AGC's 'What are PFAS?' page, set against the record
AGC Chemicals Europe's public page 'What are PFAS?' (last modified 4 March 2026), quoted line by line beside the documents on the record: what its 96% figure measures, what it says and does not say about PFOA, the 2012 phase-out, 'full compliance', the estuary monitoring, and matters on the record that its text does not mention. Where the record agrees with the page, that is stated too.
- AGC Chemicals Europe, Ltd., ‘What are PFAS?’, page metadata ’last modified’ 4 March 2026; text captured 20 October 2026 (copy held by us, with the raw HTML): https://agcce.com/about-us/what-are-pfas/
- AGC Chemicals Europe, Ltd., ‘Site Investigation’, last modified 9 July 2026, captured 20 October 2026: https://agcce.com/about-us/site-investigation/
- AGC Chemicals Europe, Ltd., announcements of 13 July 2026 and 14 September 2026, captured 20 October 2026: https://agcce.com/agc-chemicals-europe-ltd-to-consult-with-staff-on-proposal-to-cease-production-at-hillhouse-thornton-cleveleys/ and https://agcce.com/announcement-from-agc-chemicals-europe-ltd-closure-of-agc-chemicals-europe-hillhouse-manufacturing-site-confirmed/
- Korzeniowski S.H. et al., ‘A critical review of the application of polymer of low concern regulatory criteria to fluoropolymers II: Fluoroplastics and fluoroelastomers’, Integrated Environmental Assessment and Management 2023;19(2):326-354, DOI 10.1002/ieam.4646 (abstract and author affiliations as recorded by the publisher through Crossref; the full text was not retrievable, see ‘What is not confirmed’)
- Henry B.J. et al., ‘A critical review of the application of polymer of low concern and regulatory criteria to fluoropolymers’, Integrated Environmental Assessment and Management 2018;14(3):316-334, DOI 10.1002/ieam.4035 (abstract and author affiliations via Crossref)
- American Chemistry Council, press release, 14 June 2022, on the 2022 paper: https://americanchemistry.com/chemistry-in-america/news-trends/press-release/2022/new-study-demonstrates-vast-majority-of-commercial-fluoropolymers-meet-criteria-for-polymers-of-low-concern-designation
- Lohmann R., Cousins I.T., DeWitt J.C., Glüge J., Goldenman G., Herzke D., Lindstrom A.B., Miller M.F., Ng C.A., Patton S., Scheringer M., Trier X., Wang Z., ‘Are fluoropolymers really of low concern for human and environmental health and separate from other PFAS?’, Environmental Science & Technology 2020;54:12820-12828, DOI 10.1021/acs.est.0c03244 (full text read through PubMed Central, PMC7700770)
- International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC), news release dated 1 December 2023, ‘IARC Monographs evaluate the carcinogenicity of perfluorooctanoic acid (PFOA) and perfluorooctanesulfonic acid (PFOS)’, Monographs meeting of 7 to 14 November 2023: https://www.iarc.who.int/news-events/iarc-monographs-evaluate-the-carcinogenicity-of-perfluorooctanoic-acid-pfoa-and-perfluorooctanesulfonic-acid-pfos/
- UK Parliament, Environmental Audit Committee, oral evidence, Addressing the risks from PFAS, HC 852, 10 September 2025, Questions 107, 126 and 133 (Stuart Ede, Head of Sustainability, AGC Chemicals Europe): https://committees.parliament.uk/oralevidence/16461/html
- Defra and the Environment Agency, written answer to residents’ questions, 17 April 2026, received by us through the office of the local MP. We hold no public web address for it; quotations are verbatim from our copy of the three-page document.
- AGC Chemicals Europe, Ltd., letter to the Environment Agency, 20 December 2023, Ref EPR/BU5453IY, Regulation 61 Notice, Part 6, as published by ToxicDocs: https://www.toxicdocs.org/d/M49R3qNN209xEE446jd9rq3my
- ENDS Report, Pippa Neill, 15 September 2025, quoting an AGC Chemicals Europe spokesperson: https://www.endsreport.com/article/1932433/revealed-ea-allowing-factory-produce-products-banned-pfas-%E2%80%93-release-air
- Environment Agency, Environmental risk evaluation report: perfluoro(2-ethoxy-2-fluoroethoxy)-acetic acid, ammonium salt (EEA-NH4), April 2023, as linked from AGC’s page (text read): https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/1146182/8._Environmental_risk_evaluation_report_Perfluoro_2-ethoxy-2-fluoroethoxy_-acetic_acid__ammonium_salt.pdf
- WSP for the Environment Agency and Wyre Council, Part 2A Phase 1 soil sampling, fieldwork 9 September to 4 October 2024, as recorded on our timeline (/timeline/); Environmental Protection Act 1990, Part 2A: https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1990/43/part/2A
- Stockholm Convention on Persistent Organic Pollutants, ninth Conference of the Parties, May 2019, listing of PFOA in Annex A, as recorded on our timeline (/timeline/)
- US Environmental Protection Agency, summary tables of company progress reports for the 2010/15 PFOA Stewardship Program, 2012 report and 2013 report, Table 2: https://www.epa.gov/sites/production/files/2016-05/documents/2012_pfoa_stewardship_summary_table.pdf and https://www.epa.gov/sites/production/files/2016-05/documents/2013_pfoa_stewardship_summary_table.pdf
- Asahi Glass Co., Ltd., letter to the Administrator of the US Environmental Protection Agency, 1 March 2006: https://www.epa.gov/sites/default/files/2015-05/documents/asahiresponse.pdf
AGC Chemicals Europe, Ltd. runs the fluoropolymer plant at Hillhouse, Thornton-Cleveleys. Its website carries a page headed “What are PFAS?”, which is the company’s public account of what PFAS are, what it makes, what it releases and how it manufactures.
This article goes through that page one claim at a time. Each claim is quoted word for word, then set beside what the public record says. For each one we state what the sentence covers and what it does not. We make no claim about why the page is written as it is.
Right of reply. We sent this article to AGC Chemicals Europe for comment on 21 October 2026, at the address it has used to correspond with us. We will publish any response alongside the article and update it when we receive one. Updated 18 November 2026: AGC’s email to us of 11 November 2026 thanks us for “your subsequent email of 21 October”, the email that sent it this article; it makes no comment on the article. The rest of that email replies to the separate questions we put to AGC in writing on 14 October 2026. It is published in full on AGC in its own words, and each question’s status is on our Questions page.
Terms. PFAS is a class of several thousand chemicals. PFOA is one chemical in it. EEA-NH4 is another PFAS; the Environment Agency’s published evaluation of it is linked from AGC’s page. Fluoropolymers such as PTFE are polymeric PFAS: very large molecules. Some ways of making them use smaller, non-polymeric PFAS as processing aids. Where a source speaks about one of these we do not report it as speaking about another.
How this was checked. We captured the page on 20 October 2026. AGC’s page metadata gives its last modification as 4 March 2026, and the wording we captured is identical, word for word, to an earlier text capture of the page held by this project. A page can change without its metadata changing, so every “before” and “after” below is relative to that metadata date. Where we say the page does not mention something, we mean its main article text, including the footnotes and the “Further Information” section, but not the site menu. We searched that text for “PFOA” (one appearance in the text, in a bullet point, and one inside the web address of footnote 8), “EEA-NH4” (one appearance, inside the title of a linked report), and “legacy”, “historic”, “contaminat”, “cancer”, “carcinogen”, “toxic”, “blood”, “Part 2A”, “Regulation 61”, “investigation”, “closure” and “cease” (no appearances). The page’s own words are quoted exactly; its footnote numbers are left out.
1. The 96% figure, and the chemicals that leave the plant
What the page says
“At our UK manufacturing facility, AGC Chemicals Europe, Ltd., we undertake a responsible manufacturing approach to produce the fluoropolymers PTFE and ETFE, which are polymeric PFAS. 96% of fluoropolymers display properties predictive of low hazard, which has been demonstrated by data in regulatory submissions and peer-reviewed literature.”
The two sources given for it are footnote 5 (Henry and colleagues, 2018) and footnote 6 (Korzeniowski and colleagues, 2022).
What those two sources are
Both are review papers in Integrated Environmental Assessment and Management. The publisher’s records, which we read through Crossref, list the authors’ affiliations.
- Henry et al. (2018), eight authors: the affiliations given include W. L. Gore & Associates (first author), The Chemours Company, Örebro University and Bergeson & Campbell (Washington DC).
- Korzeniowski et al. (2022, in the journal’s 2023 volume), sixteen authors: the affiliations given include AGC Chemicals Americas and AGC Performance Chemicals (Tokyo), The Chemours Company, Arkema, Daikin America, 3M, Gujarat Fluorochemicals, Solvay Specialty Polymers and BeachEdge Consulting.
The American Chemistry Council’s press release of 14 June 2022, about the second paper, says: “The American Chemistry Council’s Performance Fluoropolymer Partnership has published in an academic journal a brand new, peer-reviewed study”, and “PFP researchers analyzed an additional 14 fluoropolymers and fluoroelastomers”. Both author lists include authors affiliated with fluoropolymer producers, and the second includes authors affiliated with AGC Chemicals Americas and AGC Performance Chemicals. We have not been able to read either paper’s funding statement (see the end of this article), so we do not say who paid.
What the 96% is
The abstract of the 2022 paper says: “commercial fluoropolymers are available from the seven participating companies that meet the criteria to be considered PLC, which represent approximately 96% of the global commercial fluoropolymer market.” (“PLC” is polymer of low concern.) The American Chemistry Council’s release words the figure in more than one way: “96% of commercial fluoroplastics and fluoroelastomers on the global market meet internationally accepted criteria”, and the 18 fluoropolymers that meet them “represent 96% of the global market volume.” AGC’s sentence reads “96% of fluoropolymers display properties predictive of low hazard”. The abstract’s figure is a share of the global market.
What the page itself says about the classification, and what the criteria cover
The page says, in its next sentence: “While the OECD has not officially established a ‘Polymer of Low Concern’ classification, the industry has assessed fluoropolymers and data demonstrate their low hazard when compared against criteria used by a range of global regulatory scientists to assess the safety of polymers.” That is AGC’s statement of the classification’s status. The OECD is the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development. What the criteria cover is a separate matter. Lohmann and twelve co-authors (Environmental Science & Technology, 2020) wrote:
“The PLC concept is currently derived from the characteristics of substances and articles but does not cover problems occurring during production and disposal.”
and, in the paper’s abstract:
“Production of some fluoropolymers is intimately linked to the use and emissions of legacy and novel PFAS as polymer processing aids.”
The 2018 Henry paper’s own abstract describes its subject as the finished polymer: it says fluoropolymers have “negligible residual monomer and oligomer content and low to no leachables”. A statement about the finished product is not a statement about what is released while it is made.
Why this matters here. The questions raised locally and on this site concern PFOA and EEA-NH4, among other PFAS, and these are not the plastic. A later section of the page says the plant uses “a limited number of PFAS” in its process and that “some impurities are generated, and these include a small quantity of non-polymeric PFAS”. The 96% sentence does not apply to those.
The page lists the Environment Agency’s April 2023 evaluation of EEA-NH4 under “Further Information”, without describing its conclusions. In that report the Agency writes: “There are no environmental simulation data so a realistic half-life in relevant media cannot be established”, that “By analogy with other PFAS, EEA-NH4 is considered to be very persistent (vP)”, that “experimental data are available to indicate that bioconcentration in fish is likely to be low”, and that “EEA-NH4 is not acutely toxic to aquatic organisms, but it is self-classified for human health as Reprotoxic Category 2 by the UK supplier” (the Agency’s position; our summary is on Evidence). The page also links “AGC Chemicals Europe, Ltd. Response to Environment Agency Environmental Risk Evaluation Reports”, which we have not read for this article.
What the statement covers. The figure concerns the finished polymer, and the abstract gives it as a share of the market. The sections around it concern what is used and released in making the polymer. The record agrees that these are different things.
What would answer it. The hazard information AGC holds for each substance that leaves the site, and its sources.
2. “Some PFAS have potential negative health impacts”
What the page says
“Concerns have been raised about PFAS, in particular; … Some PFAS have potential negative health impacts.”
“However, PFAS is a very large group of chemicals and not all PFAS have the same properties and impacts.”
What the record says
Both sentences are statements about a class of thousands of chemicals. The page does not name PFOA’s classification by the International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC). IARC’s news release of 1 December 2023 says:
“PFOA is carcinogenic to humans (Group 1), on the basis of sufficient evidence for cancer in experimental animals and strong mechanistic evidence (for epigenetic alterations and immunosuppression) in exposed humans. There was also limited evidence for cancer in humans (renal cell carcinoma and testicular cancer) and …”
That is a statement of hazard, not of risk. IARC says so itself: “the classification does not indicate the level of cancer risk associated with exposure at different levels or in different scenarios.” Group 1 is IARC’s highest strength-of-evidence category.
AGC has addressed PFOA’s hazards elsewhere. In oral evidence to the Environmental Audit Committee on 10 September 2025 (Q107), Stuart Ede, AGC Chemicals Europe’s Head of Sustainability, said: “The fluoropolymers we manufacture are benign, inert, so do not pose a hazard. There is a key factor of PFAS that some other PFAS, particularly when we talk about PFOA and PFOS, do have hazards, as do other chemicals.”
What the statement covers. It states the general case. It does not name PFOA or state IARC’s classification of it.
What would answer it. The hazard information AGC holds for PFOA.
3. “Voluntary phase out of the use of PFOA … in 2012”
What the page says
“Voluntary phase out of the use of PFOA as an additive to the manufacturing process under a global US EPA Stewardship Agreement in 2012, before its inclusion in the Stockholm Convention.”
It is the only statement about PFOA in the page’s text.
What the record says
The sentence is about the use of PFOA “as an additive to the manufacturing process”. It does not address whether PFOA has been generated, released or present since. AGC has said, elsewhere, that it “does not manufacture or use PFOA” and “voluntarily phased out the use of this substance in 2012” (spokesperson, quoted by ENDS Report, 15 September 2025). The record on generation and release is as follows.
- Defra and the Environment Agency, written answer of 17 April 2026: “Information so far obtained by the Environment Agency through the contaminated land inspection (Part 2A) and a notice requesting information under the Environmental Permitting Regulations (Regulation 61) of current activities, show PFOA is being released from historic and current activities. Historic contamination of PFOA is currently the most likely source of PFOA to surface water.” And: “A small amount of PFOA is also generated through the current manufacturing process.” And: “AGC have provided information which shows a small release to air from their activities, amounting to a few tens of grams per year.” The last sentence does not name the substance, and appears in the answer to a question about PFOA. The quantity is AGC’s information as relayed by the Agency, not an Agency measurement, and it is for air. The answer says it “will be considered when the Environment Agency reviews the permit in the near future”.
- AGC, in the same ENDS article: “very limited amount of PFOA is inadvertently generated during the lubricant grade manufacturing process as a trace contaminant and a trace amount of impurity remains within the lubricant product.”
- AGC, to the Environmental Audit Committee, 10 September 2025 (Q133): “Currently, there are some legacy emissions of PFOA from the site, which the council and the Environment Agency are evaluating. Our treatment plant that we installed last year has been put in place to try to minimise that. We have seen a more than 90% reduction in the trace amounts of PFOA in our effluent from that process.”
Separately, AGC’s letter to the Environment Agency of 20 December 2023 carries the heading “Regulation 61 Notice - Part 6 - Historic information related to releases of Perfluorooctanoic acid (PFOA) from the site”, and says: “The approximate total mass release of PFOA to air, land, water and in products has been provided from first production (ICI period) on site to 03/10/2023.” By its own words it runs from first production to 03/10/2023, not only after 2012.
The page’s one sentence on PFOA mentions none of this, and the words “legacy” and “historic” do not appear in its text.
The 2012 date itself. The date is AGC’s own account, and this site attributes it to AGC (see Start here and the changelog). The record we hold is partial and mostly AGC’s own. The US Environmental Protection Agency’s published summary tables for the 2010/15 PFOA Stewardship Program list “Asahi” (Asahi Glass, now AGC Inc.) as reporting emissions of “PFOA, PFOA salts and Higher Homologues” to all media from non-US operations of 237 kg for 2011 and 23.5 kg for 2012. The tables name no plants. AGC’s 2006 letter to the same programme lists three fluoropolymer plants, at Chiba (Japan), Hillhouse (UK) and Bayonne (New Jersey), so the non-US figure may combine Hillhouse with Chiba; that is our reading, not the table’s. The figures are AGC’s own reports, not independent measurements, and they do not say when the use stopped at Hillhouse.
The Stockholm Convention. The convention listed PFOA at its ninth Conference of the Parties in May 2019, so 2012 comes before the listing (our timeline).
A second statement about what stays out of the product. The page says: “Both these PFAS impurities and the non-polymeric PFAS we use in our manufacturing processes are removed from the final product to meet our high quality requirements.” The ENDS quotation above says “a trace amount of impurity remains within the lubricant product”. Both are AGC’s. They may concern different products or different impurities, which we have not asked, and the page does not say whether PFOA is among the “PFAS impurities” it mentions.
What the statement covers. The sentence answers whether PFOA is still added to the process. It does not address whether PFOA is generated, released or present, and on the record those are different questions with different answers.
What would answer it. AGC’s figures, by year, for PFOA released to air, water and land and sent to landfill since 2012, and any measured results, published with the method used.
4. “In full compliance with UK and EU regulations”
What the page says
“The use of PFAS in our manufacturing and emissions are in accordance with our Responsible Manufacturing approach and in full compliance with UK and EU regulations.”
What the record says
The sentence does not say which regulations, for which period, or on whose assessment. The record on limits is in two separate statements with different scopes.
- Defra and the Environment Agency, 17 April 2026, about PFOA: “There are currently no statutory environmental limits for PFOA.” The same answer, replying to a separate question about EEA-NH4, says the Environment Agency served the Regulation 61 notice “to obtain additional information for the Environment Agency to assess risks and then determine whether the permit needed to be reviewed and if new conditions need to be added or existing conditions varied”. It also says the Agency “has now reviewed the available evidence and scientific data on PFOA and other PFAS” and that this evidence “will be considered as part of the ongoing permit review”. It mentions drinking-water guidelines and says they are “not applicable for a discharge to a river”.
- AGC to the Environmental Audit Committee, 10 September 2025 (Q126). The question, from Sammy Wilson MP, concerned whether there is a limit on the amount that can be disposed of, and did not name PFOA. The answer began: “What we are assessing is the impact of those emissions. Quite correctly, the permit does not state a limit. The permit requires us to follow best practice to provide environmental protection.” It continued: “We submit those reports to the Environment Agency to demonstrate why we believe what we are doing does not have that significant environmental impact.” In the same answer he said: “Through voluntary industry programmes, for example, we are committing to emissions reductions beyond regulatory requirements.”
The Agency’s April 2023 evaluation of EEA-NH4 (page 67) says of the permit: “The permit stipulates a requirement to monitor for EEA-NH4 in effluent entering the receiving environment, but does not set a numerical limit or require any specific control measures.”
A statement that regulations have been met does not state how much is released or whether it harms anyone. That is not a finding that anything is wrong. It is a statement of what the sentence can and cannot tell a reader. We have not seen the permit itself and do not assess it here. This article does not assess emissions other than PFAS, or limits on PFOA in products.
What the statement covers. A claim of compliance. It does not say what the applicable limits are, if any, or what has been released.
What would answer it. The permit conditions that apply to PFOA and EEA-NH4 at each discharge and emission point, and the Agency’s compliance assessments against them.
5. “Over 40 years … not having a significant effect”
What the page says
“Continuation of Ecological Monitoring of the River Wyre Estuary, providing a dataset which currently spans over 40 years . This concludes the Hillhouse industrial complex’s effluent discharge is not having a significant effect on the SPA (Special Protection Area), MCZ (Marine Conservation Zone), SSSI (Site of Special Scientific Interest) or other protected habitats or species within the Wyre estuary.”
What it says and does not say
The page calls the work “Ecological Monitoring”. Within its text it does not say what was measured, by whom, how often or who reached the conclusion. The sentence contains neither the word “PFAS” nor the word “PFOA”, and the page does not say whether any PFAS was ever measured in the water, sediment or animals of the estuary. We have not seen the dataset and cannot say whether it contains PFAS measurements. An ecological survey and a chemical analysis answer different questions, and the page does not say which kind of evidence lies behind the sentence beyond the two words “Ecological Monitoring”.
The sentence is about “the Hillhouse industrial complex’s effluent discharge”. The page does not say whether that means AGC’s discharge alone or also that of the other companies on the Hillhouse site. It concerns effects on named protected sites and species, not on people.
To assess this conclusion, a reader needs the criteria used to judge “a significant effect” and what would follow if one were found. For this ecological-monitoring conclusion, the page states neither: it does not say what level of any substance, or what change in habitats or species, would count as significant, or what action would follow. (The page does give numerical emission targets elsewhere, for air and water; those are not criteria for judging effects on the estuary.)
Separately, the Environment Agency’s April 2023 evaluation of EEA-NH4 reported that the site’s permit “stipulates a requirement to monitor for EEA-NH4 in effluent entering the receiving environment, but does not set a numerical limit or require any specific control measures” (section 4 above). The same evaluation goes on to describe the removal and control processes in use; the absence of a numerical limit in the permit is not the absence of controls.
What the statement covers. A conclusion about protected habitats and species, from a dataset whose length is given (over 40 years) and whose contents are not.
What would answer it. The monitoring reports: who commissioned them, what was sampled, which substances were analysed, whether PFOA or EEA-NH4 was among them, what levels or changes were treated as “a significant effect”, and whether any finding would have triggered action and, if so, what action.
6. Matters on the record, and statements within the page
The page’s metadata gives 4 March 2026 as its last modification, and the page says of its list of further information that “this section will be periodically updated”. The first three rows of the table are matters on the record, each dated; the last two rows are statements within the page itself. A short list of later events follows the table.
| Subject | In the page’s text | On the record |
|---|---|---|
| The investigation of historic contamination | The word “investigation” does not appear. | AGC to the Environmental Audit Committee, 10 September 2025, before the date in the page’s metadata (Q133): “we are working with the Environment Agency and the local council on a programme of investigation of legacy issues.” AGC publishes a separate page, “Site Investigation” (last modified 9 July 2026), and the markup of agcce.com’s menu links to it. The main text of the “What are PFAS?” page does not. |
| The Part 2A investigation | “Part 2A” does not appear. | Our timeline records that WSP carried out Phase 1 soil sampling from 9 September to 4 October 2024, instructed by the Environment Agency, which it describes as leading the Part 2A inspection on behalf of Wyre Council (timeline). The Defra and Environment Agency answer of 17 April 2026 refers to “the contaminated land inspection (Part 2A)”. Part 2A is the part of the Environmental Protection Act 1990 under which a council can determine land to be contaminated land. |
| Historic releases of PFOA | “Historic” and “legacy” do not appear. | AGC’s letter of 20 December 2023 to the Environment Agency, quoted in section 3. |
| The programme’s target dates | One passage says the voluntary programme “sets specific targets for all signatories to reach by the end of 2024, and the end of 2030”. Another says “by the end of next year, and the end of 2030”. | The page says the programme was “agreed by the above-mentioned European fluoropolymers manufacturers in September 2023”. “Next year” reads as 2024 if the passage was written in 2023, as 2025 if in 2024, and as 2027 if in 2026. The 2024 date in the other passage is consistent only with the first. |
| The water target | The page says the group’s members, “including AGC Chemicals Europe, Ltd., have successfully met the first reduction target”, and, for water, “while not all European fluoropolymers manufacturers have met the 2024 annual average emission factor for the emissions target of 0.001%, they all met that ambitious target at the end of 2024”. The target is described as one “for non-polymeric PFAS residues from polymerisation aid technology”. | The page does not say which manufacturers did not meet the 2024 annual average for water, or whether AGC Chemicals Europe did. The link to the industry group’s statement (“The FPG statement can be found here”) returned an HTTP 404 error to us on 20 October 2026. The address as printed on AGC’s page contains the spelling “manufcturing”. |
Events after the date in the page’s metadata: on 13 July 2026 AGC announced a proposal to cease operations at Hillhouse, giving as its reason that “the site has experienced significant financial and operational challenges, generating a loss for the past four years”, and on 14 September 2026 that “production is expected to cease by 31 December 2026” (AGC announcements). These events postdate the modification date in the page’s metadata, and we draw no connection between them and the page. We do not say the page was required to include any of the matters in this section.
What the statement covers. The page’s text contains none of the first three subjects, each of which was on the record at the date in its metadata.
What would answer it. A statement from AGC of whether the page is intended to be current and, if so, when it will next be reviewed.
7. How the page frames the product
Of the fluoropolymers made at the site, the page says they “cannot be replicated by other compounds, making them essential for critical applications across the UK, European and global markets that contribute to sustainability including, but not limited to, use in renewable and alternative energies, electric vehicles, and medical applications.” These are statements about what the products do. They are not statements about what the process releases.
A similar passage appears under a later heading, “Use of PFAS In the Manufacture of Fluoropolymers”. There the sentence follows “a limited number of PFAS are used to ensure the quality and performance of our final ETFE and PTFE products” and begins “These create unique properties which cannot be replicated by other compounds, making them essential for critical applications”.
“Essential use” is also a term in the research literature on PFAS. Lohmann and colleagues write: “Our recommendation is to move toward the use of fluoropolymers in closed-loop mass flows in the technosphere and in limited essential-use categories, unless manufacturers and users can eliminate PFAS emissions from all parts of the life cycle of fluoropolymers.” The page does not refer to that framework.
Where the record and the page are consistent
- The page separates the polymers from the non-polymeric PFAS used in making them, and says so.
- The page states that the OECD “has not officially established” a polymers-of-low-concern classification. That is AGC’s statement, and it is attributed to AGC here.
- The Stockholm listing of PFOA (May 2019) came after 2012.
- AGC’s reported emissions of “PFOA, PFOA salts and Higher Homologues” from its non-US operations fell sharply in 2012 in the EPA’s published tables (section 3).
- The page lists, among its “Further Information” links, the Environment Agency’s evaluation reports for the chemicals used at the site, including EEA-NH4.
- The page states that “not all European fluoropolymers manufacturers have met the 2024 annual average emission factor” for water.
- AGC told Parliament that PFOA and PFOS “do have hazards” (Q107), that there are “some legacy emissions of PFOA from the site” (Q133), and that its treatment plant achieved “more than 90% reduction in the trace amounts of PFOA in our effluent” (Q133).
What is not confirmed
- Who funded the two papers behind the 96% figure. Crossref and Unpaywall list both as open access, but the publisher’s server refused our automated requests (HTTP 403), so we did not read the funding or conflict-of-interest statements. We have the abstracts and author affiliations as the publisher records them.
- What the 40-year estuary dataset measures. We have not seen it, and the page does not say.
- Whether the page has changed since 4 March 2026. The metadata gives that date. Our capture of 20 October 2026 and the earlier one agree.
- The 2012 date. The records we examined for this are the EPA tables, AGC’s own statements and the documents listed in the sources. None dates the end of PFOA use at Hillhouse independently of AGC.
- The quantity of PFOA released now. “A few tens of grams per year” to air is AGC’s information as relayed by the Agency, in a sentence that does not name the substance. The 17 April answer supplies no Agency measurement and does not state a quantity for water.
- The permit. We have not seen the permit conditions for this article. “The permit does not state a limit” is AGC’s account to Parliament. “No statutory environmental limits for PFOA” is Defra’s and the Agency’s, in an answer we hold but for which we have no public web address.
- Quotations at second hand. The ENDS Report passages and AGC’s letter of 20 December 2023 are quoted as they appear on our page AGC in Its Own Words.
- Whether the page’s “emissions” and “compliance” wording is meant to cover anything beyond PFAS. The page does not say, and we have not assessed it.
- Why the page is written as it is. We make no claim about that.
What we will do
If AGC wants to correct or add to anything here, it can write to us through the contact form or at [email protected], and what it sends will be published alongside this article, in full unless that would be unlawful. If the page is revised, we will compare the new version with the capture of 20 October 2026 and note what changed.
The person who runs this site lives near the plant and is a client of Leigh Day, the law firm investigating a possible claim, and is the Case Owner of a CrowdJustice fund for expert work in that matter. The About page says: “He is a client of Leigh Day in its investigation of a possible claim. As a resident of the area under investigation, he could benefit financially if a claim succeeds.” It also says that Hillhouse Watch “receives no funding from, and has no commercial arrangement with, any law firm”.
This article reports what documents say and sets out what they do not say. It makes no finding of fault.