September, no reply has come. The status now reads “No substantive reply” and links our reminder of 28 October 2026. The matching line in the question list, and the FAQ answer on garden sampling, are updated too.
28 October 2026 (networks)
Updates
- About and the site footer. Both said Hillhouse Watch was not affiliated with any campaign group, and About said it was “independently maintained”. In October 2026 Andrew Molloy, who runs it, also founded PFAS Communities UK, PFAS Communities and the Fenceline Network, free directories and networks for community groups, and runs them. Both pages now say so.
- Common criticisms: “Everyone has PFAS in their blood anyway”. A third point: widespread exposure is a reason for action nationally and internationally, and does not rule out an additional contribution from a local source. Sources: Shearer et al. (2021), UKHSA (22 September 2026), and the Stockholm Convention review committee’s conclusion on PFOA (2016) and its listing (2019, with specific exemptions).
27 October 2026
Updates
- Thornton in national and international context. Three government written answers of 26 October 2026, all to Ruth Jones MP, are added. In people: data on background levels of metals, bisphenols and phthalates is being processed, “with expected publication from early 2027”, and data on PFAS and flame retardants “will follow at a later stage” (written answer 36014). The earlier sentence on written answer 85312 now uses that answer’s own words, “expected to be published by Autumn 2026”, instead of “due”. In what is changing: the Health and Safety Executive intends to adopt in Great Britain the EU’s requirements for six new hazard classes, to keep the regime consistent with Northern Ireland, with a public consultation “subject to Ministerial agreement” (written answer 36200) and legislative changes “Subject to consultation” (written answer 36203).
26 October 2026 (evening)
Updates
- Wyre Council’s FAQ page, answer by answer. At 14:10 we published that the council’s FAQ was now 12 questions in its contaminated-land guide and that 21 questions were not on any of the guide’s six pages. That matched our capture of 25 October and our monitor’s checks through 12:05 on 26 October. The monitor detected changes to pages 5 and 6 at its 16:05 check; our captures that evening show page 5 carrying those 21 questions and their answers again, word for word as in the council’s 25 September 2026 version, and page 6 the 12 blood-test questions (33 of the former 34; “Where can I find more information?” is not among them). The box at the top of the page now says so, with Internet Archive copies of both pages made that evening, and notes that the restored answer “No contamination has yet been confirmed” is on the guide again after the council’s 22 October decision. The page’s description and source note are updated to match.
- Thornton in national and international context. The section on soil screening levels said the council’s guide did not contain “C4SL”; in our capture on the evening of 26 October its page 5 again carries the council’s former answer on them, and the page now says so.
26 October 2026 (blood testing wording; Phase 3 results contact)
Updates
- Clarified: who arranged and carried out the blood testing, on Blood test results for 49 residents, Common criticisms and Wyre Council’s FAQ page, answer by answer. These pages said the testing was arranged by the law firm Leigh Day and carried out by Manchester Metropolitan University, and the council FAQ page said that was accurate. Leigh Day’s press release of 24 September 2026 says the firm “has also been investigating PFAS contamination in the area, working with experts led by Dr Dave Megson at Manchester Metropolitan University (MMU)”, that “As part of these investigations, blood tests were arranged for 49 residents”, and that the testing was “undertaken by an expert team from MMU” (Leigh Day). The three pages now say that, cited to the release. On the council FAQ page the “Who uses it” point gives that account in place of the concession, and notes that the council’s wording describes the users as organisations “commissioned independently by a law firm” and names neither the organisations nor the law firm; the answer on predicting health problems is reworded to match. The results post’s summary and its point on how participants were chosen are reworded to match.
- Clarified: the same description on other pages. New here? Start with this, the FAQ (four places, and the heading of the answer now titled “Why was the blood testing part of a law firm’s investigation?”), Health (two places), The Numbers, the timeline (23 September 2026), The petition for PFAS blood testing, The CrowdJustice fund for expert work, Thornton in national and international context, Blood Tests in a UK PFAS Community (summary and its 25 September update note), “Blood Tests Cannot Predict”, Two Thornton-Cleveleys allotments determined as contaminated land and the home page each said, in a few words, that the testing was arranged by Leigh Day. Each now says it was arranged as part of Leigh Day’s investigation with experts led by Dr Dave Megson at Manchester Metropolitan University (on the home page, “with experts at Manchester Metropolitan University”). On Health, the timeline and the CrowdJustice fund page, “analysed by” or “carried out by Manchester Metropolitan University” now reads “carried out by an MMU team”, and the FAQ now quotes the release’s “undertaken by an expert team from MMU”. The Bentham post’s update note now says, as the release does, that the testing took place over summer 2026. Each of these pages has a dated note, on the home page beside the blood-test figure.
- Information and resources: Phase 3 results not received. A short section for residents whose property was tested in Phase 3 and who have not received their results: they can contact Leigh Day at [email protected] to ask for advice. It points to the page’s existing note that this site is not part of Leigh Day and that the person who runs it is a Leigh Day client.
- Common criticisms: links to the BBC’s report. Four citations of the BBC’s report of the blood test results linked a Yahoo News copy that no longer loads. They now link the BBC’s own article, “Blood tests find high level of cancer-causing forever chemical in residents near factory”, which the BBC dates 23 September 2026 (BBC News). The quoted words are unchanged and appear in it.
- Common criticisms and “Blood Tests Cannot Predict”: the Director of Public Health’s words. The Yahoo News copy of a second BBC report, of 24 September 2026, which these pages cited for the words of Lancashire’s Director of Public Health, is no longer online, and the links to it are removed. On Common criticisms, the words “remains uncertain” and “should not be pursued without specialist clinical advice and oversight” are now also cited to the Health Cell statement attributed to Dr Sakthi Karunanithi on Wyre Council’s contaminated-land guide (Wyre Council, Information from the Health Agencies; Internet Archive copy of 26 October 2026). The other quotations stay attributed to the BBC’s report, because the council’s page words them differently.
- Clarified: “Blood Tests Cannot Predict”, the Director of Public Health’s wording. The post compares the wording of three statements and said that the Director of Public Health’s version does not include “for individuals” or “currently”. That is true of his words as the BBC reported them on 24 September 2026 from his BBC Radio Lancashire interview, and the post now says so. It now also says that the written Health Cell statement in his name, on Wyre Council’s contaminated-land guide (page 6), does include both: “PFAS biomonitoring is not currently recommended for individuals through the NHS or private blood tests.” (Wyre Council; Internet Archive copy of 26 October 2026).
26 October 2026
Corrections
- Timeline, 27 March 2026: Leigh Day’s monthly update. The entry said the update “confirms” that Phase 3 is “the final phase of soil testing” and that no further residential soil sampling is planned. The update said that Leigh Day understood Phase 3 would be the final testing in the investigation; the entry now says that, in our words. The entry also gave the week of 7 April 2026 for the Phase 3 reports, which the update did not give (it said an attendee at the 12 March drop-in had said to expect the reports after Easter), and said “no concrete timeline” for the seven high-risk properties where the update said no concrete steps had been taken. Each bullet now follows the update more closely, the lead-in says the update “reports” its points, and a dated correction note is on the entry.
- Timeline, October 2025: Wyre Council’s FAQ. The entry, headed “Wyre Council FAQ published”, said the council’s FAQ included AGC’s statements that the company has “no significant impact” from current emissions and has “never used or manufactured PFOS”. Those words are not in the Internet Archive’s copies of the council’s FAQ page that we checked (five copies, November 2024 to September 2026). They are AGC’s statements as reported by BBC News on 21 February 2026, now in their own dated entry (BBC News). The October 2025 entry is now headed “Wyre Council FAQ page updated” (the page existed from at least November 2024) and gives what the 28 October 2025 version said, with links to Internet Archive copies.
- Timeline, February 2026: egg testing results. The source line gave the date of the BBC article quoting AGC on PFOS as 2 February 2026. The article is dated 21 February 2026; the line now says so and links it.
- The Numbers: “PFOA still present after 2012”. The box said “AGC Chemicals Europe’s documentation indicates that PFOA use ceased in 2012” and “AGC says PFOA is no longer used as a processing aid”, and cited Wyre Council’s FAQ, which on this point says only that AGC’s emission estimates ran “up until 2012 when PFOA was phased out”. Both statements now quote AGC’s own website (“What are PFAS?” and “Site Investigation” pages), and the citation to the council’s former FAQ says what it supports.
- Wyre Council’s FAQ page, answer by answer. The second of the “five things to keep in mind” said “The page is about PFOA and almost nothing else”. The council’s blood-test answers discuss PFAS generally, including PFOS. The heading now says that the September FAQ did not mention EEA-NH4.
- Open questions: the accessibility entry. The entry said, in our own voice, that future reports “will be published as accessible downloads”. That is the council’s commitment; the entry now says that in its response of 16 October 2026 the council said so.
Updates
- The Reports: the Phase 2 factual report. On 22 October 2026 Wyre Council removed the Phase 2 factual report from its website. Its contaminated-land guide lists it as “Phase 2 Factual Report - currently under review.”, with no link (Wyre Council). A dated note on the Reports page says so, says that the council has not given a reason, that we do not know why the report was removed and that we are trying to find out, and says that the file here is our download of the council’s PDF from the council’s website on 21 October 2026, byte for byte. The link to the council’s PDF is replaced by a statement that it was removed. The page’s introduction now calls the files the council’s downloads “as published”. Two passages were taken out: the words “re-redacted” from the description of the repository, and the sentence “If a public body objects to residents being able to read public environmental information, that would be worth knowing too.”
- Open questions: the accessibility entry. The status is now “Answered (16 Oct 2026). Phase 2 report removed from the council’s website (22 Oct 2026).” The entry said all three reports “are now downloadable”; it now says they were published as downloadable PDFs (council files dated 14 and 15 October 2026), that the council removed the Phase 2 report on 22 October, and that the council has not given a reason and we are trying to find out. It links the council’s guide and our Reports page instead of the council’s removed Hillhouse page.
- Wyre Council’s FAQ page, answer by answer. The council’s FAQ page that this page goes through was online at our check on the morning of 23 October 2026 and has returned “not found” at every check since 16:05 that day; the council’s FAQ is now 12 questions in its contaminated-land guide. A box at the top lists the 21 questions that are not on the guide, says where some of their subject matter appears on the guide in other words, notes the 22 October 2026 determination of the two allotments as contaminated land, and says the page stays as our record of the 25 September 2026 version. Three lines further down now refer to the determination and to the replacement FAQ.
- Timeline, 27 March 2026: Phase 4. A dated line quotes the council’s guide: it is “awaiting details from the Environment Agency on Phase 4 of the investigation” (Wyre Council).
- The One Figure Thornton Residents Can’t Check. Its 21 October paragraph on the Phase 2 report is now in the past tense and ends with the date the council removed the report from its website.
- Links to council pages that have been removed. Where a page cited the council’s former Hillhouse page, its FAQ page or the Phase 2 PDF, and the cited words are not on the council’s new guide, the link now goes to a dated Internet Archive copy marked “page since removed by the council”: Information and Resources (two links; the allotment-produce figures of 3-4 and 7-8 times are now also cited to WSP’s Occupation Road interpretative report, printed page 59), The Numbers, New here? Start with this, the FAQ (the 4 October 2026 search record, which also notes that the council’s multi-agency address now shows its contaminated-land guide) and ICI at Hillhouse (sources, and two quotations now in the past tense). Our 26 October 2026 search of the Internet Archive’s index found no capture of the council’s Phase 2 PDF address, so the Glossary and a Victrex source line now cite our download of the council’s PDF (21 October 2026).
26 October 2026 (national context)
New
- New page: Thornton in national and international context. It sets out the published evidence connecting the Thornton-Cleveleys investigation with Phase 4 of the Environment Agency’s national PFAS Risk Screening Project (“70100310 EA PHASE 4” on the drawings of the first soil report, and the WSP project number shared by the local reports), notes that the Drinking Water Inspectorate (March 2025, paragraph 8.1) and CL:AIRE give different accounts of when that phase ran, and sets the national references to “Phase 4” beside Wyre Council’s statement that it is “awaiting details from the Environment Agency on Phase 4 of the investigation”; Wyre has not explained how its numbering relates to the national programme. A table sets out who holds each decision, from determining contaminated land to drinking water, food limits, chemical restrictions and blood testing, with the law behind each and what exists for PFAS today. It also covers the responses at Parkersburg (a court-settlement programme, not a government one), Dordrecht, Zwijndrecht, Veneto, Ronneby and Jersey, and what is changing in the UK, the EU and the US.
Site changes
- Footer and Start here now link to the new page.
25 October 2026
Updates
- Links to Wyre Council’s investigation pages. The council’s Hillhouse investigation pages no longer load at their old addresses (checked 25 October 2026). The investigation material it still publishes, including its latest update, its reports and its contact address, is now in a six-page guide headed “Contaminated land” (Wyre Council). One link each on Sources and evidence, the FAQ and Information and resources now points to the page of the guide that carries what the link was given for: the latest investigation update (Sources and evidence, FAQ) and the council’s contact address for questions (Information and resources).
23 October 2026
New
- Two Thornton-Cleveleys allotments determined as contaminated land. On 22 October 2026 Wyre Council’s Full Council voted to determine the Occupation Road and Sandringham Avenue allotments as contaminated land under Part 2A (Wyre Council, notice of 23 October 2026). The post sets out what was decided, what the term means, the dates for each site and the council’s stated next steps.
Updates
- Pages that said Wyre Council’s updates “do not record a formal determination of either site” now carry a dated update saying the determination was made on 22 October 2026: the home page (two places), Start here, Evidence, FAQ, Information and resources, Common criticisms Wyre Council’s FAQ page, answer by answer, and two earlier posts: residential testing and planning powers and Hillylaid Pool. The earlier wording was accurate when written and is kept, with the update after it.
- Timeline: 22 October 2026 entry added.
- Open questions: a question on the liability assessment and consultation added; the biomonitoring question now refers to the determination.
22 October 2026 (IARC Group 1 answer)
New
- FAQ: Bacon and sausages are on the same cancer list as PFOA. A new answer. It states first that an IARC group describes the strength of the evidence, not the level of risk, as IARC itself says, and gives the exact groups for processed meat, red meat, PFOA and PFOS. It then sets out what the concern rests on besides the classification: the C8 Science Panel’s probable links, the US National Academies’ blood-level bands, the local blood results as reported, the Health Cell’s kidney cancer counts with its conclusion of “no evidence of a kidney cancer cluster”, and the study that includes Hillhouse workers, says plainly that none of this shows anyone here is ill because of PFOA, and describes the further work that would investigate the local findings: blood testing with expert epidemiological interpretation, among the work the residents’ CrowdJustice fund is likely to pay for (with the site’s disclosure of who runs it).
Site changes
- FAQ: What health conditions have been linked to PFOA?. The answer now has its own link; its text is unchanged. The CrowdJustice fund page now lists the new FAQ answer among the places that discuss the fund.
22 October 2026 (model sweep)
Corrections
- The west-north-west “second peak”. Start here, the FAQ, Common criticisms, Open questions and six posts (Phase 3 results, soil sampling, the “lower risk” marking, kidney cancer cluster, council statement, the chart question) said WSP’s data shows the highest soil concentrations in two directions, south-east and west-north-west, and in places that the west-north-west was an unexplained peak in “lower risk” ground. WSP’s report does say “c. 120° (south-east) and 280° (west-north-west)”, but it does not state the value at the 280 degree bearing. The earlier pages went further than that text in treating it as a second peak of the south-east’s size. The pages now say that. Two post titles that built on the “second peak” are changed, and the soil-sampling post’s question is now how closely the south and west were sampled.
- What the model report says about direction. Pages that gave the south-east as the area where the Environment Agency’s modelling indicated higher deposition now also give RP03’s own wording: peak off-site PFOA concentrations and deposition are predicted at receptors bordering the site boundary “to the south-east, south and west” (RP03, p.1). WSP’s Figure 1 marks the south, south-west, west and north-west “lower risk” and its Scope of Work describes a wider spacing in the wider area; the post on that marking is rewritten around the contrast, and notes that WSP cites RP02, which the Agency says it does not hold.
- The two soil maps. The map in the Phase 2 garden results and kidney cancer map post drew dashed wedges for the 120 and 280 degree directions and a “report’s other direction of highest readings” label, and the satellite map used on the kidney cancer posts drew both directions as arrows and described the Environment Agency’s air model as “unpublished”. Both maps are redrawn without the direction marks, and the satellite map’s key no longer says “unpublished”.
- Who instructed WSP. The citation on Sources and evidence read “for the Environment Agency, on behalf of Wyre Council”. All three WSP reports name the Environment Agency as the client; the Phase 1 report says the Agency “is leading the inspection on behalf of Wyre Council”. The citation now says “for the Environment Agency”.
- Phase 3 results post: note order. The 11 October correction note had a sentence added on 22 October; it now sits in the 22 October note.
Updates
- Open questions. The Wyre Council accessibility complaint, answered on 16 October, is moved out of the open-requests table; its record stays under Other bodies. The Environment Agency row about the west-north-west peak is replaced by a question on the “lower risk” marking.
22 October 2026 (open requests)
Updates
- Open questions: three changes to the open-requests table. (1) The Environment Agency replied on 22 October to our request of 29 September for the air dispersion model and the sampling design (its reference EIR2026/46693). The page now shows it as partly answered. The EA says it does not hold AQMAU-C2478-RP02 and sent RP03 (whose cover page gives a response date of 5 April 2024); it withheld its plans showing average soil concentrations against the model’s predicted deposition pattern as personal data under regulation 13; and for the sampling design, sample locations and depth it pointed to the published Phase 1 to 3 reports. Two other rows on the page that recorded the same request now say so. (2) Lancashire County Council extended its deadline for our request FOI1643 under regulation 7 of the Environmental Information Regulations: the new date is 23 November 2026 (the earlier date, 26 October, was our calculation). (3) A new row records our request to Wyre Council, filed on 22 October on WhatDoTheyKnow, about WSP’s roles: its appointment for the Masterplan Review, any declaration of its Part 2A work for the Environment Agency, and any conflict-of-interest consideration. The due date, 19 November 2026, is our calculation.
22 October 2026 (EA dispersion model)
New
- The EA’s reply on the dispersion model: RP03 supplied, RP02 not held. What the Environment Agency sent on 22 October 2026 in answer to our request for the AQMAU dispersion model and the soil sampling design (EIR2026/46693): a covering letter, the model report AQMAU-C2478-RP03 and one plot. The Agency says it does not hold RP02, the issue WSP’s reports cite. The post sets out what RP03 says about its own assumptions and limits, what the response does not answer, and what it does not show. The model-versus-soil plans were withheld under regulation 13. Quotations are checked against the documents; the documents are on the request’s WhatDoTheyKnow page.
Updates
- Open questions. The Environment Agency row and the matching row lower in the table now record that on 22 October 2026 we asked the Agency, on the same WhatDoTheyKnow thread, for an internal review of four of its answers and made further requests for records.
Corrections
- Phase 3 soil results. The post said the testing locations “were planned using” the Environment Agency’s dispersion model, AQMAU-C2478-RP02, and that the model “has not been published”. The Phase 3 report’s own words are that the modelling, with earlier results, “indicated the presence of a potentially significant contaminant linkage” and that Phase 2 results “aligned with” it. The Agency says it does not hold RP02 and on 22 October 2026 released a later issue, RP03. The summary, sources line and the two passages that restated this were changed and a correction note added. The Phase 1 and 2 reports do describe some land and areas as chosen on the basis of the AQMAU modelling; the post now says WSP’s reports cite RP02 and none says whether RP03 was considered.
- The 1km zone post. The post and its April update said no dispersion modelling had been published, that none supported the 1km figure, and that no document we hold gave the location of the main stack (RP03 gives grid references for two assumed release points, though not as the reference point for the zone). The Agency’s RP03, released 22 October 2026, contains no 500 m, 1 km or 5 km distance and does not mention the advisory zone, so the point about the missing basis stands; the wording now says so and a correction note was added.
- FAQ. “We have asked the Environment Agency for the model (below); what it covers, and for which years, is not stated in the report” was out of date after the Agency’s reply and is replaced.
22 October 2026 (fund questions)
Updates
- The CrowdJustice fund for expert work. A new section, Questions about the fund, answers ten questions people ask about it: where the money goes, what it is for, what happens if the target is missed, whether donors get a share, leftover money, whether the Case Owner benefits, whether Hillhouse Watch is independent of Leigh Day, whether there is a claim, why residents should pay, and the BBC’s 1 July 2026 report on the kidney cancer assessment. Each answer has its own link and uses only what this page and the site’s sourced pages already state, with a link to each source. The page now also cites the BBC’s report of 1 July 2026 and Wyre Council’s FOI response of 6 March 2026.
22 October 2026 (CrowdJustice fund)
Updates
- The CrowdJustice fund for expert work. The page’s list of where the fund is promoted now includes the home page and the headline ticker. A Donate button and a link to the share buttons now sit under the disclosure at the top of the page.
Site changes
- Headline ticker. The first item at the top of every page is now the CrowdJustice fund, linking to the fund page. The headlines after it are unchanged.
- Home page. A block near the top on the fund: what its page says the money is likely to be used for first, the first target and that it is all or nothing, a Donate button, share buttons, and the disclosure that the person who runs this site is the fund’s Case Owner and a client of Leigh Day, with a link to the About page.
- Share buttons for the fund (Facebook, WhatsApp, LinkedIn, X, email and copy link) on the home page, the fund page and What You Can Do. They are plain links that share the CrowdJustice page; they load no third-party scripts.
21 October 2026 (What You Can Do)
New
- What You Can Do. A short page with the two things readers can do now: sign the petition for PFAS blood testing, and back the CrowdJustice fund for expert work. The fund card carries the fund page’s disclosure: the site’s operator is the Case Owner and a Leigh Day client, could benefit financially if a claim succeeds, and receives none of the money; a pledge is a donation; no claim has been issued.
- The petition for PFAS blood testing. What the Change.org petition asks, in its own words, and our relationship to it: we did not write it or start it.
Updates
- The CrowdJustice fund for expert work. The page said it and the footer link were the only places on the site that ask for money. It now lists every place the fund is promoted.
Corrections
- The petition, on Start here and Information and resources. This morning’s link said the petition was started by “a local resident” and asks the government to “offer PFAS blood testing and ongoing health screening to people exposed”. The petitioner writes “I grew up near the Hillhouse site”, and the petition asks the government to “ensure comprehensive blood testing for all residents at risk of PFAS exposure”. Both pages now use the petition’s own words.
Site changes
- Menu. “What To Do” is now “What You Can Do” and opens a submenu: the petition, the CrowdJustice fund, and Information and resources, which keeps its address and all of its content. On phones the three items show indented under it. Links elsewhere on the site that pointed to that page as “What To Do” now say “Information and resources”. The footer links to the petition page.
21 October 2026
New
- AGC’s ‘What are PFAS?’ page, set against the record. AGC Chemicals Europe’s public page, quoted line by line beside the documents on the record, including where the record agrees with it. Sent to AGC for comment on 21 October 2026; any response will be published alongside it.
Corrections
- Withdrawn: our post on the Phase 3 report’s quality control. It said the report does not set out the numbers behind its quality-control conclusions: “what the 13 rinsate results actually measured, or what percentage the 6:2 FTAB recovery actually reached”. Both are in the report. Table 4-5 on PDF page 38, the page before the conclusion, lists the rinsate detections; the laboratory certificates in the appendices print 6:2 FTAB recovery figures for quality-control samples against the laboratory’s acceptance range (for example PDF page 600). The claim survived our 18 October correction of the same post. The page now carries a withdrawal notice saying what was wrong; the Sources and evidence link to it is labelled as withdrawn.
- “Published by Wyre Council in March 2026.” Four posts said this of the Phase 3 report (other contamination pathways, sampling density, the redacted figure, the “Generated using AI” caption), and so did the withdrawn post. The report is dated March 2026; the file the council serves is dated 14 May 2026, and we have not established when it was first posted. They now say “dated March 2026 and published by Wyre Council”.
- A page citation on Victrex. The Phase 2 report’s sentence about Victrex is on PDF page 46 (printed “Page 3”), not pages 46 to 47; page 47 is an appendix divider. Corrected in two places.
Updates
- Start here and What To Do: a link to the residents’ petition for blood testing. A local resident has started a Change.org petition asking the UK government to offer PFAS blood testing and ongoing health screening to people exposed. We link to it under “What can I do?” and in the Community box. We did not write it.
- The Reports (now Downloadable Copies): the council’s own files are now the current files. By 16 October 2026 Wyre Council had replaced the Issuu viewers for the Phase 1, Phase 2 and Occupation Road reports with downloadable PDFs. On 21 October we replaced our July copies, which we had made from Issuu and given a text layer, with the council’s files at the same links, and moved our copies to an archive folder. File sizes changed: Phase 1 from 74 MB to 24.7 MB, Occupation Road from 29 MB to 18.7 MB. We added the Phase 2 report (13.3 MB) and the council’s Occupation Road produce summary and data. The page now says what we found when we compared the files: same page counts, same redactions, no text under any black box, and parts of the appendices that remain inaccessible to assistive technology.
- Our July text layers misread many figures; the soil values we use check out. Of the numbers in the council’s text for the same pages, 41% (Phase 1) and 35% (Occupation Road) were missing or misread in our text layers. The PFOA values in our sample library, which our soil maps use, match the council’s text: all 190 Phase 1 values that cite a page appear on that page, and 247 of 258 Phase 2 rows match exactly. Of the other 11, four are non-detects we held as blanks, five are rows at one sample point the council’s table labels differently, and two were read from laboratory certificates. The council’s Phase 2 table also has 33 results not yet in our library; we will add them after a second read.
- Open questions: the accessibility entry now records our check of the council’s files and the council’s statement that the request for accessible copies “has therefore also been met”. The one figure residents can’t check has a dated paragraph: the Phase 2 report’s own Figure 2, average PFOA per sample point, is published unredacted, and the redacted Phase 3 page contains no map underneath.
19 October 2026
Updates
- Open questions: the Health and Safety Executive’s reply on the October 2024 fire. HSE has still not answered our request of 5 August 2026 (due 4 September). On 19 October it sent a holding reply citing “issues with a third-party service provider that supports a system to process information requests”, saying the request remains open, with no date. The three places the page records this request now say so, and the holding reply was sent to the Information Commissioner’s Office on its open case (IC-573871-P5Y8).
18 October 2026
Corrections
- Government agencies are no longer cited as the authority for scientific statements on the pages the morning’s audit reached (this entry originally said “on any page we audited (every page and post)”; a second, whole-site review the same afternoon found further instances, corrected and listed below; corrected 18 October 2026). On 18 October we adopted a rule: the UK Health Security Agency, the Environment Agency, the Food Standards Agency, the Lancashire County Council Health Cell, Wyre Council, the Drinking Water Inspectorate, HSE, Defra, United Utilities, AGC and WSP are parties to this matter. Their documents are used for what was sampled, measured, reported and decided, and their statements are reported as their positions, dated. They are not used as the authority for what is scientifically true: what PFAS are, how many there are, where they come from, how long they persist, half-lives, toxicity, exposure or statistics. A full audit of the site against that rule found 15 passages where an agency was the source for a scientific statement, 25 where a scientific statement in our own voice had an agency document as its only source, and a number of scientific statements with no source at all. Every one found in that audit is now sourced to peer-reviewed research (cited with DOI), recast as the body’s attributed position, or removed; the few we could not yet source are listed in our to-source file and will be sourced or removed. A second review (Codex) of the changes found a further eleven points, all applied the same day, including two of our own new sentences that read more into a confidence interval than it shows. The pages changed: What is PFAS, Glossary, Start here (five passages), the timeline (five), Evidence (two), Common criticisms (four), the council’s FAQ (three), The Numbers (six), the FAQ (two), What To Do, Open questions, ICI, AGC, the homepage, and the posts on the HSE consultation, kidney cancer, “no link”, the council’s statement, “no concern”, the assessment questions, blood tests, Hillylaid Pool, the fire and AGC’s 2024 accounts. The main replacements: Buck et al. (2011) for the definition of PFAS and the chemistry of PFOA; Cousins et al. (2020) and Evich et al. (2022) for synthetic origin and persistence; Schymanski et al. (2023) and Glüge et al. (2020) for counts; Li et al. (2018) for half-lives in the body; Dalmijn et al. (2025) and Wang et al. (2013) for EEA-NH4 and replacement processing aids; Lohmann et al. (2020) for PTFE; Greenland et al. (2016), Gardner and Altman (1986), Goodman et al. (2012), Elliott and Wartenberg (2004), Kingsley et al. (2007) and Thun and Sinks (2004) for confidence intervals, significance, standardised incidence ratios and disease clusters; Angerer et al. (2007) for biomonitoring. Where only an agency had said something (for example, the Environment Agency’s assessment that EEA-NH4 is very persistent “by analogy”), the page now says so and sets the independent position beside it. One unsourced sentence was removed from The Numbers (“Once released into the environment, a chemical behaves the same way regardless of where it was originally made”) and one from the fire post (that PFIB is a decomposition product of fluoropolymer manufacture); both are listed in our to-source file.
- Wording that adopted an agency’s framing. The same audit swept the site for words of reassurance or interpretation used in our own voice. Thirteen passages changed: “precautionary closure” is now “closure announced by Wyre Council …, which it described as precautionary” (The Numbers, FAQ, What To Do, Open questions); “historical” and “legacy” as our own descriptors of the discharges and deposition are replaced with plain dates or attributed to the report using them (The Numbers, Evidence, Common criticisms, ICI, Hillylaid Pool); the homepage heading “Contaminated land criteria met” now names it as the Environment Agency’s conclusion; a FAQ line that read as our own gardening instruction now opens with “UKHSA’s advice, as relayed in Wyre Council’s letter of 12 August 2026, is that …”; the phrase “regulatory compliance” in the AGC accounts post is replaced by what the accounts say and do not say; and the “safety limits … safe intake levels” paragraph on What is PFAS is gone.
- PFOA and kidney cancer: the science no longer uses the US EPA as a scientific authority. The post cited the US Environmental Protection Agency’s 2024 toxicity assessment as a third body alongside the C8 Science Panel and IARC. Under the rule above, that section is removed and the post now rests on the C8 Science Panel, IARC and two peer-reviewed studies (Vieira et al., 2013; Shearer et al., 2021). Title line, summary and closing section updated to match; no other finding changed.
- What is PFAS: the opening. The lead said PFAS “do not break down naturally” and “persist in the environment and human body indefinitely”, gave a count of “around 4,700 (OECD) to over 10,000”, and expanded the acronym as “per- and poly-fluorinated alkyl substances”. Persistence in the environment and persistence in the body are different things: Li et al. (2018) measured half-lives in human blood of 2.7 years for PFOA, 3.4 for PFOS and 5.3 for PFHxS after exposure ended. The count depends on the definition and is now explained in “What counts as PFAS?”. The expansion is “per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances” (Buck et al., 2011). The comparison table’s “Indefinite (does not break down in nature)” for PFOA is replaced with the peer-reviewed wording. A dated note is on the page.
- The 145 tonnes of PFOA: whose estimate it is. Start here, The Numbers, Evidence, the timeline, the Bentham post and the homepage gave about 145 tonnes of PFOA (75 to water, 70 to air) as an Environment Agency estimate, following Dalmijn et al. (2025), who attribute it to the Agency. The same split is recorded in notes of AGC’s comments on the draft Regulation 61 notice (31 March 2023, ToxicDocs), where AGC is recorded as saying: “An estimate of historic emissions between 1950 and 2012 has already been provided to the Environment Agency, and has been used in the Environment Agency in response to an information request from an external body.” It is AGC’s own estimate, and AGC itself says “a large number of assumptions were made”. The pages now say so. We have not seen the Agency’s response to that request and the documents we hold do not show whether the Agency checked it; the paper’s attribution to the Agency is quoted as the paper’s, not ours. Earlier entries below that call it an Environment Agency estimate are left as written.
- A second, whole-site review on 18 October found agencies still cited for science, and other errors, on pages the morning’s audit had passed or not reached. Three independent reviews of every page and post at the state of the site that afternoon (one on scientific sourcing, one on agency-framing language, one on data provenance, plus two automated checks of the science) found the following, all corrected the same day. The at-a-glance count for 18 October includes them.
- Our own changelog overstated what the morning’s audit had done. The entry above originally said agencies were no longer cited for science “on any page we audited (every page and post)”. That was not true: the review found remaining instances on the kidney cancer cluster post (the US EPA’s 2024 classification and the US National Cancer Institute’s cluster definition), “no link” (NCI), Health (an EFSA block), Common criticisms (a UKHSA statement as the source on exposure), the biomonitoring post (EFSA and US EPA values as the yardstick for blood results) and the March investigation update (EFSA’s intake figure cited as “the science”). The entry now says what was done, and this one records the rest.
- Kidney cancer cluster and “no link”: the US EPA classification and the NCI cluster definition are removed; the cluster description rests on Elliott and Wartenberg (2004) and Thun and Sinks (2004), who write that even where testing confirms an excess, “chance remains a plausible explanation for many clusters”. The “about 90%” overlap between WSP’s higher-deposition area and the neighbourhood area now states how we measured it (traced outline, ONS 2021 boundary, British National Grid; 89.6%).
- PFOA and kidney cancer: the science: the summary and introduction said two peer-reviewed studies “measured” PFOA in people. Shearer et al. (2021) measured it in blood taken before diagnosis; Vieira et al. (2013) estimated residents’ serum PFOA from a model of their water supply, and its odds ratios (2.0, 95% CI 1.3 to 3.2, for the “high” estimated category; 2.0, 95% CI 1.0 to 3.9, for “very high”) compare estimated exposure categories with unexposed areas. The C8 cohort’s hazard ratio of 1.10 now gives its exposure scale (per unit of the natural log of estimated cumulative serum PFOA) and its own p-value (0.10), separately from the trend across exposure quartiles (p=0.18) (Barry et al., 2013). A statement that IARC had earlier placed PFOA in Group 2B is removed until we have read the earlier monograph.
- Health: the “Immune System (EFSA)” entry rested on a regulator’s opinion; it now rests on the National Academies (2022) and the peer-reviewed studies (Grandjean et al., 2012: a twofold higher PFAS concentration in children’s blood at age 5 associated with 49% lower vaccine antibody concentration at 7; Abraham et al., 2020). “Standardised incidence rates” is corrected to “age-standardised figures” (the BBC’s figures are prevalence), and our arithmetic beside the BBC’s percentages is shown (439 of 9,558 is 4.59%, 337 of 7,614 is 4.43%; the BBC printed 4.58% and 4.42%). The C8 Health Project line gives enrolment (69,030) and the number with serum results (66,899), from Frisbee et al. (2009), on Health, The Numbers and the biomonitoring post. Two unsourced general sentences are replaced or removed.
- Common criticisms: the “frying pans” answer used a UK Health Security Agency statement as its source on exposure; it now cites Shearer et al. (2021) (“detected in the serum of over 98% of the US population”) and Buck et al. (2011). The “tiny amounts” answer now describes EFSA’s tolerable weekly intake as a regulatory value and cites the peer-reviewed studies behind it. The “no evidence of harm” answer adds the National Academies’ independent findings. The “lowering PFAS” answer states this site takes no position. An unsourced smoking analogy is removed. The 30 September note that called EFSA’s figure “published science” is relabelled.
- Biomonitoring refused: “EFSA and US EPA health-based guidance values” and “recommended by international health authorities” are replaced with the National Academies’ bands and percentiles, Frisbee et al. (2009) and Angerer et al. (2007); “the only method that can directly answer” and a sentence about why the C8 Health Project was conducted (unsourced) are removed. The post now says the project enrolled 69,030 and obtained serum results for 66,899.
- Investigation update, March 2026: the sentence “the science does not support the claim that PFAS blood levels are uninterpretable” cited EFSA’s intake value and an unsourced reference to German reference ranges; it now names the National Academies’ bands and the Jersey panel’s values. “Cannot both be true” is removed. A statement that soil PFOA “cannot be attributed exclusively to atmospheric deposition” because the river has a floodplain had no source and is now put as the question it was. “Precautionary” is now the council’s word, in quotation marks.
- Timeline: the 2011 EFSA entry stated “no safety concern for the consumer” in our own voice; it is now EFSA’s quoted opinion as recorded by the Environment Agency, with its scope (food-contact use) stated. Four unsourced statements are removed: the Stockholm Convention as “the most significant international environmental treaty … with 184 state parties”; PFOS’s 2009 listing as “a major international signal”; IARC describing the C8 cohort as the largest of its kind; and “the most comprehensive soil survey yet conducted”. The council leader’s “eight times the safe level of a carcinogen” is now quoted as the BBC’s words, with the note that the article names no threshold.
- The egg advice and the “safe weekly limit”. Timeline and Sources and evidence relayed, as reported speech without quotation marks, that the FSA said one egg a week “would go over the safe weekly limit”. Both now quote Wyre Council’s notice of 2 February 2026 (“could reach or go over the EFSA safe weekly limit”, the council’s wording) and say that the EFSA figure is a tolerable weekly intake, a regulatory value, not a safety threshold.
- Kinfauns Castle meeting: “every monkey showed increased liver weight, a sign of toxicity” and “no safe threshold could be determined” went further than Butenhoff et al. (2002), which reports dose-dependent liver-weight increases in every treated group, attributes them to mitochondrial proliferation, and says a no-observed-effect level “was not established in this study” (lowest-observed-effect level 3 mg/kg/day). The post now quotes the paper and attributes the interpretation to Dr Fletcher.
- What is PFAS: the C8 Science Panel list cited one study per condition as if each had established it. Knox et al. (2011) report thyroid hormone levels, not thyroid disease; Barry et al. (2013) report a kidney cancer hazard ratio of 1.10 with a confidence interval (0.98 to 1.24) that includes 1; Stein et al. (2009) report pre-eclampsia weakly associated with PFOA (odds ratio 1.3, 95% CI 0.9 to 1.9). The list now gives the Panel’s report dates and explains the “probable link” standard. An unsourced list of other Group 1 agents is replaced with IARC’s statement that the classification does not indicate the level of risk.
- Sources and evidence: the Miteni case. The entry said about 200 citizens each received EUR 50,000 and that the court “recognised a causal link between PFAS exposure and employee deaths”. The court’s operative judgment (dispositivo, 26 June 2025) awards individual citizens EUR 15,000 each as standard; the EUR 50,000 awards went to six organisations and one municipality. The court’s written reasons, as quoted by Il Giornale di Vicenza (19 April 2026), say the correlation between the civil parties’ illnesses and PFAS exposure “cannot be regarded as proved with sufficient certainty” at the level of general causation. “21 towns” and “the first successful criminal prosecution of PFAS pollution at this scale in Europe” were unsourced and are removed; the 350,000 figure is now attributed to press reports; the pending appeals are noted.
- The Numbers: the five mass-balance figures (49.1, 54.3, 6.2, 5.1 and 63.3 tonnes) carried a stale “original document not independently verified” tag; they are now cited to AGC’s Regulation 61 Part 6 submission of 20 December 2023, which we hold and which gives each figure. The 8.6 km² and 0.9 km² buffer areas now state their method (OpenStreetMap outline of Hillhouse Business Park, British National Grid, 1 km buffer; 8.615 and 0.915 km²). Two unsourced statements in the open questions (on combined PFAS toxicology and on EEA-NH4 fate data) are replaced with what the record shows, the latter quoting the Environment Agency’s 2023 evaluation.
- Hillylaid Pool: the closing list said the paper “attributes the high PFOA … not to current discharge”, contradicting the body of the same post; the paper offers re-emission from on-site reservoirs as a possibility and says current use or formation must be ruled out. The list now matches.
- Soil sampling density: the 50 m grid was described as “tight enough to tell one garden from the next”; the report states the spacing, not what it resolves. The post now compares spacings by area per sample point.
- The AGC fire: a pyrolysis temperature (650 to 800 °C), an association with hydrogen fluoride and the description “arguably the most hazardous process on the site” had no source; they are removed. The pyrolysis route is cited to Dalmijn et al. (2025), the naming of perfluoroisobutene to the fire-service log, and its toxicity to the OPCW schedule and Wingfors et al. (2022).
- Kidney cancer assessment questions: “Kidney cancer develops over a long time” (unsourced) and “the report is not fabricated, and some of its cautions are fair” (our grading of the report) are removed.
- Posts that vouched for the Agency’s contractor in our own voice. The one figure residents can’t check supplied a reason for a redaction the report does not give (“most likely for ordinary property-privacy reasons”, “legitimate”, “defensible”) and called the report “careful, methodical”; Quality control said a reassurance “may be entirely correct” and disclaimed any suggestion that the findings should “change anyone’s understanding of the risk”, which read as reassurance on the report’s behalf; Other contamination pathways said WSP and the Agency “may have entirely good answers” and described LCRM as “the government’s standard approach”. Each now states what the report does and does not say, and stops.
- Start here: “a biomonitoring result … is not a diagnosis” was attributed to Angerer et al. (2007), whose paper supports only that it measures exposure; the limit on reading individual risk is now the National Academies’ own statement. The 630 m distance of the highest soil reading is now stated, here and on the Phase 3 post, as our reading of WSP’s plot (“about 630 to 640 m”), which the report does not print. The persistence sentence carries its sources.
- Glossary: the fluoropolymer definition was attributed to Lohmann et al. (2020); it is Buck et al. (2011), quoted by Lohmann. The EFSA entry now carries the standard line that its statements are reported as its position. A sentence in the ng/ml entry about blood and drinking-water values, sourced only to the SI prefixes, is removed.
- Sources and evidence: PRTR. “Perfluorocarbons … are not the PFAS family” is corrected: whether CF4 and C2F6 count as PFAS depends on the definition used.
- FAQ: an unsourced sentence comparing PFAS with a virus is removed; the half-life answer now gives both published estimates (3.8 years in retired workers, Olsen et al., 2007; 2.7 years in residents after exposure ended, Li et al., 2018) and why they differ.
- Homepage: the 783 kg figure’s page reference is corrected from p.68 to p.69 of the Environment Agency’s April 2023 evaluation, and the figure is described as the release rate the Agency assumed from 2019 data; “the latest published figure” is now “we have found no later published figure”.
- Bentham: the comparison named PFOA as the contamination of concern at Angus Fire; the reported groundwater results there are PFOS and PFOA. “Legally produced” is now “produced”.
- Wording that adopted an agency’s framing: second sweep. “Precautionary”, “precautionarily”, “as a precaution”, “historic” and “safe” in our own voice are now the body’s quoted words or plain dates (take-action, council FAQ, Common criticisms, Start here, The Numbers, timeline, ICI, Hillylaid Pool, residential testing, the “lower risk” post); the council’s “precautionary screening level” is named wherever it is relayed (CL:AIRE interim Category 4 Screening Level, 7.6 µg/kg for gardens with home-grown produce); “To be fair to the company” (AGC accounts) and the Agency’s self-description of its role (EA 25 sites) are replaced; the FAQ headings “Water Safety” and “Food Safety”, The Numbers’ “Food Safety Assessments” and the homepage’s “food safety assessments” are renamed; the heading “What the position gets right” (one position, three speakers) is now “Where the position is correct, and where it stops”; the site’s search metadata no longer claims “verified environmental data” or lists “regulatory compliance”.
- Older changelog entries. Entries of 6 March, 2 August and 18 February 2026 below carried wording later corrected elsewhere (“the EFSA safe limit of 4.4 µg/kg”, “closed as a precaution”, the Hillylaid attribution, “standardised incidence rates”). Each now carries a bracketed, dated note; the changelog archive, which is kept word for word, carries one note at its head listing them.
- A legal read of the whole site (18 October, Codex briefed as the company’s counsel and as a defamation specialist) found one passage that implied dishonesty, and others that stated more than the record shows. All corrected the same day; the at-a-glance count includes them.
- AGC’s closure and its accounts: the post said “four years of losses” appeared “only in the press statement, the one place no one is held to account for what it says”, that the filed accounts and the statement “do not tell the same story”, and that AGC’s answer was “not reconciled”. Company-wide profits are compatible with losses at one internal unit, and one principal activity does not preclude internal business units. The audited figures stand; the post now states AGC’s unit-level explanation as AGC’s claim, which cannot be verified because the figures are confidential, and the inference of a false explanation is removed. The matching entries on Open questions and AGC now read “Explanation supplied; unit figures not independently verified”. The source note’s “under its former name, Asahi Glass” is corrected: the UK company was already named AGC Chemicals Europe in 2014 and 2015.
- PFAS as “top risk”. AGC’s 2024 accounts (title, summary and body) and the closure post called PFAS regulation the company’s “top”, “first and foremost”, “leading” or “principal” risk. The accounts give a numbered list and do not say it is ranked; the pages now say PFAS regulation is listed first among the principal risks, and that the accounts do not say the list is in order of importance.
- The October 2024 fire: the title, summary and body still said the only public record did not say what burned and that the fire’s nature “has not been made public”. AGC’s notification and investigation report, disclosed by the Environment Agency on 2 September 2026, describe a lagging fire on the Steam Pyrolysis section, the process gas involved and an estimated release; the post now carries that, attributed to AGC, with the dated history of what was and was not public kept. The timeline entry “the October 2024 fire becomes public” (14 July 2026) now says that Hillhouse Watch published its investigation that day and that the fire had appeared in AGC’s accounts filed in September 2025.
- Timeline, Leigh Day: the entry said Leigh Day’s theory was “private nuisance on a continuing basis” and that “because the contamination is ongoing, there is no limitation period”. We have no exact statement by Leigh Day to that effect, and whether a nuisance is continuing, and which limitation rules apply, are questions of fact and law. The entry now says what Leigh Day has published: that it is investigating the viability of legal action. We have seen no announcement that a claim has been issued.
- Who has been at Hillhouse: the register’s version dates were presented as proof of who held each discharge consent at each date (“held by”, “Versions held”). The register names a company against a version date; it does not by itself show the legal holder throughout. The page now says so, as the ICI page already did.
- Timeline, 2012 entry: “PFOA is not remediated from the surrounding environment” and “the study … attributes them to … a reservoir remaining within the site, not to continued use” stated more than the record shows. Detection shows contamination remains, not that nothing has been remediated; Dalmijn et al. offer re-emission as a possibility and say current use or formation must be ruled out.
- Other contamination pathways: a passage said a risk-management framework “exists precisely so that a report does not just note that a pathway is being looked at elsewhere and move on”, which implied that WSP and the Agency had fallen short of LCRM. We have not established what that framework requires of this phased report. The passage now states the information gap and what we are asking the Agency for.
- Victrex and Veolia, 2018: the timeline called the £80,000 a “penalty” and said the chemicals “would have contaminated the River Wyre”; Victrex said the legal form was unknown. The Environment Agency’s archived list of enforcement undertakings accepted between June and September 2020 records two undertakings for “a permit breach at Victrex Technology Centre, Lancashire in June 2018”: Victrex (reference 614) contributing £35,000 to Wyre Rivers Trust and Veolia (reference 694) £45,000 to Lancashire Wildlife Trust. An enforcement undertaking is an offer by the operator that the Agency accepts; the case appears in no record we hold as a prosecution or fine. The Gazette’s headline said the spill “could have contaminated” the river, and gave July 2018; the Agency’s list gives June. Both pages now say so.
- Timeline, smaller items: the 1980s entry asserted a corporate consolidation under ICI Chemicals and Polymers Ltd with no primary source (now limited to what the discharge-consent register and Companies House show); the 1988 entry said the site “would have been subject to” the CIMAH Regulations 1984 “throughout the 1980s and 1990s” and the 2003 entry asserted COMAH coverage for that year (both now give the legislative history separately from the earliest site-specific record we hold, HSE’s lists to October 2021); the 2006 entry’s PTFE and ETFE tonnages are now stated as the permitted capacities recorded in WSP’s February 2025 desk study; the 2011 entry implied the supplier’s Repr. 2 self-classification dates from 2011, which the Environment Agency’s 2023 evaluation does not say.
- Statements that went beyond the evidence: What To Do said four descriptions of the 1 km zone “are not the same perimeter” (different wording does not show different perimeters were intended; now “do not establish whether the same perimeter was intended”); the council FAQ said five times that “nobody” had claimed a blood result could show cause or predict illness (now limited to this site and Leigh Day’s published material); a link on Sources and evidence called a chart “AI-generated” where the post itself says only that its caption reads “Generated using AI”; The Numbers described the 783 kg figure as “the current” discharge figure (it is the Agency’s estimate from 2019 data) and said other operators’ discharge records “are not readily accessible” (public permits and reported emissions exist for Victrex and others; what is missing is PFAS data that would attribute the shared-outfall results).
- Older changelog entries. Entries of 6 March, 30 September and 18 February 2026 below still said the permit has “no PFAS monitoring requirement on any of its 15+ air emission points” or no “PFAS limit on air emissions”, and that the 119 µg/kg reading was “still rising when sampling stopped, a pattern consistent with groundwater migration”; both were corrected on later dates (27 September; 26 September). Each now carries a bracketed note, and the changelog archive head note lists them.
Updates
- What is PFAS has a new section, “What counts as PFAS?”. A reader suggested saying plainly that PFAS are man-made. The section explains that the number of PFAS depends on the definition (several thousand in use, Glüge et al. 2020; over 7 million structures in the PubChem database under the OECD’s 2021 definition, Schymanski et al. 2023), quotes the peer-reviewed literature on their synthetic origin (Cousins et al. 2020; Evich et al. 2022), notes that a natural source has been proposed for one PFAS, trifluoroacetic acid, and that a 2021 review found the evidence insufficient (Joudan et al. 2021), and says which PFAS are at issue at Hillhouse. A first version, published at about 08:30 on 18 October, quoted the UK Health Security Agency and the Environment Agency for the man-made origin and for a count; it was withdrawn at 09:07 and republished later the same day with those statements sourced to peer-reviewed papers instead (see Corrections).
New
- New page: Glossary. Fifty-one terms, acronyms and units used on this site (for example PFAS, PFOA, EEA-NH4, LSOA, standardised incidence ratio, limit of detection, Part 2A, COMAH and the units µg/kg, ng/L and ng/ml), including an entry that says in plain words what Phase 1, Phase 2 and Phase 3 of the Environment Agency soil investigation each covered, citing each report by title and date. Scientific terms are defined from peer-reviewed papers, cited with DOI; legal and procedural terms from the law or the body that sets the procedure, labelled as such; regulators are described in their own words. Where definitions differ, as with PFAS and cluster, the entry says so. No definition contains a figure about Hillhouse. A first version, published at about 08:30 on 18 October, defined nine scientific terms from UK Health Security Agency and Environment Agency pages; it was withdrawn at 09:07 and the page republished later the same day with those entries re-sourced (see Corrections).
- New post: Phase 2 garden soil readings and the Health Cell’s kidney cancer area, on one map. A map of the highest Phase 2 garden PFOA reading in each 300 m hexagon, the directions of highest readings stated in the Phase 3 report, and the residential land of the neighbourhood area where the Lancashire Health Cell counted 14 kidney cancers against about 6 expected. The post and the map state that the overlap is co-location, not cause, quote the Health Cell’s conclusion that there is no evidence of a statistically significant kidney cancer cluster, and set out what the map does not show, including the Health Cell’s comparison populations, rounding and the absence of Phase 3 positions. No garden or house is shown; the base map carries street names from OpenStreetMap.
Site changes
- Links to the glossary. The footer and the reading list on Start here link to the Glossary. On Start here, The Numbers, Health, Sources and evidence, the FAQ and Open Questions, the first use of each glossary term is a link to its entry. Withdrawn with the Glossary at 09:07 on 18 October and restored with it.
17 October 2026 (Wyre Council reports)
Updates
- Open questions: Wyre Council’s accessibility complaint answered. On 16 October 2026 the council upheld at Stage 1 (ref ONE000291) the complaint made on 9 October 2026 about three reports published only through an embedded Issuu viewer: the Phase 1 technical report, the Phase 2 factual report and the Occupation Road interpretative report. It removed the Issuu links, published all three as downloadable, text-searchable PDFs, apologised that the problem was not resolved when first raised in March 2026, and said future reports will not rely on an embedded viewer alone. Both entries on the page now show it as answered.
- The Reports (Accessible Copies) now says the council’s own copies are downloadable PDFs as of October 2026 and links to them directly. Our copies stay up as a permanent record.
- Victrex: the source line for the Phase 2 factual report now links to the council’s PDF instead of the Issuu page, which the council has removed. The page numbers cited are unchanged.
17 October 2026 (CrowdJustice fund)
New
- New page: The CrowdJustice fund for expert work. A fund on CrowdJustice for expert work in the Thornton-Cleveleys PFAS matter opened at 13:00 on 17 October 2026. The page says who hosts it (the person who runs this site, who is the Case Owner and a client of Leigh Day), that the money goes to Leigh Day’s client account and not to this site or to him, what it is meant to pay for, the targets and the all-or-nothing rule, and that CrowdJustice’s terms send unused funds to an approved cause, less a 10% fee.
Site changes
- Footer and disclosure wording. The footer now links to the page and says the money goes to Leigh Day’s client account. A matching disclosure line is added to About, Start here, Contacting Leigh Day, Sources and evidence, the FAQ and Information and resources, so that no page describes the site’s relationship with Leigh Day differently from the others. No evidence page changed because of the fund.
14 October 2026 (Who has been at Hillhouse)
New
- New page: Who has been at Hillhouse: companies and bodies on the site since 1889. A profile of every company and public body we have found on record as operating at, holding a permit or consent at, occupying, or applying for planning permission on the Hillhouse site, from the salt works of the 1890s to today, with links to the full pages on AGC, Victrex, ICI, NPL and EVC, INEOS and Vinnolit. Each entry says what the company did there, what its permits allow it to release where they say, and any enforcement on the public registers, with what was searched. The list is a floor: the page explains why. A table lists the companies registered at a Hillhouse address, from Companies House only. Reviewed before publication by a five-way panel over three rounds.
14 October 2026 (NPL; EVC, INEOS and Vinnolit)
New
- New page: NPL at Hillhouse: the main landowner, its companies, and what the public record shows. NPL Group at Hillhouse: its companies on the estate, what the public record shows they run (roads, utilities, security, three Environment Agency discharge consents including a “Lagoon Outfall”, and the permit for the former ICI chemical waste landfill), its part in the masterplan, the Enterprise Zone’s marketing for sale since August 2025, its stated plans, and its filed accounts, quoted with their own conclusions. Where NPL’s figures differ from other records, both are given with their sources. Reviewed before publication by a five-way panel over three rounds.
- New page: European Vinyls Corporation and INEOS at Hillhouse: the PVC plant, what it used and released, and how it closed. The PVC plant at Hillhouse from ICI to closure in 2019 under European Vinyls Corporation, INEOS and Vinnolit: what it made, its vinyl chloride and other releases as reported to the Pollution Inventory, its hazardous substances consents, the 2021 permit surrender and the soil sampling behind it, and a 1988 industry register’s count of cases at the site. No document we hold ties the plant to PFAS or to the 2024 to 2025 Royles Brook findings, and the page says so. Reviewed before publication by a five-way panel over three rounds.
14 October 2026 (ICI)
New
- New page: ICI at Hillhouse: what it made, where its waste went, and where the two main ICI companies are now. Imperial Chemical Industries at Hillhouse: who ran the site, what was made there, when PFOA was used, the waste tips and lagoons recorded in Lancashire County Council’s 2011 planning file, the main outfall consent held in ICI’s name from 1980 to January 1999, what today’s investigations say, and where ICI’s companies are now. The 1954 to 1999 PFOA totals on the page are our own sums from the rows of AGC’s decade table, and they are not a figure for ICI alone, because the 1990s row includes 1999, the year AGC took over. No source we found says who holds ICI’s historic liabilities at Hillhouse, and the page says so. Reviewed before publication by a five-way panel over three rounds.
14 October 2026 (Victrex)
New
- New page: Victrex at Hillhouse: what it makes, what its permit covers, and what it says about PFAS. Victrex plc at Hillhouse: how it came out of ICI, what it makes there, the substances its Environment Agency permit names, its Pollution Inventory returns for 2022 to 2024, its lower-tier COMAH status, the incidents on record, and what Victrex itself has said about PFAS. Victrex’s permit does not use the terms PFAS, PFOA, perfluoro, polyfluoro, fluoropolymer or PTFE. Reviewed before publication by a five-way panel over three rounds.
14 October 2026 (AGC in its own words)
New
- New page: AGC in Its Own Words. What AGC Chemicals Europe and its parent, AGC Inc., have said to Parliament, to the Environment Agency, to investors, to the press and to us about the Hillhouse site, PFOA, emissions, the October 2024 fire, remediation and closure. Every quotation is copied from the document named beside it, with its date and a link; Japanese passages are given with our own translation, marked as ours. Three AGC documents are quoted on this site for the first time: the November 2024 return to the Environment Agency listing “unauthorised emissions” (none of the sixteen entries names PFOA or any other PFAS), AGC’s Stage 2 investigation report on the fire, released by the Environment Agency under EIR2026/37608 and public on WhatDoTheyKnow, and note 24 of AGC’s 2024 accounts. Reviewed before publication by a five-way panel over three rounds.
Update
- The site’s COMAH status. Rows on Questions said the site’s status under the major-hazard regulations was not confirmed. The Health and Safety Executive’s public COMAH register, checked 14 October 2026, lists the site as a lower-tier establishment, as our fire article already said. The rows now say so; what remains open is the site’s status on the day of the fire, which we have asked the HSE.
14 October 2026 (kidney cancer pages)
A third panel review of the kidney cancer pages found errors that the earlier rounds today had not removed. In every case the error was ours. The Health Cell’s public statement of 15 June 2026, which two posts quote, was checked against the live page on Lancashire County Council’s news site; every quotation from it on those posts matches.
Corrections
- “The Council” in titles and links. Two post titles (assessment questions, statement omissions) and link text on Common criticisms and the timeline called the kidney cancer report or statement “the Council’s”, which readers take to mean Wyre Council. Wyre Borough Council is a member of the Health Cell, whose membership completed the assessment and the report, and Wyre Council publishes it; the Health Cell was convened by Lancashire County Council’s Director of Public Health, and LCC Public Health owns the document. Titles and link text now say Lancashire County Council, and the pages name the Lancashire County Council Health Cell at first mention. The link text on Evidence now matches the titles.
- Kidney cancer post: the headline. Kidney Cancer South-East of Hillhouse was titled “… The Health Cell Found the Variation ‘Consistent With Normal Statistical Fluctuation’.” It is now “Kidney Cancer South-East of Hillhouse: 14 Cases Where 6 Were Expected. What the Health Cell’s Assessment Did and Did Not Measure.” The summary quotes the report’s conclusion, “no evidence of a kidney cancer cluster” and “consistent with normal statistical fluctuation”, and says the report did not measure anyone’s exposure and does not seek to establish causality. The web address is unchanged; the timeline link text matches the new title.
- “No link” post: what the Health Cell tested. The no link post said in its title, summary and three sections that the study did not assess the cause, that “the causal question was not asked”, that the statement was “a causal all-clear” and that “no one has assessed” a link. The report’s second stage asked “whether the observed pattern could, in principle, be linked to a plausible environmental exposure pathway”, and compared the distribution of cases with soil and air-dispersion data; the report says it does not “seek to establish causality”. The post, now titled “‘No Indication of a Link’: What the Lancashire County Council Health Cell Compared, and What It Did Not Test”, says that; it also says “no indication of a link” rests on that comparison together with the distance analysis and the review of tumour types, and asks the Health Cell to say that “no indication of a link” is not a finding on causation. The web address is unchanged. A row on the Questions page quoted the statement as “for contextual comparison only and not to assess causation”, dropping “individual exposure or”, and asked the Health Cell to “acknowledge no causation assessment was done”. The row now quotes the statement in full and asks on what basis the Health Cell concluded there was “no indication of a link”. A second Questions row asked whether the local rate had been compared “only against neighbouring areas … rather than against the England rate”; the report compares against England throughout. That row now asks whether the other small areas the rate was compared with, against which it was “statistically similar”, may share the same exposure.
- Comparisons and case locations described as unpublished. The kidney cancer post said the report “does not publish figures” for its other comparisons and “does not show where the cases were”, and the status lines on it and on the assessment questions, no concern and statement omissions posts said the report does not name, or does not quantify, its comparison populations. Technical Appendix 1 maps the ratio for each small area, Technical Appendix 2 compares the cases in the area south-east of the site with the 498 kidney tumours in the 79 small areas across Wyre, Fylde and Blackpool that were listed to NDRS, and Technical Appendix 4 charts the ratios over time “faceted by comparison group”: England, the North West region, Wyre (or Fylde, Blackpool and Wyre together) and a group the charts label “lanc_sampled_lsoas”. The pages now say the report gives its comparisons as statements and charts but not the comparator rates or ratios as figures, and that what it withholds is the postcode location of each case. The kidney cancer post also said members of the Health Cell “hold both” the cancer table and the soil coordinates; that is removed, and the post no longer says those two would test the alignment, since neither locates cases within an area. The no link post and the assessment questions post are corrected the same way.
- “Significant”, against what. The assessment questions title said “A Significant Finding” and its text “significantly higher”; two headings on the statement omissions post and image captions on the kidney cancer and no link posts used “significant” without the report’s term or its comparator, and a question on the Questions page referred to “the significant excess” and said “the contamination runs by direction”. They now say statistically significant against England’s rates, and the question says that PFOA in the gardens WSP sampled in Phases 2 and 3 runs by direction rather than distance.
- The report’s remit. The no concern post treated the report’s remit as the study area “taken as a whole”, described the small-area excess as a separate question its conclusion did not cover, and kept the gloss “higher than expected by more than chance would predict”. The report’s second stage examined the two small-area findings, and its Technical Appendix 2 sets the cases in the area south-east of the site against the 498 tumours in the 79 study-area small areas. The post now describes both stages, quotes the report’s conclusion, “no evidence of a kidney cancer cluster” and “consistent with normal statistical fluctuation”, and asks for the comparison figures behind it. Its title quoted “No Concern”, words the report does not use; it now quotes the report’s “no further cluster investigation”. The web address is unchanged.
- Blood testing and the report’s conclusion. The assessment questions post said “the test that could settle it was not done”, meaning PFAS blood testing, and that the report “reaches a confident conclusion the limitations do not fully support”. No source supports either. The post now quotes the report: it “did not include direct measures of individual exposure”, and its conclusion, taking its stated limitations into account, finds the variation “consistent with normal statistical fluctuation”.
- The blood-test figures are PFOA. Common criticisms said the available reports do not say whether the reported percentages refer to PFOA alone or to several PFAS combined. Leigh Day’s release of 24 September 2026 gives “levels of PFOA above 20 nanograms per millilitre (ng/ml) in 69.4% of participants”, “with the overall average at 26 ng/ml”. The page now quotes it.
- A retrospective study of health outcomes exists. Health said no retrospective study had examined health outcomes among residents. The Health Cell’s assessment is one: cancer registrations for 2003 to 2022, counted by place of residence at diagnosis. The page now says so, with the report’s own statements on residential mobility and on the years before 2003.
- Where the figures are in the report, and one opening line. The no concern post said the 14 cases, 6 expected and ratio of 218 are in the report’s Results; they are in its Background, and the gradient finding and the comparison with other small areas are in its Results. The PFOA and kidney cancer post opened with a line saying it was from the Health Cell’s report; it is not, and the line now says what the post covers.
- The Shearer study: which adjustment changed the result. The PFOA and kidney cancer post said that after adjusting for kidney function (eGFR) the estimate comparing the highest and lowest exposure groups lost statistical significance. In Shearer et al. (2021), the odds ratio of 2.63 (95% CI 1.33 to 5.20) is already adjusted for eGFR; the estimate of 2.19 (95% CI 0.86 to 5.61) comes from further adjustment for two other PFAS, PFOS and PFHxS (Table 2, footnotes b and d). The post now says so, and that the authors report the association persisted among participants without diminished kidney function.
14 October 2026
A first-principles source review of the whole site took each claim back to its primary document. It produced 48 corrections, listed below; in every case the error was ours, in attribution, sourcing, wording or reading. Claims for which no primary source was found were removed rather than qualified: 45 are held on our to-source list, and a further set of corporate-history, regulatory and local-news claims were put back in a narrower form, each tied to the source that was found. The biggest single change is that the 2012 date for the end of PFOA use and the start of EEA-NH4 is now attributed to AGC wherever it appears, because no independent record dates it. Earlier today we also put six questions to AGC; that update is the first entry under Updates.
Corrections
- The 2012 date is AGC’s. About, Start here, What is PFAS?, Open questions, The Numbers, Evidence, FAQ, Common criticisms, Wyre Council’s FAQ page, the timeline and four posts (Kinfauns Castle, Hillylaid Pool, HSE consultation, Phase 3 results) said in our own voice that PFOA use ended and EEA-NH4 began in 2012, and that PFOA was used for “around 60 years”. No permit, purchase or inspection record dates the change; the date is AGC’s statement, repeated by Wyre Council. The pages now say “AGC says”. The only dated start we found is Dalmijn et al. (2025): “From 1955 to 2012, ammonium perfluorooctanoate (APFO) was used as a processing aid”. The “60 years”, the 1890s and 1950s start dates and “AGC therefore knew” are removed. The Defra and Environment Agency answer of 17 April 2026 is cited for a small amount of PFOA still being generated by the current process.
- The 783 kg figure. Twelve pages (The Numbers, Evidence, FAQ, council FAQ, Start here, What is PFAS?, Information and Resources, the timeline and four posts) gave 783 kg as a quantity discharged in 2019 and as “the latest published figure”. It is the Environment Agency’s assumed release rate of 0.783 tonnes a year to the River Wyre, calculated from the 2019 average effluent concentration and effluent flow rate (the evaluation labels the flow figures “company data”), on page 69 of its evaluation (we cited page 68). “Latest published figure” is removed. Two posts now give a dated search: on 14 October 2026 the Environment Agency’s 2024 Pollution Inventory dataset lists no EEA-NH4 row for AGC’s permit, and the 17 April 2026 written answer gives no discharge figure.
- PFOA compared with a limit for a sum of PFAS. “206 times”, “around 120 times” and “over 200 times” compared PFOA alone with 100 ng/L, which in Directive (EU) 2020/2184 is the value for the sum of 20 specified PFAS. The multiples are removed from The Numbers, Evidence, FAQ, Start here and four posts (Bentham, March 2026 update, Hillylaid Pool, two consents). The pages give PFOA alone (20,624 ng/L), the study’s highest sum of detected PFAS (22,542 ng/L), and the sum at the main outfall W1 (30 and 33 ng/L).
- AGC’s mass balance and the 145 tonne estimate. The Numbers, Evidence, the timeline and two posts (Kinfauns Castle, Bentham) called 145 tonnes an “earlier estimate, later superseded” and gave 103 tonnes as a total. No document links the two. They now sit side by side: an Environment Agency estimate of about 145 tonnes (75 to water, 70 to air), cited by Dalmijn et al.; and AGC’s 20 December 2023 Regulation 61 submission, as reported by the Guardian and Watershed Investigations, of 49.1 tonnes to air and 54.3 to water, which is AGC’s calculation, not a measurement. 103.4 tonnes is our own sum. [Corrected 18 October 2026: the 145 tonnes is recorded as AGC’s own estimate, attributed to the Agency by Dalmijn et al.; see the entry of that date above.]
- “First” detection of EEA-NH4 and the Hazelrigg air results. The timeline, The Numbers, Evidence, FAQ, Common criticisms, Start here, Information and Resources and three posts (March 2026 update, HSE consultation, Bentham) said Dalmijn et al. made the first detection of EEA-NH4, the first measurement in air, and showed airborne transport up to 20 km. The authors say their study “is the first to quantify EEA in any matrix”; they measured EEA, the anion; Megson et al. (2024) cite earlier Environment Agency detection at an average of 2.24 mg/L (2016 to 2020). At Hazelrigg they found PFOA in 20 of 21 air samples (0.51 to 2.50 pg/m3) and EEA in three, and call the evidence “largely circumstantial”. The pages now state those results.
- Megson et al. (2024). The timeline, The Numbers and Evidence gave “697 matched”, “approximately 40 µg/L” without its assumption, and said the paper used no total-fluorine method. They now give 89 to 1,175 candidate PFAS at confidence level 4 (33 at level 3, 10 at level 2), an estimate of about 38 to 40 µg/L on the assumption that all 43 identified PFAS responded as PFOA, and that 8 of the 43 (17% of peak area) are in the Drinking Water Inspectorate’s 47-PFAS panel.
- Who instructed WSP, and the phases. The timeline, The Numbers, Evidence and FAQ said the investigation was Wyre Council’s and misdescribed the phases. WSP’s Phase 1 report says it was instructed by the Environment Agency, which leads the inspection on behalf of Wyre Council; at the 12 March 2026 drop-in Wyre, UKHSA and the Agency each gave a different answer on who leads. Phase 1 was 79 sample points in 22 council-owned parcels (about 246 samples collected, 199 analysed; fieldwork 9 September to 4 October 2024). Phase 2 was 291 samples from 63 points (fieldwork February to March 2025; final issue 9 July 2025; PFOA detected in 287). Phase 3 fieldwork ran from 9 October to 19 November 2025.
- The source of the soil PFOA. The Numbers, Evidence, FAQ, Start here, About and the residential testing post listed current operations and shared estate infrastructure as possible sources and said no attribution had been published. WSP’s Phase 3 report says aerial deposition of PFOA “is considered to result from historical airborne emissions associated with the AGCCE facility and former site operators”. It does not apportion it between operators or periods. The pages now quote that.
- The allotment conclusions are Wyre Council’s report. Thirteen pages and posts (including the timeline, FAQ, Common criticisms, council FAQ, Start here, Information and Resources, Open questions, The Numbers, Evidence and three posts) stated in our own voice that the Environment Agency had concluded the Occupation Road and Sandringham Avenue allotments meet the contaminated-land criteria, and gave Wyre’s reasoning as the Agency’s. They now say Wyre Council reported it (5 March, 3 July and 12 August 2026), quote Wyre’s “significant possibility” sentence as Wyre’s, and note that WSP’s report to the Agency recommends Category 2: Human Health on a precautionary basis, with no formal Part 2A determination recorded in the updates or letter.
- Egg results. “Elevated PFAS in every egg” and “exceeds safe weekly thresholds” were in our voice on FAQ, Common criticisms, The Numbers, Evidence, Start here, Information and Resources and the timeline. WSP detected all four EFSA PFAS in all 19 samples from four properties, a sum of 3.4 to 46 µg/kg (PFOA 44%, PFOS 51%). “Elevated” and the Tolerable Weekly Intake are Wyre Council’s and the Food Standards Agency’s words; the intake is set for the sum of four PFAS. The BBC egg article is dated 2 February 2026, not 21 February.
- Screening values and the single property. 1.4 and 7.6 µg/kg were described as values WSP applies. They are the CL:AIRE interim Category 4 Screening Levels (allotments; residential with home-grown produce). The “first residential property tested” and “named residential property” are removed (WSP states no order); the property is a poultry-keeper property (WSP code POUL-SP510) with 25 results. “Found in the majority of properties” now reads: above the limit of detection in 1,116 of 1,126 soil samples from 71 properties. Pages: The Numbers, Evidence, FAQ, Common criticisms, council FAQ, timeline, Start here, Information and Resources, Open questions and three posts. Two lines left behind, in Open questions and the residential testing post, still credited 7.6 µg/kg to WSP; they now name CL:AIRE.
- IARC’s basis, and the volume date. The timeline, Start here, What is PFAS?, Health and two posts (Hillylaid Pool, PFOA and kidney cancer) said there was enough evidence that PFOA causes cancer in humans, or “definite cause”. IARC’s Group 1 rests on sufficient evidence in experimental animals and strong mechanistic evidence in exposed humans, with limited evidence for cancer in humans (renal cell carcinoma and testicular cancer). The working group met 7 to 14 November 2023; the council FAQ no longer says Volume 135 was “published 2025”.
- Where the kidney cancer area is. Common criticisms, Start here, Health, the timeline and five posts (cluster, no link, no concern, omissions, assessment questions) said the area was “beside”, “next to” or “immediately” by the site, and that the report “did not examine exposure”. The Health Cell report says the first area (E01025596) is south-east of the site and close to it, with no distance. It compared case locations with Environment Agency soil results and modelled air dispersion, found no spatial alignment, and used no direct measure of individual exposure. “Cluster” is now described as our use of a general definition, not the report’s finding.
- Health conditions on the Health page. Health listed infection susceptibility, altered immune function, hypertension, liver effects, developmental effects, low birth weight and reduced fertility as PFAS-linked, against the C8 Science Panel page it cites. It now lists the Panel’s six probable links (kidney cancer, testicular cancer, thyroid disease, ulcerative colitis, diagnosed high cholesterol, pregnancy-induced hypertension) and the outcomes the US National Academies (2022) rate as sufficient evidence: decreased antibody response, dyslipidemia, decreased infant and fetal growth, and kidney cancer.
- BBC cancer figures. Health said the BBC reported cancer prevalence “35-43% above the national average”, and Evidence said “above the national average”. The BBC (30 June 2025) gave 4.49%, 4.58% and 4.42% for three areas in 2021, and said local rates were “broadly in line with those in surrounding areas”; Lancashire County Council gave 3.5% for Lancashire and the south Lake District and 3.2% for England. Both pages now give those figures.
- Washing and peeling. FAQ, Start here, Information and Resources and The Numbers said plants take up PFAS through the roots, that washing cannot remove it, and that peeling removes what is in the skin. The Food Standards Agency’s stated reason for washing and peeling is to remove soil, dust and bacteria. We found no source that peeling removes PFOA; a 2026 review notes some PFAS are at higher concentrations in the peel of root vegetables, which is now stated.
- The HSE consultation on EEA-NH4. The timeline, Start here, What is PFAS?, Evidence and the HSE post gave HSE’s proposed categories, their bases and the close date from press reports. They are now cited to HSE’s own consultation (GBCLP 009, 2 March to 1 May 2026): Carcinogenicity Category 2, which HSE calls “a borderline case between Category 2 and no classification”, and Reproductive toxicity Category 1B, with the other proposed hazard classes. The post’s claim of a “first formal classification process under GB CLP” is removed; HSE’s page does not say it.
- EEA-NH4’s properties and classification. The timeline, Evidence and What is PFAS? said the Environment Agency “classified” EEA-NH4 as very persistent and mobile, that it “does not break down naturally”, that AGC’s reproductive-toxicity classification was “confirmed”, that EFSA “approves” it, and that a 2011 study showed “developmental harm”. The Agency considers it very persistent by analogy with other PFAS, there being no degradation data, and likely to meet the draft criteria. Its UK supplier self-classified it as Reproductive Toxicity Category 2, which the Agency records. The EFSA panel found no safety concern for a stated use (recorded 19 May 2011). The 2011 study showed reduced pup survival; HSE said the information does not allow a clear conclusion on development or on lactation.
- PFOA’s legal status. The timeline, The Numbers, What is PFAS? and the Hillylaid Pool post said PFOA was “prohibited in the UK since 4 July 2020”, “banned in the EU 2020” or required to be eliminated by all states. The Stockholm Convention requires elimination except where registered exemptions apply, and the 17 April 2026 Defra and Environment Agency answer says a specific exemption exists for the production and use of PFOA, its salts and related compounds. Delegated Regulation (EU) 2020/784 applies from 4 July 2020, with a derogation for PTFE and PVDF gas filter membranes until 4 July 2023. The pages now say that.
- The US EPA Stewardship Program. The timeline said the commitment covered US operations only and that Hillhouse continued to use PFOA. The EPA fact sheet says eight companies, including Asahi Glass, committed to cut facility emissions and product content by 95 percent by 2010 and to work toward elimination by 2015, and reported on US and global operations.
- The C8 litigation and Science Panel. The timeline dated the Parkersburg class action to 2007 with about 3,500 residents, called the C8 work “the largest PFAS health study ever conducted” and said it established PFOA as a human carcinogen. Frisbee et al. (2009) record the August 2001 filing, certified as a class action, and the November 2004 $107 million settlement. 69,030 people were enrolled in 2005 to 2006; that paper calls it “the largest known population study of community PFC exposure”. The 2007 and 3,500 figures are removed.
- European comparisons. The Numbers, Evidence, the timeline, Health and the biomonitoring post described a Belgian “government-ordered shutdown”, “up to 70,000” offered blood tests, a Dutch “court-ordered soil replacement at 1,300 locations”, “~3,500 ng/L” at Little Hocking and a French “regulatory mandate”. They now state what the sources say: the Flemish environmental agency issued a safety measure on 29 October 2021 prohibiting all PFAS emissions from the 3M site; 8,568 people gave a blood sample within 5 km (a 2023 to 2025 study); in the Netherlands 382 residents gave blood in autumn 2016 (not 2016 to 2017) and RIVM advised against eating home-grown produce within 1 km; and Arkema says it ceased all use of 6:2 FTS at the end of December 2024. The 70,000, 1,300 and 3,500 figures and the French ban item are removed.
- The Guardian, February 2023, and the REACH list. The timeline said the Guardian reported PFOA “far above standards” and the site’s history, and that AGC “self-classified PFOA as an SVHC” in 2008. The Guardian reported PFOA at up to 12,000 ng/L in samples of AGC’s effluent from 2021 and noted there is no UK standard for PFOA in rivers or effluent; AGC’s statement is quoted. The 2008 entry is removed; PFOA’s addition to the REACH Candidate List on 20 June 2013 is added from Regulation (EU) 2017/1000.
- “First” parliamentary question. The timeline headed 19 March 2026 as the first parliamentary question although the same page records one on 19 June 2025. It now says “Parliamentary question”.
- COMAH. The fire post and the timeline stated the site’s tier without a source and put the regulation 17(1) duty on the operator. Regulation 17(1) places it on the competent authority; the duty to send safety information to the public falls on upper tier operators (regulation 18). HSE’s COMAH register, read on 14 October 2026, lists AGC Chemicals Europe at Thornton Cleveleys as a lower tier establishment. “No law obliged the company to tell them any more than that” is removed. The questions as sent to AGC are left as sent.
- The discharge consents and the EEA-NH4 permit entry. The timeline, FAQ, council FAQ and two posts said the 2006 permit “sets no emission limit for EEA-NH4” from a table entry whose code, SAA-1000, we had equated with EEA-NH4; that consent 017290384 “has never been updated”; and that neither consent requires PFAS monitoring. The Environment Agency’s April 2023 evaluation says the permit requires monitoring of EEA-NH4 in effluent and sets no numerical limit; that is now what the pages say. The public register lists consent 017290384 from 21 January 1999 with no later version and does not publish conditions, so the post on the two consents is retitled “Two Discharge Consents, Conditions Not Published” and states only what the register shows. The thermal treatment plant is described as the 2017 permit variation describes it.
- Jameson Road, Transwaste and Suez. The timeline and The Numbers stated in our own voice that Jameson Road served as settlement lagoons from the 1940s, and gave the “lake of acid” and “no lining” accounts of one anonymous former worker as fact. Transwaste’s account to the Guardian and the anonymous worker’s are now attributed. Dalmijn et al. say the two landfills (Hillhouse and Jameson Road) “were used until 2014 for disposal of material from the plant, which included <5 tons of PFOA”. The licence suspension is dated from the Environment Agency’s notice (effective 27 March 2025); the “70 permit breaches” are Central Radio’s, covering February 2024 to November 2025. “Suez ceased operations in 2017” is replaced by the planning permission expiring on 31 March 2017.
- The investigation’s scope was one attender’s account. The March 2026 post, The Numbers, Information and Resources, Health and Open questions stated that air, water, dust and skin pathways “have not been assessed”, or gave one chemical, one emission point and one pathway, as Wyre Council’s confirmation. They were officers’ remarks at one drop-in. WSP’s Sandringham report uses United Utilities drinking-water data, and the Phase 3 report refers to “other linkages of concern … including the risk to the water environment”.
- The 1 km zone. Information and Resources, Health, Open questions and the 1 km post said Wyre and the Food Standards Agency “set” the zone, and that a zone centred on the main stack would put significant portions inside the industrial estate. The FSA and Wyre announced it on 2 February 2026 and Wyre referred the question of its basis to the Agency. No document we hold gives the stack’s location, so that sentence is removed.
- Sampling grid and distance. The soil sampling post said every direction except the south-east was sampled on a grid four times wider, and it, Start here, the kidney cancer post and the Phase 3 post said the contamination “does not fall away with distance”. The Phase 3 report gives 200 m or wider beyond 500 m; within 500 m, Phase 2 used 100 m grids to the south and south-east and 150 m grids to the south and south-west, and Phase 3 used about 50 m in the south-east; no spacing is stated for the west-north-west. The distance statement is WSP’s finding for its Phase 2 and 3 gardens, within 1 km, and is now scoped to that. The soil sampling post is retitled.
- Blood-test figures and reference values. FAQ, Common criticisms, council FAQ, Start here, the Bentham post, the 49 residents post and the timeline gave the 69.4% figure, the 26 ng/ml average and the within-1 km result from an Environment Journal article we could not read. The figures are now attributed to Leigh Day’s press release and ITV News of 23 September 2026; the underlying results have not been published. The Bentham figure of 405 ng/ml is ITV’s, and the National Academies bands are for a sum of seven PFAS, which the report does not identify. “The UK has no official guidance on safe levels of PFAS in blood” is restated as what the documents we searched contain.
- PFOA, PFAS and “the contamination”. The council FAQ page, FAQ and Common criticisms used “the contamination” or “one named chemical, PFOA” where the evidence concerns one substance or a sum of several. The investigation is built around PFOA, and WSP analysed 50 PFAS. The council FAQ page now separates the cholesterol evidence by substance, states that the Tolerable Weekly Intake is for a sum of four PFAS, and dates the drinking-water tiers to the Drinking Water Inspectorate’s March 2025 guidance. The FAQ health heading now reads “linked to PFOA”.
- Quotations and attributions. Common criticisms gave the Leigh Day partner’s words as a paraphrase; they are now the BBC’s: “financial losses on residents’ homes and the impact it has had on their use and enjoyment of the land”. Information and Resources applied the Wyre FAQ’s 3 to 4 times and 7 to 8 times Tolerable Weekly Intake multiples to garden produce and called them “confirmed”; the FAQ says them only of some regular consumers of large amounts of allotment vegetables. Start here said UKHSA and FSA advice was “unchanged” in August 2026; the 12 August letter does not say so, and Wyre’s 3 July statement that FSA advice “remains the same” is quoted instead. AGC’s “well over a century” statement and the “under Part 2A” words in its quoted statement are given as ITV News reported them, attributed to AGC, and United Utilities as the water company is given as Wyre Council’s FAQ states it.
- Two sentences of our own commentary. The AGC accounts post headed a section “Their own auditors saw no problem” and said “this was not a company on the edge”. They are replaced by the auditor’s unqualified opinion and the going-concern note, which refers to AGC Inc.’s letter of support for at least twelve months. The soil report post said a consultant’s report is “by its nature, written in one safe direction”; that generalisation has no source and is removed.
- Worker studies on the FAQ. The FAQ gave 756 UK workers and per-site follow-up years from Consonni et al. (2013), said the Olsen (2007) workers were from 3M and said DuPont’s 1981 study was withheld “until a residents’ lawyer sent it in 2001”. IARC Monograph 135 says the six TFE sites, including Thornton-Cleveys, “comprised the entire population of workers in TFE manufacture in Europe and the USA”, among 5,879 male workers, and Monograph 110 says plant-specific results were not presented. The 756 and per-site years are removed. Olsen’s retirees were from 3M’s Decatur and Cottage Grove facilities. The EPA’s 2005 memorandum says DuPont “had studied PFOA in pregnant workers and their offspring as early as May, 1981”, and that EPA “was not aware of this information until Bilott sent it to EPA in 2001”.
- Kidney cancer post: the headline, who produced the report, and what it found. The post Kidney Cancer South-East of Hillhouse was titled “A Kidney-Cancer Cluster Sits South-East of Hillhouse”, and its summary and two lines said the Health Cell report “found” a cluster and that the excess was “more cases than chance alone would explain. The report says so itself.” The report does not say that. A first correction today retitled it “… The Council Called It Chance.”; that title, the summary and a heading attributed the report to “the Council”. The report is the work of a multi-agency Health Cell convened by Lancashire County Council’s Director of Public Health (members: Lancashire County Council, Wyre Borough Council, the Environment Agency, UKHSA, the NHS ICB and the National Disease Registration Service), with case counts and ratios from analyses provided by NDRS. The post also gave the ratio of 218 as “statistically significant” without saying it is against England’s rates; gave as the report’s grounds only small numbers, multiple comparisons and the lack of a distance gradient; said the report’s two-part test was “met” and that it “acknowledged the pathway”; said the C8 Science Panel, the US EPA and IARC described the link “alike”; included an unsourced sentence about how many investigated clusters are linked to an exposure; and dated the report June 2026. The title is now “Kidney Cancer South-East of Hillhouse: 14 Cases Where 6 Were Expected. The Health Cell Found the Variation ‘Consistent With Normal Statistical Fluctuation’.”, the report’s words. The post now names the Health Cell and NDRS; says the excess is against England and quotes the report that the rate there “was statistically similar to those in most other LSOAs, although it was higher than the England average”; quotes both purposes of its second stage and all its grounds, including “no alignment with expected environmental air dispersion or soil contamination data”, geographically dispersed cases and tumour “heterogeneity consistent with background incidence”; quotes what the report did not measure; gives each body’s own finding on PFOA and kidney cancer (IARC: sufficient evidence in experimental animals and strong mechanistic evidence in exposed humans, with limited evidence in humans for kidney and testicular cancer); takes the cluster definition from the US National Cancer Institute, cited; removes the unsourced sentence; and dates the report by the last-review date on its cover, 12 May 2026. Our reading of the distance finding is marked as ours. The web address is unchanged; the timeline link text matches the new title.
- The HSE consultation had closed. The HSE post (title, summary, opening and a heading) and Evidence said in the present tense that HSE “is consulting”. The consultation ran from 2 March to 1 May 2026. A line saying HSE’s proposal “proposes” the classifications now says “proposed”. The present tense now appears only inside the Defra and Environment Agency written answer of 17 April 2026, which said HSE was “currently consulting”. The post’s unsourced line that EEA-NH4 “was part of the fluoropolymer industry’s transition away from PFOA” is removed.
- A total for 43 PFAS compared with a limit for 20. The Numbers set Megson et al.’s estimated total of about 38,000 to 40,000 ng/L (an estimate across 43 identified PFAS, assuming each responds as PFOA does) beside the EU drinking water value of 100 ng/L, which is for the sum of 20 specified PFAS, and called it “380 to 400 times”. The multiple is removed.
- Where the Dalmijn et al. water readings were taken. The FAQ put a PFAS sum of 33 ng/L at W2. Both 30 and 33 ng/L are the two samples taken at W1, the main discharge; W2 feeds Hillylaid Pool. The Hillylaid Pool post and the post “What independently confirms 2012” (held as a draft) gave 1,744 ng/L as “EEA-NH4”; the paper measured EEA, the anion, and gave 21.17 and 17.12 ng/L of EEA at W1. Start here, the Bentham post and the March investigation update said the sum of detected PFAS “at that site” was 22,542 ng/L; the paper gives a range of 30 to 22,542 ng/L across all sampling points, and the pages now say that.
- 7.6 µg/kg described two ways. The FAQ, Common criticisms and Wyre Council’s FAQ page said 7.6 µg/kg was a threshold in the Environment Agency’s June 2025 update with “no derivation stated”. It is the CL:AIRE (2024) interim Category 4 Screening Level for PFOA on residential land with home-grown produce (Table 4.1, 0.0076 mg/kg), the same publication as the 1.4 µg/kg allotment level. All pages now say so.
- Periods and operators. Wyre Council’s FAQ page said AGC’s mass-balance estimates ran “from the 1950s to 2012”; AGC’s submission covers first production in the ICI period to 3 October 2023. The Hillylaid Pool post said ICI ran the site “from the 1950s to 1999”, and Start here, What is PFAS? and the timeline tied 1955 to ICI. Dalmijn et al. date the use of APFO at the plant to 1955 to 2012 and name ICI only as the former operator; the pages now say that. The What is PFAS? heading “AGC’s stated period of use: 1955 to 2012” is now attributed to Dalmijn et al. The timeline’s gloss that the paper’s quotation spans “both the ICI and AGC periods” is removed, and so is its sentence that AGC’s 2012 change “follows” its US EPA Stewardship Program commitments (no source).
- Exposure pathways. Health, The Numbers and the March investigation update said we had found no published site-specific assessment of dust ingestion or skin contact, and a first correction today still said none of “inhalation of airborne PFOA”. WSP’s reports for the Environment Agency on Occupation Road Allotments (February 2026) and Sandringham Avenue Allotments (June 2026) estimate PFOA exposure for allotment users from soil and dust ingestion, dermal contact with soil, inhalation of dust and eating allotment produce, using the CLEA model; both treat PFOA vapour inhalation as negligible and did not model it, and both consider significant indoor exposure in the allotment buildings unlikely. The Sandringham Avenue report uses United Utilities’ drinking-water data as part of background intake. The pages now say so, and limit the absence claim to inhalation of PFOA at homes, drinking water as a pathway from the site, and indoor air in homes from soil vapour.
- Discharge consents and the permit variation. The March investigation update and the dual-permit post called consent 017290384 “sewage and trade combined surface water”; the Environment Agency’s register gives its effluent type as “Trade - Surface Water”. The dual-permit post also dated the Dalmijn et al. sampling to 2025 (it was 12 February 2023; the paper was published in 2025) and the register’s earliest version of consent 017290033 to 1981 (it starts on 1 January 1980). The timeline said permit variation V004 introduced no monitoring requirements for PFAS; it lists SAA-1000 for monitoring at A5 and W1 and now says so. The timeline’s chemical name for EEA-NH4, in its 2012 and April 2023 entries, was a different structure from the one the Environment Agency gives for CAS 908020-52-0; both now use the Environment Agency’s name, and the April 2023 entry gives the evaluation’s own title and the name in its Table 1.1.
- Attribution, dates and wording. “A fluorochemical used as a replacement for PFOA” is now “AGC says” in What is PFAS? and About. The Environment Agency’s 0.783 tonnes a year is described on every page as calculated from the 2019 average effluent concentration and flow rate in the evaluation, which labels the flow figures “company data”, not as “AGC’s” figure, and the monitoring data as supplied by AGC Chemicals Europe, which the evaluation names as the UK supplier (The Numbers now says this too). Start here said EEA-NH4 “was found in the blood of 10 residents” without attribution; it now says press reports said so. The Leigh Day press release is cited as 24 September 2026 (results were given to participants on 23 September). The FAQ no longer says metals were reported in surface water (the Environment Agency’s July 2025 summary says heavy metals were generally low, with marginal mercury exceedances); it names the solvents. Open questions no longer says the west-north-west sector was “pre-classed” as low deposition. Evidence now calls the Defra document the PFAS Plan, not a “national PFAS strategy”. An orphaned bracket in the Kinfauns Castle post and the unexplained “[them]” in a quotation from Cllr Vincent on the timeline are fixed; that sentence now reads as Central Radio’s report of his words.
- The kidney cancer report on other pages. The no link post said “the Council” set the excess aside “chiefly because the cases did not fall away with distance”, and said without limit that the contamination “does not fall away with distance”; its title and two lines attributed the Health Cell’s statement to “the Council”, one quotation of it was inexact, and it said the report’s “no alignment” finding was wrong on the soil data. Start here, Health, Common criticisms and the timeline attributed the report to Lancashire County Council and gave the two excesses as statistically significant without saying against what. Three more posts did the same: the no concern post and the assessment questions post glossed “statistically significant” as more than chance would explain and gave only some of the report’s grounds, the assessment questions post paraphrased the report’s conclusion as “no link to the local environment”, and the statement omissions post said “no alignment” was the statement’s word only, although the report also uses it. The pages now name the multi-agency Health Cell convened by Lancashire County Council’s Director of Public Health, say the excesses are against England’s rates, give the report’s comparison with other small areas, and list its other grounds; the no link post confines the distance statement to WSP’s Phase 2 and 3 gardens within 1 km, says the report’s comparison of case locations with the soil cannot be checked because the locations are not published, and states only that the excess and WSP’s highest readings both lie south-east of the site. The three other posts now quote the report’s conclusion and grounds, and the omissions post says “no alignment” is in both documents. Web addresses are unchanged.
- How the 49 residents were selected. The FAQ, Common criticisms and Health said how participants in the blood testing were selected had not been published. Leigh Day’s press release of 24 September 2026 says they “were selected based on their proximity to the chemical factory, how long they had lived in the area, and whether they ate local produce”. The pages now quote it.
- Soil on roots in the produce samples. The Numbers said “the Occupation Road report records” that some produce samples may have contained soil adhered to roots, and cited only Wyre Council’s news item. The words are the Food Standards Agency’s, as recorded in WSP’s Occupation Road report (section 7.1.4), and the same sentence says PFOA in green and root vegetables was “elevated compared to expected background levels”. The page now quotes the whole sentence as the FSA’s and cites the report.
- Two lines in the HSE post. The HSE post had a heading, “AGC’s Switch from PFOA”, in our own voice over a section reporting AGC’s account, opened that section with an unsourced sentence on why PFOA was restricted, and said without a source that EEA-NH4 “is imported from Japan by AGC”. The heading now reads “AGC’s Account of the Change from PFOA”; the unsourced sentence is removed; the import is attributed to the Environment Agency’s April 2023 evaluation, which names AGC Chemicals Europe as the single UK supplier and says “It is imported into the UK from Japan”.
Updates
- Questions: six questions put to AGC in writing. On 14 October 2026 we put six questions to AGC Chemicals Europe in writing, first set out on 6 August 2026: on the October 2024 fire, whether AGC accepts that the elevated PFOA levels identified through the Environment Agency’s investigation are attributable to the company, remediation, support for local residents, and the decommissioning plan and budget. Four are new rows on the page; two fire questions AGC had declined were put again. All six are marked Awaiting response; for AGC, which has no statutory duty to reply, that status has no due date, and the page now says so. The permit-surrender row now asks only about the permit and the timetable, since the decommissioning plan has its own row.
- The timeline was cut back to what the sources support. Part One and other corporate-history entries came off in the review where no primary source was found (Zeneca, the NPL Estates agreement, Huntsman, the 1963 fire, the demolitions, the Enterprise Zone, “the last major variation to the permit”, and entries on 3M and DuPont’s internal knowledge, the January 2025 planning moratorium request, tree felling and a deleted post, among others). Where a source was then found, the entry is back in a narrower form attributed to it: the 1890 Burn Naze works and its acquisition (Wyre Archaeology Group, Visit Cleveleys), ICI’s formation, the 1940 to 1941 Ministry of Supply entry (three sources side by side), ICI’s 1952 start of PTFE production without APFO (AGC’s Regulation 61 submission), the 1964 Mond Division, the 1992 chlorine plant closure, NPL Estates’ 2003 acquisition and the 2009 chimney demolition. Entries added from sources: 1970 and 1980 to 1981 (Gaber et al. 2023; EPA memorandum), August 2001 (Frisbee et al.), 20 June 2013 (REACH Candidate List) and 27 January 2025 (Central Radio). “First national PFAS strategy” is now the PFAS Plan, published 3 February 2026.
- Dated statements. Information and Resources now says Wyre Council’s Hillhouse page (last updated 9 July 2026) and news page (newest item 7 October 2026) announced no further drop-in session as at 14 October 2026. Information and Resources also gives the one published tap-water figure (0.002 µg/l, lower-bound PFOA, 2023 to 2025, United Utilities data in WSP’s Sandringham report) in place of a statement that water “is tested and treated”.
- Open questions rows were reworded so they no longer assert unsourced facts: the egg PFAS source, consent 017290384, the “high risk” properties, the screening levels and the sampling spacing in the west-north-west.
- Health now carries OHID figures for the 65-and-over share of the local population (Cleveleys West 32.6%, Cleveleys East 32.7%, Thornton West 21.2%, Thornton East and Carleton West 30.4%, Wyre 28.0%, England 18.6%, mid-2022) in place of “older demographic profile”.
Site changes
- Timeline overview image removed. The overview image at the top of the timeline was drawn from entries since removed or corrected: the 1890 salt works as “the start of chemical industry on the site”, the works passing to ICI in 1926, ICI making PTFE with PFOA from the 1950s, “AGC stops using PFOA and switches to EEA-NH4” in 2012 in our own voice, the Environment Agency recommending Occupation Road be treated as contaminated land under Part 2A, the HSE consultation as on a “suspected carcinogen”, and the fire as “not made public until July 2026”. The page reads without it and the sentence describing it is removed.
13 October 2026
Corrections
- Jameson Road landfill, on the new council FAQ page. When the page was first published on 13 October, our response to the council’s statement that Jameson Road is “a separate issue” was “we have nothing to add”. That was wrong, and our own timeline already showed why: AGC’s PFOA-containing waste went to Jameson Road until 2014. The answer now sets out the published record, with sources. The error was ours.
Updates
- The council FAQ page was revised the same day. Several responses opened by agreeing that a council statement was accurate before giving what it left out. Where a statement is true but answers something nobody has claimed, the page now says that first. A section near the top sets out five patterns across the council’s answers. The drinking-water answer now explains what the Drinking Water Inspectorate’s tiers are and that EEA-NH4 is not among the 48 PFAS they cover. Sentences of our own that offered reassurance were removed.
New
- Wyre Council’s FAQ page, answer by answer. Wyre Council’s Hillhouse FAQ page has 34 questions; 13 on blood tests were added between May and September 2026. The new page goes through all of them in the council’s order, with an extract from each answer, where it matches the published record, and what the record adds. It was checked before publication by two independent reviews, one for facts and quotations and one reading as a hostile solicitor; their findings were applied. The FAQ and Start here now link to it.
12 October 2026
Corrections
- “Still rising when sampling stopped” and groundwater migration. Ten places across Evidence, Start here, The Numbers, Common criticisms, the timeline and one article said that contamination at the first published Phase 3 garden was “still rising when sampling stopped”, that “the true depth of contamination remains unknown”, or that the depth pattern was consistent with contaminated groundwater moving from the site. The reports do not say any of these. The readings at that garden’s deepest pit were 71.5, 68.1 and 119 µg/kg at increasing depth. What WSP’s Phase 3 report says is that “average PFOA concentrations appear to increase with depth across the dataset, with the biggest increase being seen between 0.4 and 0.6m depth” (section 4, Table 4-2). The pages now quote that sentence and state that no published report records sampling below 0.6 m. This was our inference presented as a finding.
- “1,000+ years” and “for centuries”. The timeline and Common criticisms gave PFOA’s persistence in the environment as “an estimated 1,000+ years” and “for centuries”. We found no primary source for either figure. Both are replaced by the US Environmental Protection Agency’s statement that “no biodegradation or abiotic degradation processes for PFOA are known” (EPA-842-R-24-002, September 2024, section 1.2).
- The 783 kg and the “uncontaminated” discharge point. The Numbers and Evidence placed the 2019 EEA-NH4 discharge of about 783 kg beside the permit’s “uncontaminated” classification, as if they were the same discharge point. They are not. The 783 kg is effluent discharged to the River Wyre through the main discharge point (W1 in Dalmijn et al., 2025). The classification “uncontaminated surface water and roof water” applies to a different point, W2, which discharges to Hillylaid Pool.
- AGC accounts article. The article said the directors “ranked” two risks above the third. The accounts give a numbered list and do not say it is in order of importance; the article now says “listed before it”. It also said “every company” must prepare a Strategic Report; companies entitled to the small companies exemption need not (Companies Act 2006, sections 414A and 414C).
- C8 Science Panel. Evidence listed “pre-eclampsia” among the six probable links and said they were “identified from 69,030-participant study”. The Panel’s stated conclusion (5 December 2011) names pregnancy-induced hypertension, and 69,030 is the number enrolled in the C8 Health Project, on whose data the studies drew, not the sample for any one finding. Corrected on Evidence, What is PFAS, the timeline, the FAQ and Common criticisms.
- IARC’s basis for classifying PFOA. The timeline said the Group 1 classification “is based on sufficient evidence of kidney cancer and testicular cancer in humans”. IARC’s basis, as the Evidence page already states, is sufficient evidence in experimental animals, strong mechanistic evidence in exposed humans, and limited evidence for cancer in humans.
- The 2006 permit entry on the timeline said the permit “contains no monitoring requirements for PFAS”. This was corrected on The Numbers on 27 September and missed on the timeline: the permit sets no emission limit for EEA-NH4, and as varied in July 2017 lists it for monitoring at one air emission point and at the River Wyre discharge, each with no limit set. Our earlier wording, “no PFAS emission limit”, was also too wide and is corrected on The Numbers, the timeline, the FAQ and Common criticisms: the permit sets a limit of 2 kg/hour for hexafluoropropylene at one air emission point.
- 145 tonnes on the Bentham article. The article gave “an estimated 145 tonnes of PFAS” with no attribution. The figure is for PFOA, it is an earlier estimate, and AGC’s submission of 20 December 2023 gives about 103 tonnes to air and water. The same article called EEA-NH4 “classified as a reproductive toxicant (category 2)”; it is a supplier self-classification recorded in the European Chemicals Agency’s database.
- The two kidney cancer areas. Seven pages described the second area in Lancashire County Council’s assessment as being “in north Blackpool” in our own words. Its nearest edge is about 1.7 km from the site (our measurement). The pages now identify both areas by the codes the report itself uses, E01025596 and E01012665. One article also called the second area a “comparator”, which the report does not.
- When PFOA use ended. About, Start here and What is PFAS stated as fact that PFOA use ended in 2012. That is AGC’s statement and is now attributed to AGC. A written answer from Defra and the Environment Agency of 17 April 2026 says a small amount of PFOA is still generated by the current process.
- What we asked our solicitors to request. The Phase 3 article said we asked for “the underlying data and the dispersion model”. The request of 27 May 2026 was for the dispersion model, the earlier draft of the report, the map of sampling locations and the correspondence between the Environment Agency and its consultant.
- Sources for two quotations. Common criticisms attributed “the aerial nature of PFOA deposition” and “an area of potential higher deposition” to pages of this site. Both are from WSP’s Phase 3 report (sections 4 and 1) and are now cited to it. On Evidence, 144 µg/kg is now labelled as the Phase 2 highest reading, with the 181 µg/kg highest reading across Phases 2 and 3 added.
- A sentence removed for want of a source. Common criticisms said property sellers “have disclosure obligations regarding known material issues”. We could not source that statement as written, and it had already been removed from the FAQ on 4 October. It is removed.
- Two documents wrongly called permit variations. The timeline had entries for a “permit variation” in September 2025 and another in December 2025, each said to introduce no PFAS monitoring. The two documents are Environment Agency compliance assessment reports, not variations of the permit. The September one is the report already described in the entry above it (BU5453IY/0572280, dated 24 September and issued 30 September 2025; we had given 24 September as the issue date here and on The Numbers), so that duplicate entry is removed. The December entry now describes the document as what it is: report BU5453IY/0589009, issued 17 December 2025, which records no breaches.
- Found by a second reader of this batch, and corrected before publication. The Phase 3 article said the reports “do not explain the choice of testing area against the measured results”; the Phase 3 report does give its reason, which the article now quotes. The Bentham article placed a PFOA reading “206 times the EU drinking water standard” at “the AGC Hillhouse discharge point”; the reading of 20,624 ng/L was at sampling points north of the plant, not at the main permitted outfall, as the Evidence page already says. It also described EEA-NH4 as produced at the site; the published study says it is imported. Start here said results are published in full for only one garden; the Phase 3 report appends the laboratory reports for all the gardens sampled. Two pages put a press figure in quotation marks (“approximately 800 kg/year”, “around 800 kg a year”) that the article cited does not use; its words are “almost 800 kg … annually”. The timeline and the March 2026 update still said AGC’s permit contains no PFAS monitoring conditions. The timeline and the kidney cancer science article dated all six C8 Science Panel findings to 2012; the first was published on 5 December 2011. The timeline also placed the Panel’s formation in 2009 to 2010; it was set up in 2005.
- Internal file names on the timeline. About 35 source lines on the timeline carried our own working file names and a “VERIFIED” marker. They are removed; the published sources named on those lines are unchanged. Two sentences describing an “[UNVERIFIED]” marker that no entry carries are also removed.
- The cookie banner said “No personal data is collected”. That was true of the analytics and not of the contact form, which sends us your message, your email address and your name if you give one. The banner now says so. About said the contact form is “at the bottom of any page”; it is on the contact page only.
- Tap water. The FAQ said “We hold no PFAS results for local tap water”. One figure had been published and we had not recorded it: the Sandringham Avenue Allotments report for the Environment Agency (WSP, June 2026, section 5.3.2.1) says its exposure estimate uses “drinking water data for the Thornton area, as provided by United Utilities (2023 – 2025 period), which reported a lower bound PFOA concentration of 0.002 μg/l”. The FAQ and the Common criticisms answer now give that figure. Both also say what it does not cover: it is a summary figure for PFOA, and no tap-water figure for EEA-NH4, the chemical used at the site since 2012, appears in that report, the three soil reports or the surface-water summary.
Updates
- The permit and EEA-NH4 at the river discharge. The Numbers now cites the permit table for its statement that no limit is set: the chemical is listed, as “SAA-1000”, at the River Wyre discharge with “No limit set” (variation V004, 19 July 2017, Table S3.3). The timeline’s permit entry now names both points where the permit lists it for monitoring.
- What happens to what you send us. The contact page now says what we receive when you use the form, that a third-party form service carries it to us by email, what we use it for, and how to ask us to delete it.
11 October 2026
Corrections
We reviewed conflicting dates, figures and attributions across the site. The entries below identify the corrections and the sources used. Some rely on secondary reporting or archived research notes; outstanding verification issues are listed separately. Where two pages were each right about a different thing, they now say which.
- The date of the Environment Agency’s conclusion on Sandringham Avenue Allotments, and the wording on a formal determination. Seven pages and the home page gave 12 August 2026. Wyre Council reported the conclusion in its news item of 3 July 2026 (“the Environment Agency has presented conclusions stating that Sandringham Avenue Allotments … meet the criteria to be determined as contaminated land under Part 2A”); its letter to residents of 12 August restated it for both sites. The pages now give 3 July and the letter as the restatement. Where we said we had not seen a formal determination, the pages now say what the sources say: Wyre Council’s updates of 5 March and 3 July 2026 and its letter of 12 August 2026 report the Agency’s conclusions and later legal steps, and do not record a formal determination of either site. One post called Occupation Road “determined” on 5 March 2026, and the Evidence and Numbers pages and one post called the Agency’s conclusion a “classification”; the council’s wording is that the Agency concluded it meets the statutory criteria. The home-page text and the unused announcement setting were corrected.
- The closure of the allotments. Several pages said Sandringham Avenue was “closed” on 5 March 2026. The council’s announcement that day said it “will also close on a precautionary basis”; on 3 July it said it “will be closed temporarily”. The pages now give the announcements. One post said the allotments in the 1km zone were closed after Phase 1 sampling; it now describes the 5 March announcement.
- The egg results. The timeline said Leigh Day arranged testing at four properties and that every property exceeded an “EFSA safe limit of 4.4 µg/kg”, the worst result being “10.5 times” that limit. The results are the egg samples in the Phase 3 programme (WSP report, March 2026, Table 4-6), circulated by Leigh Day on 17 February 2026: across 19 samples from four poultry keepers, the sum of the four PFAS ranged from 3.4 to 46 µg/kg wet weight. The 4.4 figure is EFSA’s tolerable weekly intake in nanograms per kilogram of body weight per week, not a concentration in food, so the “4.4 µg/kg” limit and the “10.5 times” are removed, and so is a sentence on the Evidence page that said concentrations “exceed” that intake. A figure of 83 µg/kg for one duck egg, from press coverage we do not hold, is removed. We added the European Union’s maximum level for the sum of these four PFAS in eggs, 1.7 µg/kg (Regulation (EU) 2023/915), for scale: the samples were approximately 2.0 to 27.1 times that level, which is a concentration comparison and not a finding of non-compliance with law in Great Britain. The timeline no longer suggests that PFOS in the eggs contradicts AGC’s statement that it has never used or manufactured PFOS; the report does not identify the source.
- The EEA-NH4 discharge figure on the timeline. It said about 800 kg a year, “essentially unchanged to the present day”, and gave 793 kg as Environment Agency data. The Agency’s April 2023 evaluation gives 0.783 tonnes a year for 2019, assumed representative of current operations; 793 is how ENDS reported it. The timeline now gives 783 kg and records what ENDS wrote. It also no longer says AGC’s emissions were reduced “to 0.009% of former levels”: AGC told ENDS the emission factors were “less than 0.009% and 0.001%”, with no stated denominator.
- PFOA in AGC’s mass balance. The Evidence and Numbers pages treated the 103-tonne, 115-tonne and 178-tonne figures as measures of one breakdown, and called the difference from 145 tonnes unexplained. The documents show more. AGC’s submission of 20 December 2023 covers production from the ICI period to 3 October 2023 and says it supersedes earlier figures; its 178 tonnes includes 63.3 tonnes supplied as product and 5.1 tonnes “captured and destroyed through incineration”, neither a release. The 145-tonne figure (75 tonnes to water, 70 to air) matches AGC’s earlier estimate in March 2023, so it is an earlier estimate. We cannot show from the documents we hold how the 115 tonnes reported by Leigh Day, citing the Guardian, was derived. The pages now say this. The 115 tonnes had been attributed to the Guardian article itself; the source we hold is Leigh Day’s article citing it.
- PFOA formed as a by-product. The Numbers page said whether this applies at Hillhouse “has not been addressed in publicly available documents”. AGC told ENDS that “a very limited amount of PFOA is inadvertently generated” in lubricant-grade manufacture, and Defra and the Environment Agency wrote on 17 April 2026 that “[a] small amount of PFOA is also generated through the current manufacturing process”. The page now says so, and says that neither statement establishes whether by-product formation occurred during 1950 to 2012.
- The Phase 3 report. The timeline gave 24 June 2026 as the date results were “published” (that is the date of our own analysis) and said the outcome of the Phase 3 factual report was not established; Wyre Council lists it as a PDF download. The Numbers page said one property was the only one with its Phase 3 data public. Both corrected. The Open questions page carried a question describing the Phase 3 report as published only through a flip-book service; that was wrong for Phase 3. The question is now the request actually sent on 9 October 2026 about the three reports that are published only through that service.
- The filing date of AGC’s 2024 accounts. One post gave 8 September 2025 in the text and 3 September 2025 in its sources line. It is 8 September.
- When Phase 1 soil sampling took place. One post said 2023. It was 9 September to 4 October 2024.
- The highest residential reading. The timeline called 119 µg/kg “the peak residential result”. 119 µg/kg is the highest at the property described there and among the poultry-keeper properties; the highest in the Phase 2 and 3 garden data is 181 µg/kg. Both are now stated.
- The “25 sites” post. Its headline and summary said the Environment Agency detected PFAS at 25 sites in 2022, that councils were not told until 2025, and that there was a gap of “about three years”. The Guardian of 14 February 2026 reports samples taken in January 2025; the Agency says it identified elevated PFAS in the area in 2022 through surveillance monitoring and that councils and other bodies were informed in 2025. The headline no longer says “Three Years”, each date is attributed to who gave it, and the post no longer asserts what councils or health bodies did or did not know. A second post that repeated “three-year disclosure delay” is corrected.
- The Regulation 61 notice and what the Agency knew. Posts described the notice differently and the timeline placed AGC’s historic data after the IARC classification. The third-party index of Environment Agency correspondence records the Agency saying on 21 December 2022 that it understood about 70 tonnes of PFOA had been emitted historically, and AGC saying in March 2023 that it had already supplied a summary of mass-balance data for 2003 to 2012. The notice was served on 3 October 2023, before IARC’s classification in November 2023, and AGC’s revised historic mass balance followed on 20 December 2023. The timeline now says the record places the Agency’s knowledge of historic emissions before the IARC classification, and treats the “IARC, then review” account as our notes of an ENDS interview, not as the interviewee’s words.
- Whether EEA-NH4 has been tested for cancer. The “What is PFAS” summary said it had not. The Environment Agency’s 2023 evaluation recorded that no carcinogenicity information was available in the EU registration dossier, and the Health and Safety Executive’s 2026 consultation proposes classifying it as a suspected carcinogen (Category 2, a “borderline case”) from rat studies of 52 or 104 weeks. The page, the Evidence page and the timeline now say this.
- The Health Cell’s kidney cancer findings. Several pages described one statistically significant area. The assessment reports two: 14 cases against about 6 south-east of the site, and 17 against about 9 in north Blackpool. The Health page also said no assessment of other cancers had been published. The report’s Stage 1 screening covered other cancers, including testicular, liver, uterine and pancreatic cancers, and “did not identify higher than expected rates for most cancers”. Kidney cancer was higher than expected in two areas and was examined further. The report does not publish figures for the other cancers. Three posts that explained a confidence interval as the range the true figure “most likely falls within” no longer do.
- The March 2026 drop-in sessions. The timeline listed the Food Standards Agency among those attending both sessions. On 12 March the Environment Agency, UKHSA, Wyre Council and Lancashire County Council were present and the Food Standards Agency was not; our attendance account covers 12 March only.
- The “seven high risk” properties. The Numbers page and a post said seven properties “have been designated” high risk and called it the council’s internal classification, and the post’s headline said “7 Designated High Risk”. The council’s letter of 12 August 2026 confirms that a small number of properties were placed in a higher risk category. The number seven comes from Leigh Day’s press release reporting what the council told the BBC; neither council document gives the number or the threshold. The pages now say that, and the headline says “Seven Reported as High Risk”.
- The March 2026 parliamentary question. The timeline still said it was the first time the contamination had been raised on the Parliamentary record, which we withdrew from the post on 25 September. It also called the MP’s referral to the Secretary of State the first escalation of its kind, which we cannot source. Both removed. The timeline’s separate entry for the MP’s attendance at a multi-agency meeting no longer gives a date, because the date we had recorded, a Friday 14 March, was a Saturday.
- Which body launched the investigation. Pages said different things because they were about different things. Wyre Council’s update of 7 January 2025 says it launched the investigation in July 2024 and that the Environment Agency is carrying it out, and the Council Leader described the group to the BBC on 21 February 2026 as led by the authority and carried out by the Agency. At the 12 March drop-in we received different verbal answers on leadership, which require clarification. The AGM post also tied the investigation to the identification of elevated PFOA in soil, which came after the launch; that is removed.
- The blood-level bands. We described the US National Academies’ guidance as “above 20 ng/ml”. Its interpretation guideline says an increased risk “above 20 ng/mL”; its recommendation on clinical follow-up applies at “20 nanograms per milliliter (ng/mL) or higher”. The pages now give each in its own place, and the middle band as 2 ng/ml or higher and below 20 ng/ml. Counts reported by the press (“69.4% above 20 ng/ml”) keep the wording reported.
- The March 2025 statement on food grown near the site. The timeline said Wyre Council advised residents within 1km not to eat home-grown vegetables until further sampling was complete (with a CHEM Trust source we do not hold), and other pages said the Council Leader “advised” or “upgraded” to “consider not eating”. We now hold the BBC report of 7 March 2025. It reports the Leader, Michael Vincent, telling a full council meeting that the authority would contact residents and allotment holders within 1km to urge caution; that “It’s probably best not to eat fruit and vegetables grown in the ground there”; that “I can’t advise people not to do it, but to consider whether it’s right to do it”; and that the authority would write again to urge residents “to consider not eating them until such time as more is known”. It also reports him as saying that samples of produce from allotments next to the site had eight times the safe level of a carcinogen. Every page now gives the speaker, the setting, the date and those words, and the CHEM Trust sentence is removed.
- The 12,100 ng/L figure. Pages called it a measurement in the River Wyre. The 2024 paper by Megson and colleagues reports PFOA of 838 to 12,100 ng/L in five surface water samples taken in May 2021 from lagoons and small streams affected by industrial discharge pipes from the plant, supplied by Watershed Investigations; it does not say any sample was from the River Wyre. The Numbers page and timeline now say that. The timeline also dated the paper to early 2024 (it is November 2024), called it the first study of the River Wyre, and said the team began sampling in 2022; those are corrected or removed. The Guardian’s figure of up to 12,000 ng/L in effluent samples from 2021 is a separate report.
- Smaller points. Headings that did not match their dates were corrected; three timeline sentences with no source were removed (the CHEM Trust sentence above, a list of possible sources of PFOS in eggs, and the claim of a first escalation); the Evidence page’s reference to a “placeholder” source for AGC’s PFOS statement now cites the BBC report.
Updates
- The Open questions page now lists the 9 October 2026 complaint and information request to Wyre Council about the three reports published only through an embedded Issuu viewer, with its two different response dates, in its table of open requests.
Not yet settled
- The 12,000 and 12,100 ng/L maxima. Neither the Guardian article nor the paper says whether the highest sample is the same one, so we keep them as two separate reports and do not describe them as one finding.
- The 115-tonne figure. We cannot show from the documents we hold how Leigh Day’s reported 115 tonnes was derived from AGC’s figures.
- When Wyre Council first posted the Phase 3 report, and the date Sandringham Avenue Allotments physically closed. Neither date is in the documents we hold.
- The date of the MP’s attendance at a multi-agency meeting. Our note of her email gives a date that cannot be right, and we do not hold the email.
4 October 2026
Corrections
We had the FAQ read as an opponent would read it: once for what it implies, once against each source, once for overstatement. These are the errors that review found.
- The closure answer said “the questions we are putting to” the Environment Agency and AGC. They have not been sent yet; the Open questions page shows both as “Preparing”. It now says “intend to put”. The error was published earlier the same day.
- The food answer said “PFAS detected in 287 of 291 soil samples”. The figure is for PFOA, as The Numbers and the rest of the FAQ say. Corrected.
- The FAQ said UKHSA “recommends against” individual blood testing. UKHSA’s words are that it “is not currently recommended for individuals through the NHS or private blood tests”. The FAQ now quotes the guidance and no longer says it “runs counter” to the US National Academies.
- The FAQ and Common criticisms said Wyre Council “said” blood testing would be “not appropriate”. The council’s FOI reply relayed advice from UKHSA and Lancashire County Council. Both pages now say so.
- EEA-NH4 in residents’ blood was listed under “What we know” in the answer about attributing contamination to a source. The figure (10 of 49) comes from press reports, not published data, and a blood result does not show where exposure came from. It is now under “Open questions” with that stated.
- The tap water answer gave “up to 20,624 ng/L” for “the discharge”. The paper gives one range, 891 to 20,624 ng/L, for three points together (a discharge beside a former ICI effluent lagoon, a land drain and a leaking pipe), sampled on one day, 12 February 2023, and attributes the PFOA to use at the plant between 1955 and 2012. The answer now gives the range, the date and the authors’ attribution, and no longer calls it “industrial discharge”.
- The FAQ said AGC “used PFOA until 2012” without the later official statement. A written answer from Defra and the Environment Agency on 17 April 2026 says a small amount of PFOA is still generated by the current process. Our 1 October update added that to other pages and missed the FAQ.
- The workers answer. It said we had found no blood testing “whether by ICI, AGC or a public body”; it now says we have found no published results, and that this describes what we searched. A sentence pointing to 1980s papers in the ToxicDocs archive has been removed: we had not read them, and our rule is that a claim we cannot source does not go on the page. The paragraph on other companies’ plants is now labelled as not describing Hillhouse. The figure of 756 UK workers is now cited to the IARC volume that gives it (Monograph 110, Table 2.1).
- The private soil testing answer attributed a depth finding to Phase 2 and to The Numbers. The statement is from the WSP Phase 3 report, which is now quoted.
- Three pages said 8,568 people “took part in 2025” in blood testing around 3M’s plant at Zwijndrecht (FAQ, The Numbers, one post). The Flemish health department says 8,568 gave a blood sample and that group results were published on 18 March 2025. All three now say that.
- About said the site “has no commercial or funding relationship with any law firm”. The person who runs it is a client of Leigh Day, which the same page states two sentences later. The sentence now says the site receives no funding from, and has no commercial arrangement with, any law firm, and points to the disclosure.
- The blood-testing answer commented on whether the Council Leader’s call for blood tests and the council’s FOI reply were “consistent”. That was our comment, not a fact. The answer now gives the two dated statements and no more.
- The cancer classification was stated without its limits. The FAQ now gives IARC’s basis for Group 1 (sufficient animal evidence, limited human evidence, strong mechanistic evidence) and IARC’s statement that the classification “does not indicate the level of cancer risk associated with exposure at different levels or in different scenarios”.
- The half-life sentence went further than its source. It said repeated exposure “can keep the amount in the body up or increase it”, from a study of 26 retired workers. It now says what the study shows, and that it does not show what is happening in residents.
- The 69.4% blood figure appeared in the FAQ without the caveats Start here carries. The FAQ now says the 20 ng/ml level is a prompt for screening and not a diagnosis, and that the US bands apply to a total of seven PFAS, so the figure may not be PFOA alone.
- The property answer made two statements with no source: that sellers “have disclosure obligations regarding known material issues”, and that “no official property blight designation has been made”. Both are removed (the first also from Common criticisms). The answer now states what is on the public record and refers readers to a conveyancing solicitor.
- The “Not currently in place” list named ambient air monitoring, a requirement to cease EEA-NH4 discharge and a residential remediation programme, without saying what we had searched. It now says what we have not found and where, and “requirement to cease EEA-NH4 discharge” is removed as our opinion, not a record.
- Contaminated land wording. One line said the Environment Agency concluded Occupation Road “meets the statutory criteria for formal classification as Contaminated Land”. The council’s wording is that it meets the criteria “to be determined” as contaminated land. The FAQ now uses that throughout.
- The food advice list called “wash and peel” new advice of 5 March 2026 and attributed hand-washing to the FSA. Wash and peel was continuing advice, raised beds was the addition, and the garden and hand-washing advice is UKHSA’s. Corrected, and UKHSA’s advice that gardens can be used as normal is now included.
- The tap water answer said mains water is “supplied and treated” by United Utilities and gave no source for “treated”. It now says who supplies it and that we hold no PFAS results for local tap water.
- Open questions: the fire question to AGC described the site as “major-hazard”. That was our wording as put to AGC. The page now says so, and that the site’s status under the major-hazard regulations is not confirmed.
New
- A new FAQ answer: Is it only the soil that is contaminated? It sets out, with the source for each, what has been reported in soil, home-grown produce and eggs, discharge water at the site, air samples at Hazelrigg and residents’ blood, and what is not known about what any level means for one person. The air figures come from the primary paper (Dalmijn et al., ES&T 2025: 21 samples, 11 June to 24 September 2021), which the timeline and criticisms pages had cited only in summary. Added because the question is asked often and the evidence was spread across several pages.
- A new FAQ answer: What happens when the factory closes? It sets out AGC’s closure statements and the Wyre Council Leader’s comment, what the Environmental Permitting (England and Wales) Regulations 2016 and GOV.UK guidance say about surrendering a permit and who decides, and where we searched for a published decommissioning or surrender plan and found none as of 4 October 2026. Two matching questions are listed as Preparing on Open questions.
Updates
- Who runs the site is now stated at the top of the FAQ, including that he is a Leigh Day client and could benefit financially if a claim succeeds. Leigh Day’s contact details now appear only on the Leigh Day page; the FAQ links there.
- AGC’s on-site investigation now has its source in the FAQ: AGC’s own Site Investigation page, quoted. The Environment Agency dispersion model is now described as the WSP report describes it, with a note that we have asked for it.
- The Wyre Council statement on the closure now has its source. The FAQ said the council had “stated that the announcement does not change the investigation” without a citation. The statement is the Council Leader’s response to AGC’s 13 July proposal, reported by the Blackpool Gazette on 16 July 2026: “The announcement does not affect the ongoing investigation, which is being progressed in accordance with the relevant regulatory processes.” The two closure sentences in the FAQ’s operator and current-actions answers now link to the new answer instead of repeating it.
1 October 2026
Corrections
-
The fire article said the reporting of the fire to regulators was unconfirmed. Our own Open questions page already showed that the Environment Agency’s record, disclosed on 2 September 2026, confirms it was notified on the evening of the fire. Our 30 September correction repeated the error. The article now says so, and only the HSE’s confirmation is outstanding.
-
The Numbers said the thermal oxidiser was “offline 43 days” and presented the permit-breach figures as “indicative”. The Environment Agency’s Compliance Assessment Report BU5453IY/0572280 records the oxidiser offline across four periods totalling about 56 days; the 43 days were invalid monitoring days, a separate breach. The table now gives each figure as the report records it, including that the particulate limit is a half-hour average and that the Agency scored each breach as category CCS3 (minor environmental impact), and cites the report.
-
The accounts article said “by 2022 the site was making a £10m operating profit” and invited readers to “decide why” AGC said one thing publicly and another in its filings. The £10m is a company-wide figure, and the closing sentence went further than the accounts do. Both now say only what the accounts record.
-
Two posts (HSE consultation, two permits) gave the EEA-NH4 discharge as “793 kg per year”. The Environment Agency’s report says about 783 kg, for 2019. Both now match the rest of the site.
-
Sources and evidence described the site in ways that were not quite true. It said all source documents are public (Leigh Day’s handout to participants is not), that the site uses no tracking cookies (Google Analytics sets them if you accept the cookie banner), and that unverifiable claims are “qualified or not included” (our rule is that they are not included). All three now say what the site actually does.
Updates
- Current PFOA generation. The Numbers and two earlier posts said we had no evidence of any recent PFOA release. A written answer from Defra and the Environment Agency, dated 17 April 2026, says a small amount is still generated by the current manufacturing process, with a release to air that AGC puts at a few tens of grams a year. Those pages now say so and link to the timeline.
30 September 2026
Corrections
-
The EEA-NH4 discharge figure was given as a current rate, “around 800 kg a year”, and credited to different sources on different pages. The primary source is the Environment Agency’s April 2023 risk evaluation, which used AGC’s own monitoring data: about 783 kg discharged to the River Wyre in 2019, which the Agency assumed was representative of current operations (p.68). We have not found a later published figure. The homepage, The Numbers, Start here, Sources and evidence, the FAQ, What is PFAS, Take action, the timeline and two earlier posts now give the 2019 figure and its source.
-
The accounts article said the directors’ risk list showed the closure was about “PFAS regulation and the cost of environmental compliance”, not losses. A list of principal risks is not a statement of reasons for closing a plant, and AGC has not said which risk decided it. The article now says only what the accounts record, with a dated note.
-
The fire article’s headline said “the community was never told what had burned”, and the article said “the regulators knew what had burned”. We can only say what the public record we have found shows, and the reporting to regulators and the absence of enforcement action are AGC’s account, not yet confirmed by the regulators. The headline and those passages now say so, with a dated note.
-
Common criticisms said the highest soil readings were to the south-east of the site. The Phase 3 report’s data shows the highest concentrations in two directions, south-east and west-north-west. Corrected in place with a dated note. (Superseded 22 October 2026: the “two directions” wording is itself corrected; see the model sweep entry.)
New
- A new answer on “Let sleeping dogs lie”: why not knowing does not reduce exposure or risk, with the measured egg and produce findings, PFOA’s half-life in the blood, the C8 Science Panel’s findings, the US National Academies’ testing recommendation, and how the contaminated-land law identifies who is responsible.
Updates
-
About now sets out how the site works: primary sources first, measured kept apart from estimated, no claim without a source, pages checked before publication, errors public, and what would change our view. It also links to published research by the person who runs the site.
-
We now say on the site who runs it, and that he is a client of Leigh Day in its investigation of a possible claim. He is named on About, which also says he could benefit financially if a claim succeeds. The homepage, the footer, Start here, the Leigh Day page, Sources and evidence, the FAQ and Take action now say the site is run by a Leigh Day client and link to About. Where those pages said the site was “not connected to” or “not affiliated with” Leigh Day or any legal firm, they now say it is not part of Leigh Day or any law firm and receives no funding from one. The site’s position has not changed: it is not part of Leigh Day, receives nothing from it and gives no legal advice.
-
The FAQ and Common criticisms now include more of the published science alongside official statements. Added: the US National Academies’ 2022 recommendation that doctors offer PFAS blood testing to people in contaminated areas, set beside UKHSA’s advice not to test; the C8 Science Panel’s six probable links; IARC’s Group 1 classification; a 3.8-year average half-life of PFOA in the blood, estimated in 26 retired production workers; EFSA’s intake limit in nanograms; the site permit’s lack of any PFAS limit on air emissions [corrected 18 October 2026: the July 2017 variation lists EEA-NH4 for monitoring at point A5 with no numerical limit, and sets a hexafluoropropylene limit at one air point; see 27 September]; and airborne PFOA found 20 km away. Removed: an unsourced line saying discharge water is diluted before abstraction; “no public health warning has been issued” as a statement about tap water; and closing instructions to follow official advice or check the council’s website.
-
Open questions now opens with a table of every formal request still open: who holds it, when it was filed, the body’s own reference, when a reply is due, and where it stands. Reference numbers added for the Environment Agency (EIR2026/46693), Wyre Council (FOI003977) and Lancashire County Council (FOI1643) requests, and the Information Commissioner’s Office case number for the complaint about HSE (IC-573871-P5Y8). A planned request to the Environment Agency on PFOA released since 2012 is listed as Preparing.
29 September 2026
Updates
- Wyre Council says it will not sample gardens on request. Its reply of 29 September 2026 says “the law we are working under does not allow us to choose sampling locations in response to individual requests”. New FAQ answer: Can I ask the council to test my garden soil?
- Two information requests sent, both public on WhatDoTheyKnow: to the Environment Agency for its air dispersion model (AQMAU-C2478-RP02), the sampling design and the sample locations, and to Wyre Council for the law it relies on and how properties were selected. Recorded on Open questions.
28 September 2026
Corrections
- The timeline said the site was designated upper-tier under COMAH in 2003. We could not find a source for that. HSE’s current establishment list shows AGC Hillhouse as lower-tier, as the fire investigation already stated. The sentence has been replaced with a dated note on the timeline.
- The timeline contradicted itself on when AGC stopped sending PFOA-containing waste to Jameson Road landfill. A heading said 2012, its own text said “until at least 2014”, and a separate 2014 entry cited “Wyre Council records” we cannot trace. An annotated index of Environment Agency documents released under EIR records that AGC’s filter cake, which contains low levels of PFOA, moved from Jameson Road to Whitemoss landfill in February 2014. Both entries corrected on the timeline, with dated notes.
- The Evidence page misattributed the Guardian’s 24 February 2023 article to the wrong authors. It was written by Rachel Salvidge and Leana Hosea. Corrected on Evidence.
- The Evidence page gave the 12,000 ng/L PFOA effluent reading without its sample year. The Guardian reports it was measured in 2021. Added on Evidence, with a dated note. The same entry, and the timeline, described the EU’s 100 ng/L drinking water value as a limit for total PFAS; it applies to the sum of 20 specified PFAS (the separate “PFAS Total” limit is 500 ng/L). Both corrected; The Numbers already had it right.
Updates
- The Health and Safety Executive has been reported to the Information Commissioner’s Office for not answering our request of 5 August about the October 2024 fire. HSE’s own deadline was 4 September; the request was 16 working days overdue when reported. Updated on Open questions, the timeline and the fire investigation.
- A Freedom of Information request has gone to Lancashire County Council for the figures behind its kidney cancer assessment, including the comparison populations used in its second stage. A reply is due by 26 October 2026. Recorded on Open questions.
- AGC’s current, unintended generation of PFOA is now on the timeline. Two entries: AGC’s statement to the ENDS Report in September 2025 that a “very limited amount” of PFOA is still “inadvertently generated” in lubricant-grade manufacturing, and a written answer from Defra and the Environment Agency in April 2026 that PFOA “is being released from historic and current activities”, with AGC reporting a release to air of “a few tens of grams per year”. The site previously described PFOA only as used until 2012.
- The printable leaflet now says PFOA has not entirely stopped. One sentence added to section 1: AGC’s statement that a “very limited amount” still forms unintentionally, and the Defra and Environment Agency answer that AGC’s own figures show a release to air of “a few tens of grams per year”. Nothing else in the leaflet changed.
- Status notes added to the four kidney cancer posts: the cluster, the assessment’s questions, “no concern” and the council statement. The assessment post also explains why the comparison populations matter: against a comparison rate about 19% above England’s, the headline result would no longer be statistically significant.
New
- A sharper answer to “Everyone has PFAS in their blood anyway”. It now makes two points: the amount is what matters, and here it is high; and the risk rises with the level however common it is, with the US guidance bands set out. It adds a comparison: smoking was no safer when most adults smoked, and high levels everywhere would be a reason for more concern, not less. The figures are unchanged.
27 September 2026
Two corrections found while researching how far the contamination reaches; a new post and six new answers on the responses to the blood results from UKHSA, Lancashire’s Director of Public Health and AGC Chemicals Europe; and a new FAQ answer about the people who worked at the plant.
Corrections
Found in an adversarial review of the Common Criticisms and FAQ pages, each checked against the source before it was changed.
-
We overstated what Wyre Council said about blood testing, on six pages. We wrote that the council said results “would be uninterpretable” and that testing “would cause additional distress”. Its 6 March 2026 response, relaying advice from UKHSA and Lancashire County Council, says biomonitoring was “not appropriate in the context of this investigation”, that “individual results are often uninterpretable”, and that uncertainty in interpreting them “can lead to additional distress for residents”. Corrected on the FAQ, Common criticisms, Health, the blood test results, biomonitoring and March investigation posts.
-
We said the site’s permit has no PFAS monitoring requirement on any air emission point. The July 2017 permit (EPR/BU5453IY, variation V004) lists EEA-NH4 for monitoring at one point, A5, with no limit set and a frequency “to be agreed with the Environment Agency”. It sets no PFAS emission limit. (12 October 2026: that sentence was too wide. The permit sets no limit for EEA-NH4, but it does set a limit of 2 kg/hour for hexafluoropropylene at one air emission point. See the 12 October entry.) Corrected on The Numbers, the Timeline and Common criticisms. The separate water discharge consents are unaffected.
-
A 700 m figure survived our 26 September correction. The “most gardens” answer on Common criticisms still put the highest Phase 3 reading at about 700 m. WSP’s distance plot puts it at about 630 m. Corrected, and the answer no longer calls the council’s summary a description of “shallow samples” only.
-
The FAQ said authorities in the Netherlands set up population biomonitoring, and that none of the programmes cited distress as a reason to withhold testing. We have verified programmes in Belgium and the USA only, and we cannot support the second claim. Replaced with the verified figures.
-
The FAQ listed drinking water PFAS testing as not in place. Wyre Council has said PFAS monitoring is carried out at the sources and treatment works supplying the area. Removed from the list.
-
Three unsourced statements were live, marked “[source to be confirmed]”. AGC’s position on PFOS, on the FAQ and The Numbers, is removed; both now say only that the source of PFOS found in eggs has not been identified. A “100-300 years” persistence figure for lead on What is PFAS is replaced: lead is an element and does not degrade. The Numbers also no longer dates the estate’s industrial use to “the 1950s”.
-
The FAQ overstated attribution. It said permit discharges “can be attributed” to fluoropolymer production and that source attribution “would require investigation that has not been conducted”. Reworded to what the evidence shows, noting AGC’s on-site investigation.
-
Smaller precision fixes: the US 20 ng/ml threshold is now described as applying to a combined total of seven PFAS; the egg advice now includes the advice on laying birds; the FAQ’s wash-and-peel, Phase 3 property and untested-foods wording now says only what the sources show; the Phase 3 report is no longer described as unpublished.
-
We withdrew the map comparing restriction zones at seven sites. It showed each country’s zone as circles at the same scale, but most of its figures could not be traced to a regulatory source, and its caption said those sources were still “to be compiled”. Checking them, the Netherlands advice line is 1 km, not 4 km then 10 km. The zones in Italy and at Parkersburg in the USA followed water supplies, not distances. The Belgian zones were simplified and have since changed. We found no source for the Swedish or Danish figures. The Italian panel was also centred near Padova, about 40 km from Trissino, where the plant stood. On The Numbers it is replaced by a table of what authorities did around five other sites, with a source for each row. The map of a 1 km buffer around the Hillhouse estate is unaffected.
-
We said Phase 2 soil testing covered only council-owned land, on the Take Action page. That describes Phase 1. We corrected the same error in the 1 km zone post on 26 September, but it had not been fixed here. Corrected on Take Action, with a dated note.
New
- “Blood tests cannot predict”: one position, three speakers. Sets side by side the similar statements on blood testing from UKHSA (published the day before the results), AGC Chemicals Europe and Lancashire’s Director of Public Health, with what they get right and what they leave out, including the limits UKHSA’s own rapid review records.
- A new answer to “It’s just ambulance-chasing lawyers after a quick buck”, setting out who found the contamination, who paid for the blood testing, and the stage any legal action has reached.
- Six new answers on Common criticisms: where the PFAS came from, unnecessary worry, the government review, lowering PFAS in the body, the site before AGC and no formal determination. The existing answer on blood tests and future health risk now links to the new post.
- What about the people who worked at the plant? Hillhouse workers are included in a published study of cancer deaths among workers at six tetrafluoroethylene and PTFE plants (Consonni and colleagues, 2013; IARC names Thornton-Cleveleys as one of the six). The answer gives that study’s findings and limits, what we have not found about Hillhouse workers and where we looked, and what is known from workers at other PFOA plants.
26 September 2026
An independent review found three places where our wording went further than the evidence. A review of every graphic on the site then found that a correction we logged on 25 September had not fully taken effect, and led to several more corrections checked against the WSP reports themselves. The kidney-cancer and soil map and the timeline graphic were redrawn, and this changelog was reorganised into a consistent layout.
Corrections
- We said AGC’s accounts “disprove” its “four years of losses”. The accounts show profits for the whole company in three of those four years. AGC says the losses were at the Hillhouse manufacturing unit alone and has not published that unit’s figures, so its claim about the plant is unverified rather than disproved. The article now says that, its headline reads “Its Accounts Show Profits in Three of Them”, and it carries a correction note.
- A headline said other contamination routes from the site were “never assessed”. The Phase 3 report mentions them once and never explains them; whether they have been assessed elsewhere is not known to us, as the article itself said. The headline now reads “Mentioned Once, Never Explained”, with a correction note.
- What is PFAS said no long-term cancer studies had been completed for EEA-NH4. The Health and Safety Executive’s 2026 consultation relied on rat studies of 52 and 104 weeks and proposed classifying EEA-NH4 as a suspected carcinogen. The page now says so, with a correction note.
- Our 25 September fix to the kidney-cancer and soil map did not fully take effect. We reported that the map’s legend no longer gave the withdrawn “Dutch screening value” of 3.8 µg/kg and that its cut-off key point was complete. That was true of the full-size image only. The site builds the smaller versions of an image from a second copy of the file, which we had not updated, so on the two posts that carry the map (A kidney-cancer cluster sits next to Hillhouse and the council’s “no link” statement) the smaller versions still showed the withdrawn figure, and a browser picks one of those depending on the screen. That map has now been replaced (see New below), the site now publishes each image from a single copy (see Site changes), and both posts carry a dated note.
- We put the highest soil reading at “700 metres” from the site. 700 m is the outer limit of the zone WSP sampled to the south-east, not the distance of the reading. WSP’s own plot of concentration against distance puts the 181 µg/kg reading at about 630 m from the facility. Corrected on Start here, Common criticisms, the leaflet, and four posts: Phase 3 soil results, A kidney-cancer cluster sits next to Hillhouse, the council’s “no link” statement and questions about the kidney cancer assessment. The old map also said the peak “rises from 500m to 700m”, and one caption said the readings “rise with distance”; WSP’s report finds no clear correlation between concentration and distance, and the same plot shows readings above 100 µg/kg within 100 m of the facility as well as further out. Two posts described the small area with the cancer excess as coinciding with the south-eastern soil peak (“over the soil peak” in one, “in the south-east peak” in the other); they now give what we measured from WSP’s own map, that about 90% of the area WSP treated as “potential higher deposition” lies inside it, and refer to it as the south-eastern of the two small areas with a significant excess.
- We said soil samples showed “elevated” or “raised” PFAS. The counts we quoted (187 of 199 samples in Phase 1, 287 of 291 in Phase 2) are the samples in which the laboratory detected PFOA above its limit of detection. That shows the chemical is present; it does not show it is above any safety or screening level, and WSP does not describe these counts as “elevated”. Corrected on the homepage, The Numbers, Evidence, Common criticisms, Start here and the leaflet. The Phase 3 post’s “204 of 208” and the other pages’ “287 of 291” are both WSP figures: the first counts garden samples only, the second includes public open space. Both are now labelled. (Egg results are still described as “elevated”, which is the council’s own word in its 12 August letter.)
- We said Phase 2 soil testing covered only council-owned land. That describes Phase 1. Phase 2 sampled the gardens of 46 homes within 500 m, as well as public open space. Corrected in the 1km zone post, with a note. Three other pages implied the same by treating later testing as the first in gardens: The Numbers called February 2026 the “first confirmed residential property soil data” (it is when residents began receiving their own results), Start here said garden testing “followed” Phase 2, and the Phase 3 post said Phase 3 “extended testing into residential gardens” (it expanded it). All three now say so.
- Our kidney-cancer and soil map put the second kidney-cancer area, in north Blackpool, “about 5 km” from the site. Measured on its official boundary, it is about 1.7 km from AGC’s permit boundary at its nearest edge and about 2.3 km centre to centre. The new map shows it in its true position. The timeline also described both areas as “beside the site”; it now says one is beside the site and one is in north Blackpool.
- Our timeline said AGC announced the closure on 13 July. AGC’s announcement that day was a proposal to end production, subject to consultation with staff; the decision was announced on 14 September. The timeline entry now says so, as our FAQ and About pages already did.
- The timeline’s overview graphic was out of date and wrong in places. It stopped in March 2026; it described Phase 2’s detection rate as samples “above PFOA limit”; it called the March 2026 allotment recommendation a “Part 2A designation”; it described the HSE consultation, which closed on 1 May, as current; and it placed the Environment Agency’s October 2023 notice to AGC after the November 2023 IARC classification. It has been redrawn (see New).
Updates
- Evidence page. Its note on the Environment Agency’s 2023 report now adds the same point: that HSE consulted on a suspected-carcinogen classification in 2026.
New
- A printable leaflet. A two-page A4 leaflet, on What To Do, replaces our withdrawn March 2026 handout. It condenses Start here, adds no new claims, dates anything that could change (“as at September 2026”), and links to Start here by QR code. It was re-issued the same day with two of the corrections above (the soil wording and the 630 m distance).
- A new kidney-cancer and soil map, on satellite imagery. It replaces a schematic that placed soil zones by compass direction only. It shows AGC’s permit boundary and WSP’s “area of potential higher deposition”, both digitised from WSP’s own georeferenced map in its Phase 3 report (approximate, about ±10 m), with the official ONS boundaries of the two small areas where the kidney cancer assessment found a significant excess. No individual soil sampling locations are shown, because most are private gardens. On A kidney-cancer cluster sits next to Hillhouse and the council’s “no link” statement.
- A redrawn timeline graphic, covering 1890 to September 2026, on the timeline. Every entry in it is sourced in the timeline below it.
- A new answer on Common criticisms: “It’s only the new houses built on the old ICI land.” It sets out where the soil testing was done, which covered a far wider area than the site, and WSP’s discussion of potential airborne deposition.
- Two new answers on the FAQ: why the blood testing was arranged through a law firm, and whether you can get your own garden soil tested.
- A new answer on Common criticisms: “The 49 were hand-picked, so the results mean nothing.” It sets out who arranged the testing, what the available documents do not explain about how participants were selected, and what that does and does not limit.
- A new FAQ answer: “I live more than 1 km away. Does this affect me?”
Site changes
- This changelog was reorganised into a consistent layout, corrections, updates, new content and site changes, with a summary table at the top. The original wording is kept in full at the changelog archive. No entries were removed.
- The site now has a proper “page not found” page (unknown addresses previously showed a normal page); the desktop menu fits on one row; the Evidence page’s four source cards sit in a two-by-two grid; and the cookie notice no longer covers the menu on phones.
- Post images, including the smaller versions and the full-size image, are now all built from one copy of each file, and social-media previews use that same copy where it exists. This removes the duplicate that caused the problem above. The retired schematic map and the old timeline graphic were removed.
25 September 2026
A second accuracy review found two more of our own errors and brought several pages up to date, including the confirmed closure and the first blood-test results.
Corrections
- We said we had written to the Health and Safety Executive. Our March investigation update said we had submitted a formal concern report to HSE and asked about its past involvement with the site. A search of our outbound correspondence found no record that either was sent. The sentence has been removed and the post carries a correction note. The same kind of error was corrected across the site on 11 September.
- A withdrawn benchmark was still on four pages. The 11 September entry said every instance of the “Dutch screening value of 3.8 µg/kg”, a figure we could not source, had been replaced. It had not: it remained in one FAQ answer, the 1km zone post, the questions tracker, and the timeline (which gave the highest garden reading as “31.3 times the Dutch threshold”). All four now use the screening values WSP applies in its own reports for the Environment Agency: 1.4 µg/kg for allotment soil, 7.6 µg/kg for gardens growing vegetables. The highest reading at the property whose full results are published, 119 µg/kg, is about 16 times the garden value and 85 times the allotment value; the readings themselves are unchanged. The figure also survived inside an image: the legend of the kidney-cancer and soil map, on two posts, still read “Dutch screening value 3.8”, which a text search cannot see. The image’s legend now gives WSP’s values. Its cut-off “Key point” text is also now complete.
- A supplier’s self-classification was presented as ECHA’s. The “What is PFAS” and “Evidence” pages said the European Chemicals Agency had classified EEA-NH4 as toxic to reproduction (Category 2); “The Numbers” attributed the same classification to “AGC’s own research”. The Category 2 entry is a self-classification by the chemical’s UK supplier, recorded in ECHA’s database; ECHA did not make it. The Environment Agency’s 2023 evaluation records that EEA-NH4 “does not have a harmonised classification under the EU CLP Regulation … nor a mandatory classification under UK CLP.” Another entry on our Evidence page already said this correctly, and the others now match it. The word “official” has been removed from the What is PFAS heading over this claim.
- The homepage and The Numbers mislabelled 178 tonnes of PFOA as “discharged”. That figure is the total in AGC’s own mass balance and includes 63.3 tonnes supplied to customers as product, which is not a release to the environment. Our Evidence page and Timeline already said so, but The Numbers labelled the same total “discharged”, and that has now been corrected there too. The comparable release figures are about 145 tonnes (an Environment Agency estimate, air and water) and about 103 tonnes (AGC’s own figures); the homepage now gives the Agency’s estimate and notes AGC’s. [Corrected 18 October 2026: the 145 tonnes is recorded as AGC’s own estimate, attributed to the Agency by Dalmijn et al.; see the entry of that date above.]
- The 1km zone was described as measured from the “estate boundary”. That wording appears in no official document; it was our paraphrase. The Numbers and the 1km zone post now use Wyre Council’s published wording, “within 1km of the Hillhouse site”, and list four written wordings rather than three. The post’s headline said “Three Definitions” while its body listed four, so the headline now reads “Four Wordings”; its web address is unchanged. The post no longer calls the four descriptions inconsistent, since two come from the same council article; the point that stands is that none of them defines a measurement point. Our own map remains labelled as our interpretation, and that label now also sits beside the international comparison map, whose caption had wrongly described every panel on it as drawn by the authorities.
- Occupation Road Allotments were said to have been “formally classified” or “designated” as contaminated land. What Wyre Council reported on 5 March 2026 is the Environment Agency’s conclusion that the site meets the Part 2A criteria; formal determination is the council’s own decision under the Act, and we have not confirmed from public records whether it has been made. The homepage, FAQ, What To Do, Evidence and Documents pages, and the residential-testing post, now say so, matching the fuller Evidence-page entry.
- The homepage’s soil figure and egg advice were out of date. The soil figure now carries the correct year and source, and the egg advice now uses the published wording.
- A post said Lorraine Beavers MP’s March question was her first intervention naming PFOA. The same post already recorded her naming PFOA in the House on 19 June 2025. It now gives both dates and makes no “first” claim, and carries a correction note.
- A post on the Environment Agency’s 25 sites carried leftover text from a quotation we had removed because it could not be sourced. The heading and sentence, left over from that earlier edit, have been replaced with a note explaining the removal.
- The 1km buffer map was mislabelled, and carried a marker it should not have had. The earlier version was titled as an “FSA/Wyre Council” map when it is our own interpretation, carried a location marker it should not have had, and gave an estimate of residents affected that we cannot source. It has been replaced with a map showing only the site outline and the buffer, labelled as our interpretation. No official map of the advisory zone has been published.
Updates
- The closure is confirmed. AGC confirmed the closure on 14 September 2026 and said production is “expected to cease by 31 December 2026”. The About page previously said only that AGC had announced the closure with no date made public, and one FAQ answer still described only the July announcement; both now say so. The homepage is brought up to date more broadly too: it now includes the blood results and both allotment conclusions, alongside the closure. The Numbers’ comparison table and status line now also note the confirmed closure, and the post on AGC’s accounts carries a dated update and a new row in its record of events.
- The first blood-test results are in. The post on blood testing in Bentham said no blood testing had been offered to residents here, and concluded that no evidence could yet show what testing here would find; both were true in March. The Health page, The Numbers, the FAQ and What To Do separately said no biomonitoring programme existed; that remains true of the NHS and the council. Leigh Day has since arranged testing, which was not provided by the NHS or the council, and results for 49 residents were given out on 23 September 2026.
- The HSE consultation on EEA-NH4 has closed. It closed on 1 May 2026; we have not yet recorded its outcome.
- Sandringham Avenue Allotments. The Evidence page said Sandringham Avenue Allotments had closed pending further results. Wyre Council’s letter of 12 August 2026 reported that the Environment Agency has concluded that this site, like Occupation Road, meets the criteria to be determined as contaminated land under Part 2A.
- A community meeting has been announced. What To Do said no community meetings had been announced; Leigh Day has said it will hold one in autumn 2026.
- The timeline has been extended. Its summary of events since March still said no closure date had been made public, and stopped at 4 September; it now includes the 14 September closure confirmation and the 23 September blood results, and its overview graphic is labelled as covering events to March 2026.
- Our one-page community handout is withdrawn while it is rewritten. Dated March 2026, it predated the blood results, the kidney-cancer assessment and the closure announcement.
- The open questions tracker is updated. It now gives the Health and Safety Executive’s delay as at 25 September 2026, checked against the request’s public page.
New
- Start here. A plain-English introduction for anyone who has just seen the news, linked from the menu and the homepage. It adds no new claims: each figure links to the page that sources it.
Site changes
- A new look when this site is shared. Links to the site now show a Hillhouse Watch card instead of the map: the mark is an eye whose pupil is the outline of the Hillhouse site, simplified. The site also has a browser-tab icon, and its description now reads: “An independent, sourced record of the Hillhouse industrial site, Thornton-Cleveleys, and PFAS (‘forever chemical’) contamination in the area.” The Facebook group’s cover uses the same design. Later the same day the mark was revised to read more clearly as an eye: a solid iris and a round pupil, with the site outline kept smaller inside it.
- Tables on phones. Tables on several pages were forced wider than a phone screen; they now fit and scroll sideways where needed, and long links in source lists wrap.
17 September 2026
Six corrections, most to the 3 September post on the toxic gas question asked for passing trains, and two to the March investigation update, prepared on 17 September and published on 25 September 2026, after a second reading of the two authorities’ covering letters. All are our errors of attribution, framing or reading, not new information, and none changes what the documents record about either authority’s conduct.
Corrections
- A log entry was attributed to the fire crews; it cannot be attributed to anyone. The entry at 18:04:43, reporting 200 cubic metres of process gas containing perfluoroisobutylene, reads “by phone from” a caller whose identity Lancashire Fire and Rescue Service withheld as personal data, an exemption covering its own employees and AGC’s staff alike. The post now says what the record says: the source is withheld.
- We gave the wrong number of appliances and the wrong end of attendance. We said six pumps attended; the Service’s report records ten pumping appliances (the Environment Agency’s “6 pump fire” reflects the six that had arrived by 18:07, the time its own record gives as notified). We also gave 09:50 the next morning as the end of attendance, which is when the last appliance arrived; the stop message was recorded at 11:11. The post now gives both figures and says what each measures.
- We described a toxic gas assessment as “requested and carried out”. The log shows a question asked by British Transport Police, an answer given on the basis of wind direction and smoke, and that answer relayed back, in five minutes and twenty-six seconds. The post and its headline now say that.
- We said we had asked British Transport Police which railway line was meant. We had not. That request is drafted and has not been filed; the post now says so. This is the same error as the one corrected across the site on 11 September, on a page that sweep did not reach.
- Two more claims that we had asked a question we had not. Our March investigation update was checked and cleared in the 11 September sweep, but that check only covered outbound correspondence from 1 June 2026, and the post is from March. Re-running it across the whole of 2026 finds no record that two requests, to the agencies asking which leads the investigation, and to the Environment Agency about how the two permits interact, were ever sent. Both now say we are preparing them. A third sentence on the same page, about a concern report to the Health and Safety Executive, was checked on 25 September and removed. The post’s closing summary no longer says requests were submitted.
- We gave the wrong notification time for the Environment Agency. We said it was notified “within about twenty minutes” of the release being reported. The Agency’s own record gives its time notified as 18:07, a minute after the Service’s log records the call to the Agency; at 18:16:58 the log records the Agency’s incident number and that the information was being passed to an environment officer.
11 September 2026
A full accuracy sweep of every page found three of our own errors, corrected first, and brought the rest of the site up to date with evidence we already held.
Corrections
- We said we had put questions to bodies we had not yet contacted. Sixteen posts carried wording such as “we are asking this openly, and putting it directly to WSP and the Environment Agency”, or to Lancashire County Council and the Health Cell. Our internal tracker and outbound correspondence confirmed the requests had not been sent. The wording now says we are preparing to put these questions formally to the bodies named. Nothing we published about any organisation’s conduct depended on this, and no such claim has changed. But it mattered: a body that has never been approached can rightly say so. We had written the rule for ourselves before we broke it: this site should not imply an organisation is ducking a question we have not actually asked.
- A soil benchmark we quoted does not exist. Several pages compared PFOA soil readings against “the Dutch screening value of 3.8 µg/kg”, a figure that appears in no RIVM publication; it appears to have been introduced in error rather than mis-transcribed from a real document. We caught this on 2 August and removed it from The Numbers, but we did not check the rest of the site, and it remained on five other pages, including in one post’s list of sources, where a figure that does not exist was presented as a citation. Every instance is now replaced with the screening values WSP applies in its own Phase 2 report for the Environment Agency: 1.4 µg/kg for allotment soil, 7.6 µg/kg for residential gardens growing vegetables. Where we previously said all 25 samples at one property exceeded the benchmark, we now state the position against both real values, and note that the lowest of the 25 sits just below the residential figure.
- Our timeline described itself inaccurately. It stated that three items previously listed as forthcoming (the Phase 3 reports, the HSE consultation outcome, and the Leigh Day town hall) “have now passed and are recorded above where they occurred”. They were not recorded; the page still described all three in the future tense. It now says plainly that its dated entries run to March 2026, that those three items passed their dates without our establishing what happened, and adds a short summary of developments since March.
- A correction from 3 August was never recorded here. In early August we corrected a false claim that the Lancashire County Council Health Cell kidney-cancer report was unpublished and reached only through legal correspondence; it is published in full by Wyre Council. We changed three posts at the time but did not record it on this page, which our own standards require. We are recording it now rather than back-dating it.
- The Numbers wrongly spliced two studies’ figures for PFOA in surface water. It gave a range of “12,100 to 20,624 ng/L”, combining the single value from one study with the maximum from another; that range appears in neither. It now reads “up to 20,624 ng/L”, with the two studies given separately.
- One post misdated the Health Cell report. It gave 16 June 2026, which is when the report was forwarded to Leigh Day, rather than 12 May 2026, its own review date. Every other post had this right.
- Our timeline wrongly said the October 2024 fire “had not been reported at the time”. This error was introduced earlier the same day, in the timeline correction above. The regulators were told: the Environment Agency was notified that evening, and AGC filed its statutory notification the following day. What had not happened was any public report; the page now says so and gives the notification dates.
- Our Open Questions page said, of AGC’s statement that no enforcement action followed, “We have no reason to doubt it”. That was written before the Environment Agency’s record was disclosed. The record shows a breach of a permit condition, categorised C3, with a warning issued and a required action due 25 March 2025. Whether a warning amounts to “enforcement action” depends on what the term covers: the Agency’s own form describes enforcement action as something that can include a formal caution, prosecution, the service of a notice, or suspension or revocation of a permit. We now set out the record and both readings rather than offering a view.
- One post carried two notes-to-self that should never have been published, asking for a source for the 71-properties figure and for the planning-moratorium correspondence. Both are now sourced; on the second, we had the document all along, in our own archive and on our own timeline. We also corrected how we described the moratorium: saying the government “refused” the request overstated it, since the reply pointed the council to planning powers it already holds rather than blocking it from acting.
- Two previously unverified quotations were confirmed. We had flagged them internally because we held only the documents attached to a disclosure, not the covering letter carrying the authority’s actual answer, including, in one case, the answer to the question the whole request was built around. For six weeks our own records suggested we could not support two things we had published, and the proof was sitting on a public page we had linked to all along. Both letters have since been located and are now archived.
Updates
- Events pages were out of date. The homepage and What To Do were still advertising a 21 May information event and March drop-in sessions as upcoming; both now say plainly that no further sessions have been announced.
- The closure announcement is now noted. Several pages described AGC as the current operator with no mention of the closure of production announced on 13 July 2026; they now note the announcement, that no closure date had (at the time) been made public, and Wyre Council’s statement that the investigation is unaffected.
- Sandringham Avenue Allotments. Wyre Council’s letter of 12 August 2026 states that the Environment Agency has concluded that this site, like Occupation Road, meets the criteria to be determined as contaminated land under Part 2A; the guidance-change table gained a row for the letter, which also records elevated PFAS in every egg sample taken from the four poultry keepers tested.
- Kidney cancer figures are published. The Health page said in four places that no study had examined local cancer rates in relation to the site, and that age-adjusted small-area data had not been published. That is no longer true for kidney cancer: the Health Cell assessment published figures for the neighbourhood immediately south-east of the site, 14 cases against 6 expected, a standardised incidence ratio of 218. We have narrowed those statements rather than deleted them; they still hold for every other cancer and for the non-cancer conditions associated with PFAS.
3 September 2026
The Numbers’ groundwater section has been expanded: sampling is happening, but the results are not published.
Corrections
- Our own internal research notes wrongly said groundwater had never been assessed. They went further than the site itself, saying groundwater “has never been assessed”; that was wrong, and we have said so in our corrections log.
Updates
- Groundwater sampling is under way. The Numbers said there was no published data on PFAS in groundwater beneath or adjacent to the estate; that remains accurate, but it was incomplete, since a reader could take it to mean nobody is testing at all. AGC Chemicals Europe states on its own website that it has commissioned a third party to carry out a voluntary, intrusive investigation within the boundaries of land it owns, to sample and test soil, groundwater and surface water; Stage 1 is complete, Stage 2 began in June 2026, and both stages are agreed with Wyre Council and the Environment Agency. What is missing is not the testing, but the results, which are not published, and the identity of the third party, which is not named. Source: AGC Chemicals Europe, Site Investigation page, accessed 3 September 2026.
14 August 2026
A link check found three dead citations, all now fixed, and the contact form has been rebuilt.
Corrections
- A citation pointed to a Guardian page that never existed. The Sources and Evidence page cited a Guardian article at
/environment/2026/feb/03/pfas-action-plan; that page does not exist and, as far as we can establish, never did. We do not know how a citation to a non-existent page came to be on the site, and we are not going to guess; it should not have been there. The link and its heading have been removed; no claim on the site rested on it, and the UK PFAS plan it referred to is still cited from its GOV.UK source. - A citation was wrongly dated and linked. The Numbers had attributed a pre-publication figure of over 400,000 ng/L to a Guardian article dated 17 February 2023; the quote and the reporting are real, but the date and the address were both wrong. It is the article of 24 February 2023, now linked directly. The figure itself was already marked on the page as pre-peer-review, and the published figure of about 40,000 ng/L is still the one cited. Both this and the previous item were corrected on 7 August 2026, and are published here today.
Site changes
- A retired government link was repointed. The Food Standards Agency citation pointed to
cot.food.gov.uk, now retired; it now goes to the preserved copy in the UK Government Web Archive, alongside the Committee on Toxicity’s current GOV.UK page, with a note that the source is an archived one. This was also corrected on 7 August 2026. - The contact form has been rebuilt. It now shows a live character count, saves a draft in your own browser, reports any failure on the page, and records message length so we can tell if anything arrives short; there is no length limit. If you sent a long message before 12 August 2026 and had no reply, please send it again: at least one detailed account reached us cut off part way through a sentence, and we could not recover the rest of it. We are sorry; the form should not have been capable of that.
2 August 2026
A full verification sweep against primary sources found errors we should have caught before publishing, the most significant being the location of the site’s peak PFOA reading.
Corrections
- The peak PFOA reading was wrongly placed at discharge point W1, the main permitted outfall. Dalmijn et al. (2025) record W1 as the lowest of every point sampled, at 30 and 33 ng/L total PFAS. The high readings, from 891 to 20,624 ng/L, were at three points north of the plant: a discharge beside a lagoon, a land drain, and a leaking section of discharge pipe. The paper identifies the lagoon as an effluent pit used by ICI, which operated the site until 1999, and notes it could not be accessed during sampling. The error appeared in five places across three pages and is corrected in all of them. We had also wrongly attributed the 1,744 ng/L EEA-NH4 figure to discharge point W2; the paper reports it for Hillylaid Pool water and gives no separate figure for the discharge point.
- We had not reported what the paper says about cause. It attributes the high PFOA to use at the plant between 1955 and 2012 and to a reservoir remaining within the site, with re-emission as the mechanism, rather than to current discharge. That is now stated wherever the figures appear. [Corrected 18 October 2026: the paper offers re-emission from on-site reservoirs as a possibility and says current use or formation must be ruled out; it does not attribute the readings to either. See the entry of that date.] AGC’s own reporting to the US EPA shows it was emitting PFOA as operator until 2012; the published record does not split the total between the two operators.
- Six PubMed citations pointed to the wrong paper. Every one of the six links on the “What is PFAS” page supporting the C8 Science Panel’s findings pointed to an unrelated paper; all six have been replaced. Kidney cancer was also credited to the wrong study, and “pre-eclampsia” corrected to “pregnancy-induced hypertension”, the Panel’s own term.
- Several figures were wrong. Total organofluorine “around 400,000 ng/L” is corrected to total PFAS of about 40,000 ng/L (the cited paper did not measure organofluorine; the higher figure came from a pre-publication quote). The EFSA limit was given as 4.4 µg/kg; it is 4.4 ng per kg of bodyweight per week. A dioxins figure was given in micrograms where the source states nanograms. A thermal oxidiser “offline 43 days” conflated 56 days of outages with 43 invalid monitoring days. Several dates were wrong, including the publication date of the Dalmijn paper, a company name change, the date of Phase 2 soil fieldwork, and the date of a chemical spill.
- Several attributions were wrong. Professor Crispin Halsall of Lancaster University, an independent academic with no connection to the company, had been described as an “AGC spokesperson”. A company statement to journalists had been presented as data submitted to a regulator. Classifications attributed to ECHA were the Environment Agency’s assessment and a supplier’s self-classification. Two clauses of a Guardian article had been stitched into a single quotation. All corrected.
- Three claims have been withdrawn. That a soil report’s PDF carried the same name in two independent metadata fields; it appears in one field, echoed by the software into a second (the rest of that post stands). That March 2026 was the first time the contamination reached the Parliamentary record; it was raised in June 2025. Language in our coverage of a 2000 industry meeting asserting the company “chose” to continue, and an anonymous nickname aimed at an individual; we report what the minutes record and what happened afterwards, and do not assert intent.
A full internal record of every change, with the verbatim source text relied on, is kept alongside the site.
23 July 2026
A precision correction to loose shorthand about the fire’s duration, with no change to any factual claim.
Corrections
- “A three-month fire” was imprecise. The fire article (
agc-fire-three-month-shutdown.md) used this shorthand in two places, in its body and in its closing questions list, and the same correction has been applied to the Questions tracker page; the fire itself was short-lived, and what lasted three months was the shutdown of production it caused. The wording is corrected to “a fire that shut the plant for three months” throughout. The article’s title, summary and every other reference already stated this correctly.
9 March 2026
A new post on BBC coverage and the planned Leigh Day town hall.
New
- New post: “BBC News Lancashire Covering Hillhouse Story, and a Leigh Day Public Meeting Planned for May” (
bbc-coverage-leigh-day-town-hall.md). BBC News Lancashire confirmed filming in Thornton-Cleveleys on 10 March 2026 (journalist Yunus Mulla); a Leigh Day public town hall was announced for late May 2026 at Thornton-Cleveleys FC, with contact details for Leigh Day. Specific dates were to be updated when confirmed.
8 March 2026
Three new posts, on the 1km zone, residential testing and the UK’s PFAS plan, and the biomonitoring post updated with confirmed sources.
New
- New post: “The 1km Zone: Three Definitions, No Map, No Measurement Point”. Documented three formulations of the advisory zone across official council documents (later found to be four; see 25 September), with no published map and no measurement methodology; FOI question 5 was redirected to the Environment Agency. Included a “What We Are Not Claiming” section. All three formulation citations were marked at the time as pending document-level confirmation.
- New post: “Residential Soil Testing: 71 Properties, 7 Designated High Risk”. Documented the residential testing programme: 71 properties tested, PFOA found in the majority, 7 designated high risk, no residential Part 2A determination at the time. Also covered the planning moratorium: the government declined Wyre’s request, and the council already holds planning powers under the Town and Country Planning Act 1990. An inference about a named official’s knowledge was removed from the post.
- New post: “The UK’s First PFAS Plan: Published, Challenged, and Being Watched”. Covered the Defra PFAS Plan (3 February 2026) and Emma Hardy MP’s parliamentary challenge on the Environment Act 2021’s “polluter pays” compliance, marked unverified at the time pending a Hansard reference; also noted Leigh Day was tracking statutory compliance.
Updates
- The biomonitoring post was updated with confirmed sources. (
biomonitoring-refused-three-day-gap.md) Previously marked unverified, it now cites the Council Leader’s public call for blood tests (ENDS Report, 3 March 2026) and Wyre Council’s formal refusal (FOI response, 6 March 2026, on WhatDoTheyKnow.com): “not appropriate”, results “uninterpretable”, would cause “additional distress”. The analysis was reframed to remove editorial language while preserving the documented three-day sequence, and the unverified tag was kept only for items still unconfirmed at the time (the UKHSA guidance consultation, and coordination between the Leader and the FOI response). - Existing pages updated to match. The Health page (FOI refusal, WhatDoTheyKnow link), FAQ (blood-testing Q&A, an added international comparator note, the 71/7 stat, a planning-moratorium note, disclaimer date), Take Action (1km zone box, the Defra Plan and Emma Hardy item) and The Numbers (a new Phase 3 section: 71 properties, PFOA in the majority, 7 high-risk, no residential Part 2A).
Site changes
- The About page’s “last updated” date changed from February to March 2026.
6 March 2026
Two changes published the same day: a navigation and theme overhaul, and the Environment Agency’s first Part 2A conclusion, for Occupation Road Allotments. Sandringham Avenue was announced to close the same day, “on a precautionary basis” in the council’s words [wording corrected 18 October 2026]; its own Part 2A conclusion followed later, in the 12 August letter (see 11 September).
Updates
- Occupation Road Allotments met the Part 2A criteria. The Environment Agency concluded the site meets the statutory criteria for Contaminated Land under Part 2A, based on PFOA found in both soil and produce; if formal determination is made, Wyre Council will “identify those responsible and secure remediation”. Added to Take Action, FAQ, Evidence, Untold Story and the homepage. Source: Wyre Council, 5 March 2026; all previous placeholder “verify” tags on allotment closures were replaced with this source.
- Wyre Council announced that Sandringham Avenue Allotments would close “on a precautionary basis” (its words), pending scientific interpretation of soil results. [Wording corrected 18 October 2026: this entry said “closed as a precaution” in our own voice.]
- Root uptake added to the produce advice. The Part 2A classification also rested on PFOA found within vegetables, not only surface soil; PFAS is absorbed as plants grow, so washing and peeling removes surface soil but cannot remove PFAS already taken up. The FSA’s continued “wash and peel” advice, given this finding, has not been publicly explained. Added to Take Action and FAQ.
- The FSA updated its advice (5 March 2026): residents within 1km should consider raised beds with fresh soil when growing produce.
- Permit compliance failures added (The Numbers, Untold Story): September 2025 data recorded dioxins at 3.7 times the permit limit, particulates at 47 times the limit, and the thermal oxidiser reported offline for 43 days (a figure later corrected on 2 August, which had conflated 56 days of outages with 43 invalid monitoring days). The permit has no PFAS monitoring requirement on any of its 15+ air emission points. [Corrected 18 October 2026: wrong as written; the July 2017 variation lists EEA-NH4 (as “SAA-1000”) for monitoring at point A5 with no limit set, as corrected on The Numbers on 27 September 2026.]
- A shared discharge point was added (Evidence, The Numbers): the 20,624 ng/L PFOA reading was described as a combined AGC/Victrex PLC discharge point, with the figure reflecting combined output from both operations and said to be unable to be attributed to a single operator without further investigation. This premise was wrong, and was corrected on 2 August; the reading was not at that point.
- A historical discharge discrepancy was noted: two figures for total PFOA discharge appear in the public record, 178,000 kg (Guardian/Watershed FOI, September 2024) and about 145,000 kg (an Environment Agency estimate in Dalmijn et al., 2025). The discrepancy has not been explained. [Corrected 18 October 2026: the 145 tonnes is recorded as AGC’s own estimate, attributed to the Agency by Dalmijn et al.; see the entry of that date above.]
- Egg testing results added: Wyre Council-commissioned testing found 83 µg/kg in one duck egg (from ENDS Report and BBC, not independently verified at the time); Leigh Day-commissioned testing at four properties within 1km found all four exceeded the EFSA safe limit of 4.4 µg/kg (17 February 2026). [Corrected 18 October 2026: this wording was wrong twice. EFSA’s figure is a tolerable weekly intake, 4.4 ng per kg of body weight per week, a regulatory value, not a “safe limit” and not a food concentration; the egg results were a sum of four PFAS of 3.4 to 46 µg/kg wet weight (see 2 September and 11 October).]
- Wyre Council’s leader publicly called for PFAS blood testing and a “proper inquiry” into local health (ENDS Report, 3 March 2026).
- Drop-in sessions added: 12 and 17 March 2026, Thornton-Cleveleys FC, Gamble Road, 4 to 7pm.
- Allotment closures reported (5 March 2026): at least two Thornton allotments were reported closed following soil results (Blackpool Gazette, 5 March 2026, pending Wyre Council confirmation at the time).
- A “how the guidance has changed” table was added, tracing official advice from “wash and peel” (July 2024) to allotment closures (March 2026), with sources.
- A 1km boundary caveat was added: no publicly available scientific justification for the 1km radius had been identified; airborne contamination had been detected at 20km; residents beyond 1km should not assume they are unaffected.
- Phase 3 residential soil data (February 2026) added to The Numbers (WSP code SP510): the first confirmed residential results; all 25 samples exceeded the “Dutch benchmark” then in use (withdrawn on 11 September; see that entry); the peak reading of 119 µg/kg at 0.6m depth was still rising when sampling stopped, a pattern consistent with groundwater migration. [Corrected 18 October 2026: 119 µg/kg was the result at the deepest sampled interval; the results do not establish a continuing increase below that depth or a groundwater pathway. The inference was withdrawn on 26 September 2026.]
- The homepage gained a new stat for the Part 2A classification, and its context box was updated.
Site changes
- Navigation reduced from 13 top-level items to 6: Home, The Facts (dropdown: What is PFAS, The Numbers, Regulatory Context, Evidence, Sources), Health, Take Action (dropdown: Information & Resources, Resources, FAQ), About, Contact. The changelog moved to the footer only. Dropdowns work on desktop by hover and on mobile by tap, and the active state propagates to a dropdown’s parent button when one of its child pages is active.
- Duplicate title headings removed. The template already outputs a styled heading from the page title; a redundant repeat was removed from Evidence, FAQ, Health, Resources, Sources, Information & Resources, The Numbers, Regulatory Context and What is PFAS.
- Light theme became the default, with dark theme still available by a toggle and the preference saved in-browser. All colours were checked against the WCAG AA standard (4.5:1 minimum contrast); dark theme was preserved as CSS overrides only, with no content change.
25 February 2026
Accessibility fixes for the dark theme, a tone rework of the cancer statistics, and more external sources added.
Corrections
-
The Health page’s cancer figure was given a qualification it lacked. It now states that age or other factors cannot be assessed without the standardised incidence rates. [Corrected 18 October 2026: the BBC’s figures are prevalence, so the page now says “age-standardised figures”.]
-
A headline cancer-statistics finding was reframed as a reported claim. The Evidence page’s BBC cancer-statistics entry had presented “above national average” as a headline finding; it is corrected to “reported as being above the national average”, with an expanded caveat noting Thornton-Cleveleys’ older-than-average demographic (unadjusted rates in such areas naturally run higher) and that the underlying standardised rates were not published in the BBC article.
Site changes
- Dark-theme contrast fixed. Eight inline-styled boxes on Evidence, Health and The Numbers used light backgrounds that produced white text on pale backgrounds, unreadable on the dark theme; all converted to dark-theme-compatible equivalents (grey, amber and blue note boxes). The map caption colour on The Numbers was also changed, from
#666to#8b9499, for contrast. - Cancer statistics presentation reworked for tone on the Health page. The 35-43% figure moved from an alarming red-bordered box to a plain paragraph.
- More external sources added to Resources: three CHEM Trust articles specific to Hillhouse (5 February 2026; a 2025 vegetables warning; a 2025 PFAS hotspots feature); a Guardian article and the UK Government’s PFAS Action Plan, both February 2026; the UK Environmental Audit Committee’s PFAS inquiry (2025), including Dr Megson’s written evidence (PFAS0073); the Italian Miteni criminal case (2025), the first successful criminal prosecution for PFAS pollution in Europe, 11 executives sentenced, 350,000 people affected; and France’s ban on PFAS in clothing and cosmetics (February 2026), the first such national ban. The existing CHEM Trust organisations entry was also updated to reference this Hillhouse-specific coverage and the EAC inquiry submission.
18 February 2026
The site’s foundational rewrite: a factual, sourced, estate-centric tone, with a first pass of corrections and the first readability and tone changes.
Corrections
- Several unsupported claims were removed: that the hazard was “known 1960s (internal company research)”, which implied corporate knowledge without a citation (What is PFAS); a 68,900,000 ng/L 3M Zwijndrecht figure from the comparison table, an extraordinary claim without a verifiable source (The Numbers); an inflammatory quote, “giant chunk of toxic material”, attributed to Megson (Untold Story); and European site financial-impact figures (€571M, €70M+) that lacked verifiable sources.
- A Guardian article date was corrected, from 28 to 24 February 2023 (Resources), to match the actual URL.
- The cancer-prevalence statistics (35-43% above average) were given an explicit caveat: the data is third-hand (NHS to Ribble Rivers Trust to BBC), age standardisation is unknown, no causal link is established, and ward-level data is an information gap.
- A separate cancer-statistics claim was flagged as unsupported. The Health page’s 4.42-4.58% figures were given an explicit caveat that they “do not appear in the BBC article and the original dataset has not been independently verified”; the caveat was also moved to appear before the figures.
- “Has not been publicly explained” was reworded to “has not been determined”, removing any implication of concealment.
- The EU drinking-water comparison was corrected. Figures compared to the EU standard are discharge-water measurements, not drinking water at the tap; the comparison is used because it is the most widely understood benchmark, and discharge enters watercourses where it is diluted before any abstraction for drinking water. A footnote was added to the comparison table giving the figure as discharge water, around 206 times the EU drinking water standard, and notes were added to The Numbers, Evidence and FAQ making the discharge/drinking-water distinction explicit throughout, since the comparison could otherwise mislead.
- Lead was said to have been phased out in 1999; it was phased out in 2000. The date is corrected on What is PFAS, with specific legislation links added.
- EEA-NH4 testing was described as involving “soils”; the source reports water samples. The Megson 2024 paper is about water samples, not soil; the Untold Story page is corrected, with source attribution notes added.
- “Thousands of chemicals” was replaced with a cited figure. What is PFAS now cites the OECD’s count of over 4,700, with a link, and notes that estimates vary.
- A note on the regulatory-timeline comparison table. The table on What is PFAS, distinct from the contamination-pathway table elsewhere on the site, was qualified: it shows a regulatory timeline and is not intended to imply toxicological equivalence between the substances compared.
- The 178-tonne breakdown sub-figures (49,100 / 54,300 / 6,200 / 5,100 / 63,300 kg) were qualified as coming from EA permit documentation, with the specific permit version or FOI document still to be confirmed.
- A DuPont Parkersburg figure of about 13,000 ng/L was flagged with its source still to be confirmed, and a Chemical & Engineering News citation was made more specific, with its article title and author still to be confirmed.
- A zone-size claim was qualified: the specific regulatory documents for each country’s zone sizes were still to be compiled. A separate claim about a Zwijndrecht zone change was qualified with its own source still to be confirmed.
- An area-calculation claim was qualified as derived from mapped boundaries, with its methodology available on request.
- A computer-modelling claim was qualified as based on a review of publicly available documents as of February 2026; if such modelling exists in non-public documents, we said we were not aware of it.
- A claim that no cancer studies existed was qualified as based on a review of the ECHA database and the Environment Agency’s risk evaluation.
Site changes
- An editorial URL alias,
/what-they-dont-tell-you/, was removed from the Untold Story page;/the-untold-story/was kept for link stability. - Cancer-statistics caveats were reordered to appear before the figures, on the Health and Evidence pages, so limitations are seen first.
- A number of tags were already in place and were intentionally retained at the time, to show transparency about what was not yet known: AGC’s stated position on PFOS use and on PFOA manufacture, the specific EA document for the EEA-NH4 testing exclusion, and Guardian article specifics for the Megson method development. This is a historical note about that day; it is not a statement about what the live pages carry today.
- Other citations were added or made more specific: the 178-tonne figure gained a direct link to the Guardian’s article of 24 September 2024; the $671M DuPont settlement figure (Resources) gained a New York Times source link; EU Directive 2020/2184 gained a direct EUR-Lex link; and the 2009 PFOS restriction claim (Untold Story) gained a source link for the Stockholm Convention.
- Definitions were added throughout for units: ng/L explained as nanograms per litre, with the EU comparison; µg/kg explained as micrograms per kilogram; a unit guide box added to The Numbers. Technical terms were defined on first use: EEA-NH4 (“a fluorochemical used as a replacement for PFOA in manufacturing”), biomonitoring (“blood and urine testing to check for chemicals in the body”), reprotoxic (“suspected of harming fertility or unborn children”), non-targeted analysis (“a screening technique that looks for any chemicals present”), organofluorine (“a broader category of fluorine-containing compounds, including PFAS”), atmospheric deposition (“chemicals that settled from the air over decades”), precursor compounds (“chemicals that can change into PFOS in the environment”), ulcerative colitis (“a bowel disease”), pre-eclampsia (“a serious pregnancy condition involving high blood pressure”), environmental permits (“legal documents that set the rules for what a company can discharge”), and peer-reviewed (“studies independently checked by other scientists before publication”).
- The Health page was restructured with a plain-English summary box; long sentences were split throughout; passive constructions were reduced (for example “has been detected” to “testing found”, where appropriate); a context box was added to the European comparison table noting that different sites have different contamination pathways, so direct comparison may not be appropriate; and attribution language was clarified (“unattributed” to “source not identified”; consistent use of “open question”).
- The site was reframed as centred on the Hillhouse estate rather than on AGC specifically: contamination attributed to a specific operator via its own disclosures was distinguished from contamination detected but unattributed, and from gaps where no investigation has occurred. Historical context was added acknowledging the site’s multiple operators, including ICI (1950s to 1999) and AGC (1999 to date), and shared estate infrastructure; an attribution-methodology section was added to the Sources page; “AGC site” was changed to “Hillhouse industrial estate” where appropriate. PFOS in eggs was noted as an open question: AGC states it never used PFOS, and the source of the PFOS found remained unattributed.
- The whole site was rewritten in a factual, research-based tone: editorial language, rhetorical framing and advocacy messaging removed; every claim sourced or marked for citation; the action page restructured as an information and resources page. This was the site’s original relaunch, the foundation the later corrections and updates were made against.
The original wording of this changelog, exactly as it stood before this reorganisation, is kept in full at the changelog archive.