Hillylaid Pool: what the published measurements show

The Environment Agency has said sampling at Hillylaid Pool found 'a presence of historical PFAS'. Published measurements of that water already exist. This sets out what they show, what the study attributes them to, what is being done, and what is still unknown.

Primary sources used in this post:
  • Dalmijn J, Benskin JP, Salter ME, Sweetman AJ, Halsall CJ, Garnett J, Cousins IT. ‘Perfluoro(2-ethoxy-2-fluoroethoxy)-acetic Acid and Other Target and Suspect PFAS in the Vicinity of a Fluoropolymer Production Plant.’ Environmental Science and Technology, 18 July 2025, 59(29):15420-15431. DOI 10.1021/acs.est.5c07856. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC12312159/
  • Environment Agency statement and reporting in Blackpool Gazette, ‘Third Thornton site near ICI Hillhouse found contaminated with PFOA’, Claire Lark. Headline surfaced 2 August 2026; page carries the date 3 August 2026. Article archived locally.
  • Surface water investigation, Thornton-Cleveleys: summary. WSP for the Environment Agency, sampling September 2024 to January 2025, thirteen locations. Published by Wyre Council: https://www.wyre.gov.uk/downloads/file/2269/surface-water-investigation-thornton-cleveleys-summary
  • Environmental permit EPR/BU5453IY, classification of discharge point W2 as ‘Uncontaminated surface water and roof water from the Permitted Installation’.
  • Environmental Protection Act 1990, sections 78A(2) and 78YB.
  • Wyre Council, ‘Further allotment site recommended for contaminated land determination’, 3 July 2026: https://www.wyre.gov.uk/news/article/652/further-allotment-site-recommended-for-contaminated-land-determination

The Environment Agency has said that sampling at Hillylaid Pool, a body of surface water beside the former ICI Hillhouse works, “concluded that there was a presence of historical PFAS and other industrial type containments” [sic], and that “work is underway to understand the nature and extent of this contamination and the potential risks it may pose.”

Published measurements of that water already exist. This post sets out what they show, and what the study that produced them says about where the contamination came from.

What the words mean

PFAS are “a class of synthetic organic substances” (Cousins et al., 2020) used, among more than 200 use categories, in non-stick and water-repellent materials (Glüge et al., 2020). PFOA (perfluorooctanoic acid) is one of them. The International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC) classified it in Group 1, “carcinogenic to humans”, in November 2023, on the basis of sufficient evidence for cancer in experimental animals and strong mechanistic evidence in exposed humans; evidence for cancer in humans was limited (renal cell carcinoma and testicular cancer). That classification describes how strong the evidence is. It is not a statement about the level of risk at any particular exposure. EEA-NH4 is a fluorinated processing aid used in fluoropolymer manufacture (Dalmijn et al., 2025). AGC says EEA-NH4 replaced PFOA.

Concentrations are given in nanograms per litre (ng/L). For scale only, Directive (EU) 2020/2184 sets 100 ng/L for the sum of 20 specified PFAS in drinking water. That value applies to treated water at the tap. No drinking water is taken from Hillylaid Pool, and the comparison is a unit anchor rather than a safety threshold for this water body.

The February 2023 sampling

A research team led by Joost Dalmijn, with Ian Cousins as senior author, sampled water around the Hillhouse site on a single day. The paper states it plainly: “Duplicate water samples were taken during a single sampling day (12-02-2023)”. It was published in Environmental Science and Technology on 18 July 2025.

Sampling point Status Measured, 12 February 2023
W1, main discharge to the River Wyre Discharge point named in permit EPR/BU5453IY. Shared with Victrex PLC, which makes PEEK on the same estate Sum of detected PFAS 30 and 33 ng/L (two samples)
DBL, a discharge beside a lagoon north of the plant, together with a land drain and a leaking pipe nearby Not among the three discharge points (W1 to W3) named in the permit, as described by Dalmijn et al. The paper identifies the lagoon as a former ICI effluent pit PFOA 891 to 20,624 ng/L across the three
Hillylaid Pool, the tributary receiving discharge point W2 The permit lists W2 as a discharge point, classified as “uncontaminated surface water and roof water” EEA (the anion of EEA-NH4) 1,744 ng/L in the pool water

The paper is explicit about which point was cleanest, and it is the main discharge point W1:

“Remarkably, the main discharge point (W1) of the process water effluent had the lowest PFAS concentrations compared to all the other sampling points. At the main discharge, ΣPFAS concentrations were 30 ng/L (main discharge in Wyre 1) and 33 ng/L (main discharge in Wyre 2), while the other sampling points all had PFAS levels within the thousand to tens of thousands of ng/L.”

The highest readings were to the north:

“The highest PFAS concentrations were found to the north of the plant at a discharge near a lagoon (DBL) and at a land drain north of the lagoon (WLD) and a leaking part of a long discharge pipe (WLPD) leading to the River Wyre. PFOA was very prominent in these samples, with concentrations ranging from 891 ± 37 ng/L to 20,624 ± 556 ng/L.”

That range covers those three points together. The paper does not give a separate range for the lagoon discharge alone. It also records that PFOA at two of them was high enough to saturate the detector on the primary method and had to be requantified by direct injection.

This is one day’s sampling, in February 2023. It is a snapshot, not a description of how the site operates now.

What the paper says caused it

This is the part that has not been widely reported, and it matters more than any single figure.

“The high PFOA concentrations are likely attributable to the extensive use of APFO for PTFE production at the plant between 1955 and 2012 and unabated emissions of PFOA to the environment during this time. Therefore, it could be that a large reservoir of PFOA and substances related to its production still exists within the perimeter of the industrial site.”

And on why it is still turning up in surface water:

“Elevated PFAS concentrations at these locations could potentially be explained by re-emission from existing on-site PFAS reservoirs.”

So the peer-reviewed source does not attribute this to continued use. It offers, as a possibility, re-emission from “existing on-site PFAS reservoirs” from the period of use running from 1955 to 2012, and in the next sentence says “it is crucial to rule out the possibility that current production processes still involve either the use or the formation of significant quantities of PFOA and other PFAS”. Release from an old reservoir is still a release now: the paper’s point is about origin, not that nothing is being discharged.

That period covers two operators, and it is worth being precise about both. Imperial Chemical Industries ran the site until 1999. AGC Chemicals Europe has run it since 1999. AGC says it used PFOA there until 2012. AGC joined the US Environmental Protection Agency’s 2010/2015 PFOA Stewardship Programme and reported its own emissions under it: 237 kg of PFOA from its non-US plants in 2011, falling to 23.5 kg in 2012, the year it says it stopped using the chemical.

The published record does not break the total down by operator, so we do not know how the 1955 to 2012 releases divide between them, and we do not assert a split.

The paper identifies the lagoon at the highest-reading point as ICI’s:

“This lagoon was used as an effluent pit by Imperial Chemical Industries (ICI), the former operator of the PTFE production plant and was, unfortunately, not accessible during sampling. The high PFAS concentrations measured here indicate this lagoon should be the subject of further investigation.”

We do not claim PFOA is used as a processing aid at the site now. (Updated 1 October 2026: a written answer from Defra and the Environment Agency, dated 17 April 2026 and found on 28 September 2026, says “[a] small amount of PFOA is also generated through the current manufacturing process”, with a release to air that AGC puts at “a few tens of grams per year”. See the timeline.)

The Agency’s own later sampling

Between September 2024 and January 2025, WSP, working for the Environment Agency, sampled thirteen surface water locations. The published summary records that “PFOA was detected at all 13 sampling locations. The highest concentration (19.2 µg/l) was recorded at Hillylaid Pools.”

That is 19,200 ng/L, in the pool to which W2 discharges. PFOA was found at every location sampled, including points away from this discharge, so the pool sits in a wider affected area rather than at the end of a single identified pathway.

The permit classification of “uncontaminated surface water and roof water” applies to the discharge point W2, not to Hillylaid Pool itself. The 1,744 ng/L EEA figure above is a measurement of pool water. The paper reports no separate figure for the discharge point.

Monitoring at W2

Discharge point classifications and monitoring requirements are set by the Environment Agency in the permit it issues, not chosen by the operator. The permit classes W2 as “uncontaminated surface water and roof water” and sets no PFAS limit for it. We have found no record of PFAS monitoring at W2 before the Regulation 61 notice of 3 October 2023; we have not seen the permit history. We have not seen the Agency’s basis for the classification, or whether it has been reviewed.

AGC has also given a practical reason relating to W2. In a July 2023 presentation to the Environment Agency, the company is recorded as saying “not sure we have access to W2”. On a shared estate with multiple operators, an access difficulty is plausible. We hold this through a third-party compilation of Environmental Information Regulations material rather than from the primary record, and we have not yet obtained the primary document.

What is being done

The Environment Agency says work is underway to understand the nature and extent of the contamination, and that it will “continue to monitor the area for potential impacts on the wider environment and take appropriate regulatory action where necessary.”

AGC is carrying out voluntary environmental investigations at Hillylaid Pools and other locations, under Environment Agency oversight. The Agency’s own contractor records that it continues to engage with the company, that a voluntary inspection of the main site is under way, and that a site investigation was planned with reporting expected in early 2026.

So this is not a situation where nothing is happening. What is not yet clear is what statutory route is being taken, and on what timetable.

Contaminated land, and why the position here is different

Two allotment sites near the plant have been considered under Part 2A of the Environmental Protection Act 1990, the legal process for formally designating land as contaminated.

On 5 March 2026 Wyre Council said the Environment Agency had concluded that Occupation Road Allotments meets the statutory criteria. On 3 July 2026 Wyre Council reported that the Agency had presented conclusions that Sandringham Avenue Allotments meets the criteria to be determined as contaminated land. In both cases the Agency recommends and the local authority makes the determination. Wyre Council’s updates of 5 March and 3 July 2026 and its letter of 12 August 2026 report the Agency’s conclusions and subsequent legal steps; they do not record a formal determination of either site. Update, 23 October 2026: Wyre Council’s Full Council formally determined both sites as contaminated land on 22 October 2026 (dates and sources).

In both cases the route was soil where people grow and eat produce.

The Act is not limited to soil. Section 78A(2) covers land where “significant pollution of controlled waters is being caused or there is a significant possibility of such pollution being caused.”

But Part 2A is a backstop. Section 78YB restricts its use where the pollution is being, or can be, dealt with under the environmental permitting regime. The Hillhouse site is permitted, so that restriction may be a substantial part of the answer to why this route has not been taken. We do not know whether it has been considered and set aside, or not reached yet.

What is not confirmed in available documents

  • Whether Hillylaid Pool is “controlled waters” within the meaning of the Water Resources Act 1991. The Part 2A water limb depends on this and we have not established it.
  • Who is responsible for the DBL discharge and the other discharge points not named in the permit. The paper identifies the lagoon as the former ICI effluent pit but does not attribute the discharges themselves to any current operator. Hillhouse is a shared estate.
  • Whether the monitoring position at W2 has changed since. We have not seen current monitoring requirements for that point.
  • What the Environment Agency’s Regulation 61 Notice produced. The Agency served a notice under permit EPR/BU5453IY on 3 October 2023, requiring information on PFAS at the site: a third-party index of Environment Agency documents describes it as listing the PFAS testing the Agency requires, and Part 6 required historic information on PFOA releases. AGC responded on 20 December 2023 with what it calls a historic mass balance. The sources examined here are AGC’s covering letter and the third-party document index; neither reproduces the full notice.
  • When the Agency became aware of the February 2023 results, and what assessment followed between the paper’s publication in July 2025 and this statement. We make no suggestion that any party caused or contributed to that interval.
  • The July 2023 access statement reaches us through a third-party compilation rather than the primary record. We are seeking the primary document.
  • The date of the Agency’s statement. The Gazette page carries 3 August 2026; the headline appeared in feeds on 2 August.
  • The Gazette records the Agency’s wording as “containments”. We take this as a transcription of “contaminants”.

Context that cuts the other way

  • The peer-reviewed source offers, as a possibility, re-emission from “existing on-site PFAS reservoirs” left from use between 1955 and 2012, and in the same passage says it is “crucial to rule out” current use or formation of PFOA (see above). It does not attribute the readings to either.
  • The lagoon at the highest-reading point is identified in that source as ICI’s former effluent pit. ICI operated the site until 1999. This does not put AGC outside the period: it operated the site from 1999 and reported its own non-US PFOA emissions for 2011 and 2012.
  • AGC says its PFOA use ended in 2012. The Stockholm Convention requires parties to eliminate PFOA except where registered specific exemptions apply; the Defra and Environment Agency answer of 17 April 2026 says there is a specific exemption for the production and use of PFOA, its salts and PFOA-related compounds.
  • In UK law, Commission Delegated Regulation (EU) 2020/784 added PFOA, its salts and PFOA-related compounds to Annex I of the POPs Regulation; its Article 2 says “It shall apply from 4 July 2020.” The entry carries specified derogations and trace-contaminant limits (0.025 mg/kg for PFOA and its salts), and allows until 4 July 2023 the manufacture of PTFE and PVDF for specified membrane and sealant uses (legislation.gov.uk).
  • The main discharge point, W1, was the cleanest point sampled.
  • The Environment Agency, not the operator, sets permit classifications and monitoring requirements.
  • The Agency’s contractor found PFOA at all thirteen locations it sampled, including upstream points, and also recorded non-PFAS contaminants in the wider area. Hillylaid Pool has more than one possible contamination history.

The questions

Is Hillylaid Pool being addressed under the environmental permitting regime, and if so what does that require and by when?

To the Environment Agency: on what basis was discharge point W2 classified as uncontaminated surface water, and has that classification been reviewed in light of the measurements since?

Given that the paper identifies the lagoon as a former ICI effluent pit and recommends it “should be the subject of further investigation”, has that lagoon been investigated, and by whom?

What is the scope of the voluntary investigations at Hillylaid Pools, and will the results be published?

Corrected 11 October 2026: the date of the Environment Agency’s conclusion on Sandringham Avenue Allotments and the description of the Regulation 61 notice. See the changelog.

Corrected 18 October 2026: the “context that cuts the other way” list said the paper “attributes the high PFOA … not to current discharge”. The paper offers re-emission from on-site reservoirs as a possibility and says current use or formation must be ruled out, as the body of this post already stated; the list now matches it. See the changelog.